Paul Smith & Mary Smith v John Orr

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

Local Court of New South Wales


CITATION: Paul Smith & Mary Smith v John Orr [2007] NSWLC 16
JURISDICTION: Civil
PARTIES: Paul & Mary Smith
John Orr
FILE NUMBER: 80657/06
PLACE OF HEARING: Downing Centre Local Court
DATE OF DECISION:
06/15/2007
MAGISTRATE: Magistrate H Dillon
CATCHWORDS: Negligence – Building works – Whether works defective – Whether plaintiff mitigated damages – Building & Construction - Contracts – Whether defendant breached implied terms – Whether work carried out in workmanlike manner – Whether materials supplied fit for purpose – Whether works carried out with due diligence in a reasonable time
LEGISLATION CITED:
CASES CITED: Evans v Balog [1976] 1 NSWLR 36
Hyder Consulting (Aust) Pty Ltd v Wilh Wilhemsen Agency Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 313
Makita v Sprowles [2001] NSWCA 305
Rich v ASIC [2005] NSWCA 233
Sydneywide Distributors Pty Ltd v Red Bull Australia Ltd [2002] FCAFC 157
REPRESENTATION:

Ms E. Kennedy (Counsel for Plaintiff)
Mills Oakley Lawyers (Solicitors for Plaintiff)

Mr J. Orsborn (Counsel for Defendant)
Carroll & O’Dea (Solicitors for Defendant)
ORDERS: 1. In relation to their claim, verdict for the plaintiffs in the sum of $19,406.; 2. In relation to the cross-claim, verdict for the cross-claimant in the sum of $7351.90; 3. Judgment for the plaintiffs in the sum of $12,054.10 plus interest to be assessed by the Registrar from 23 January 2001.; 4. I reserve the question of costs

Judgment


1. The plaintiffs, Mr Paul Smith and Mrs Mary Smith, own a house in Lake Cargelligo, which was built in part by the defendant, Mr John Orr. They allege that some of the work done on the house was defective and other parts were left incomplete. In their statement of claim they list 29 specific defects. They assert that Mr Orr was negligent in the way he or his agents carried out the work and they assert that he breached various terms implied in his contract with them. They claim damages which they assert amount to about $38,000.

2. The claim includes the costs of rectification ($32,318); the costs of a removalist ($3300); the costs of alternative accommodation for two weeks ($638); and the cost of insuring household contents during the removal ($900).

3. Mr Orr admitted some of the allegations and denied others. In some cases he asserts that the works were incomplete rather than defective. He brings a cross-claim against the Smiths in the sum of $7351.90. He asserts, that if he is in any way liable to the Smiths, they failed adequately to mitigate their losses and incurred unreasonable costs in completing or rectifying the works he had begun.

Background

4. In 1999, the Smiths bought their property in Lake Cargelligo, a small town in western NSW about 550 kilometres from Sydney. In early 2000, they asked Mr Orr for a quotation to build a four-bedroom brick veneer house on the property. He did so. The Smiths accepted the quotation for $179,000. In April 2000, they signed a construction contract with Mr Orr. By…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paul Smith & Mary Smith v John Orr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWLC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Paul and Mary Smith, commenced proceedings against the defendant, John Orr, regarding alleged negligent building works carried out on their property. The dispute came before the court, which had to determine whether the works were defective, whether the plaintiffs had mitigated their damages, and if the defendant had breached any implied terms. The plaintiffs argued that the defendant had failed to carry out the works in a workmanlike manner and that the materials supplied were not fit for purpose. They further contended that the works were not completed with due diligence and within a reasonable time. The defendant denied any negligence and argued that any defects were due to the plaintiffs' own actions or external factors beyond his control.

The court had to decide whether the defendant breached the implied terms of the contract by not performing the works with reasonable care and skill, and if the materials supplied were of an appropriate quality. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the plaintiffs took reasonable steps to mitigate their damages. The court examined the evidence and considered expert opinions on the quality of the workmanship and the suitability of the materials used. The court also evaluated whether the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in attempting to address the defects and whether the defendant had met his obligations under the contract.

The court found in favour of the plaintiffs on their claim, determining that the works were indeed defective and that the defendant had breached the implied terms of the contract. The court held that the materials supplied were not fit for purpose and that the works were not completed in a workmanlike manner or within a reasonable time. However, the court found that the plaintiffs had not fully mitigated their damages. Consequently, the court awarded the plaintiffs a verdict of $19,406. In relation to the cross-claim, the court found in favour of the defendant, awarding him $7,351.90. The court ordered that judgment be entered for the plaintiffs in the sum of $12,054.10 plus interest to be assessed by the Registrar from 23 January 2001. The court reserved the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to their claim, verdict for the plaintiffs in the sum of $19,406.; 2. In relation to the cross-claim, verdict for the cross-claimant in the sum of $7351.90; 3. Judgment for the plaintiffs in the sum of $12,054.10 plus interest to be assessed by the Registrar from 23 January 2001.; 4. I reserve the question of costs Judgment

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established