Paul Melis and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

[2014] AATA 58

Division General Administrative Division

File Number

2013/3681

Re

Paul Melis

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop

Date 6 February 2014
Place Perth

The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction in respect of the application for review lodged by the applicant with the Tribunal on 29 July 2013.

............................[sgd]...................................

S D Hotop

Deputy President

  1. On 29 July 2013 Paul Melis (“the applicant”) lodged with the Tribunal a completed Application for Review of Decision form, together with a letter from a Reconsideration Officer of Australian Postal Corporation (“the respondent”), dated 18 July 2013, notifying him of a decision which was expressed to have been made under s 62 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”). The contents of that letter are set out in paragraph 21 below.

  2. Following receipt by the Tribunal, on 20 November 2013, of correspondence from the respondent’s solicitors enclosing a copy of a document headed “WRITTEN SUBMISSION WITH RESPECT TO THE QUESTION OF JURISDICTION FOR THE PURPORTED REVIEW OF A PURPORTED AUTHORISED DETERMINATION” prepared by counsel, the Tribunal held a directions hearing on 27 November 2013.  At that directions hearing the Tribunal expressed the view that it was appropriate that the jurisdictional issue which had arisen in this proceeding be determined “on the papers” without holding a hearing, and the parties consented to that course.

  3. Accordingly, on 27 November 2013 the Tribunal made directions for the filing and serving of written submissions by the parties, and thereafter for the jurisdictional issue to be determined “on the papers” without holding a hearing.

    The Evidence

  4. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T22, pp 1–56) lodged on behalf of the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“AAT Act”), and supplementary documents (ST1–ST4, pp 1–23) lodged on behalf of the respondent on 17 January 2014.

    The Factual Background

  5. The following relevant background facts are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the abovementioned T Documents and supplementary documents.

  6. On 8 July 1994 the applicant claimed compensation under the SRC Act for an injury described as “ligament tear, lower back and hip (right side)”. (T4)

  7. On 2 August 1994 an officer of the respondent made a determination accepting liability under the SRC Act to pay compensation to the applicant for an injury described as “soft tissue injury (R) hip” suffered on 6 July 1994. (T5)

  8. On 7 April 1995 an officer of the respondent made a determination whereby the description of the injury, in respect of which liability had been accepted on 2 August 1994, was amended to “right L4/5 disc herniation” (ST2).  That description of the compensable injury was itself subsequently amended, by determination dated 20 May 2010, to “right L4/5 disc herniation resulting in major depression” (ST4).

  9. By letter dated 24 January 2013 an officer of the respondent notified the applicant that, pursuant to s 57 of the SRC Act, he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paul Melis and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involved Paul Melis, the applicant, and the Australian Postal Corporation, the respondent. The dispute arose from the respondent's acceptance of liability to pay compensation to the applicant for an injury sustained in 1994. The respondent required the applicant to undergo a medical examination in 2013, which he failed to do. Consequently, the respondent determined that the applicant had failed to undergo the examination without reasonable excuse and suspended his rights to compensation. The applicant sought reconsideration of this determination, but the respondent affirmed it. The applicant then applied to the Tribunal for a review of this reviewable decision. The central legal issues were whether the respondent had the power to reconsider the initial determination and make a reviewable decision, and whether the applicant was authorised by the relevant enactment to request reconsideration and to make an application to the Tribunal for review of the reviewable decision.

The Tribunal found that the respondent did not have the power to reconsider the initial determination and make a reviewable decision as it was not authorised by the relevant enactment. Furthermore, the applicant was not authorised by the enactment to request reconsideration or to make an application to the Tribunal for review of the reviewable decision. The Tribunal concluded that it did not have jurisdiction to review the respondent's reviewable decision because the application was not made in accordance with the relevant enactment. The decision of the Tribunal was based on the interpretation of statutory provisions and the understanding that the Tribunal only has jurisdiction to review decisions that are authorised by the relevant enactment.

