Pauls Ltd v Elkington & Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2001] QCA 389

COURT OF APPEAL

McPHERSON JA
WILLIAMS JA
JONES J

Appeal No 680 of 2001

PAULS LIMITED
(ACN 009 698 015)  Respondent/Applicant

and

MILLY ELKINGTON   Appellant/Respondent

and

THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL
OF THE COMMONWEALTH                  Respondent-by-Election

BRISBANE

..DATE 17/09/2001

JUDGMENT

McPHERSON JA:  This is an appeal from a judgment in the Supreme Court of Mr Justice Douglas given on 22 December 2000. 

The question that came before his Honour involved a consideration of a question whether the "compulsory takeover and acquisition" provisions of the Victorian Corporations Law were validly enacted.  His Honour decided that they were and an appeal was instituted against that decision by Notice of Appeal filed on 18 January 2001.  There were some further amendments to that Notice of Appeal on 2 March, but in the meantime the appellant's appeal in this Court was proceeding.

On 8 February 2001, the appellant's outline was filed, followed on 9 March by the respondent's outline.  The appellant's reply was lodged on or about 3 April 2001.  At the request of the appellant or of the parties, the Registrar of this Court on 25 June assigned a hearing date for the matter and the date so assigned was 17 September 2001 which, of course, is today.

In the meantime, a new Corporations Act had been passed by the Parliament of the Commonwealth and it came into force on 15 July this year. On 30 July, the written outline of the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth, who had elected to intervene in the matter, was filed. It raised or relied on the Corporations Act recently passed by the Commonwealth to which I have referred. What, in substance, the outline said was that the existing question which had been argued before Justice Douglas had become "moot" in the light of the fact that the legislative provisions were now to be found not in the Victorian Act, but in the new Corporations Act of the Commonwealth. That would, one would have thought, have meant either that the question previously before Justice Douglas should have been dealt with by dismissing the appeal or it would have been possible for the parties, if they had chosen to do so, to seek to bring the remaining matters, if any, before this Court.

Instead, the appellant has chosen a rather different course from that.  On Friday of last week, 14 September, my Associate received a phone call from a member of the firm that acts for the appellant in this case.  She advised that it was the intention of the parties that the matter now before us should be adjourned to the hearing of another appeal, No 3262/2001.  In other words the hearing today would be effectively vacated. 

That was greeted with some degree of protest on the part of the Registrar of this Court.  We were told by the appellant's solicitor that no further information could be supplied consistently with that informant's instructions.  Late on Friday we received a letter dated 14 September 2001, which informed us that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pauls Ltd v Elkington & Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QCA 389
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the validity of certain provisions in the Victorian Corporations Law, specifically the "compulsory takeover and acquisition" provisions. The appeal was brought by Milly Elkington against Pauls Limited and the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth. The primary issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland, which held that the aforementioned provisions were validly enacted, should stand. The appeal was filed on 18 January 2001 and amended on 2 March 2001. The Attorney-General elected to intervene in the case, arguing that the question before the Court had become moot due to the enactment of a new Corporations Act by the Commonwealth Parliament on 15 July 2001. However, the appellant, Milly Elkington, intended to challenge the validity of section 1384 of the new Act, which would render the original point moot if found invalid.

The Court of Appeal, comprising McPherson JA, Williams JA, and Jones J, was of the opinion that the Court should proceed to determine the constitutional validity of the provisions at hand, regardless of whether it might ultimately be rendered moot. The Court reasoned that if the provisions were found to be valid, the issue would indeed be moot. However, if section 1384 of the new Corporations Act were found to be invalid, it would be necessary to revisit the correctness of the Supreme Court's decision. The Court was prepared to hear and determine this matter, as it was in the Court's position to do so. The Court also considered that the parties had already submitted written outlines in relation to the hearing, and it would be more appropriate to proceed with the determination at that stage. All three judges agreed that the appeal should not be adjourned and the issue should be decided by the Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.