In conclusion, the Tribunal determined that it did not have jurisdiction to review the respondent's decision. The decision of the respondent affirming the initial determination was not a validly made decision under the relevant section of the enactment, and the applicant was not authorised to request reconsideration or to make an application to the Tribunal for review. Therefore, the Tribunal dismissed the applicant's application for review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T22, pp 1–56) lodged on behalf of the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“AAT Act”), and supplementary documents (ST1–ST4, pp 1–23) lodged on behalf of the respondent on 17 January 2014.The Factual Background The following relevant background facts are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the abovementioned T Documents and supplementary documents. On 8 July 1994 the applicant claimed compensation under the SRC Act for an injury described as “ligament tear, lower back and hip (right side)”. (T4) On 2 August 1994 an officer of the respondent made a determination accepting liability under the SRC Act to pay compensation to the applicant for an injury described as “soft tissue injury (R) hip” suffered on 6 July 1994. (T5) On 7 April 1995 an officer of the respondent made a determination whereby the description of the injury, in respect of which liability had been accepted on 2 August 1994, was amended to “right L4/5 disc herniation” (ST2). That description of the compensable injury was itself subsequently amended, by determination dated 20 May 2010, to “right L4/5 disc herniation resulting in major depression” (ST4). By letter dated 24 January 2013 an officer of the respondent notified the applicant that, pursuant to s 57 of the SRC Act, he had arranged for the applicant to undergo a medical examination by Mr Michael Alexeeff, Orthopaedic Surgeon, at a specified location on 24 April 2013. (T6) The applicant signed an Appointment Acknowledgement Form, dated 21 February 2013, whereby he confirmed that he would be attending the abovementioned medical appointment. (T8) By letter dated 23 April 2013 an officer of the respondent informed the applicant that she had received a telephone call from Mr Alexeeff’s rooms advising that the applicant had cancelled the abovementioned appointment with Mr Alexeeff because of ill health, and requested the applicant to provide, within 14 days, medical evidence substantiating his incapacity to attend that appointment. (T9) By letter dated 16 May 2013 to the applicant, an officer of the respondent noted that they had not received a response to the abovementioned letter of 23 April 2013, and notified the applicant that, pursuant to s 57 of the SRC Act, a further arrangement had been made for him to undergo a medical examination by Mr Alexeeff on “Wednesday [sic] 24th June 2013 at 11.00 am”. (T10) The applicant signed an Appointment Acknowledgement Form, dated 18 May 2013, whereby he confirmed that he would be attending the abovementioned medical appointment. He added, however, that, although he wished to attend that appointment, he could not guarantee that he would be well on the day of the appointment. (T11) A file note, dated 20 June 2013, by an officer of the respondent records that he had received a telephone call from the applicant advising that he had been “throwing up” and would not be able to attend the appointment with Mr Alexeeff on 24 June 2013. (T12)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, on 27 November 2013 the Tribunal made directions for the filing and serving of written submissions by the parties, and thereafter for the jurisdictional issue to be determined “on the papers” without holding a hearing.The Evidence The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T22, pp 1–56) lodged on behalf of the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“AAT Act”), and supplementary documents (ST1–ST4, pp 1–23) lodged on behalf of the respondent on 17 January 2014.The Factual Background The following relevant background facts are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the abovementioned T Documents and supplementary documents. On 8 July 1994 the applicant claimed compensation under the SRC Act for an injury described as “ligament tear, lower back and hip (right side)”. (T4) On 2 August 1994 an officer of the respondent made a determination accepting liability under the SRC Act to pay compensation to the applicant for an injury described as “soft tissue injury (R) hip” suffered on 6 July 1994. (T5) On 7 April 1995 an officer of the respondent made a determination whereby the description of the injury, in respect of which liability had been accepted on 2 August 1994, was amended to “right L4/5 disc herniation” (ST2). That description of the compensable injury was itself subsequently amended, by determination dated 20 May 2010, to “right L4/5 disc herniation resulting in major depression” (ST4). By letter dated 24 January 2013 an officer of the respondent notified the applicant that, pursuant to s 57 of the SRC Act, he had arranged for the applicant to undergo a medical examination by Mr Michael Alexeeff, Orthopaedic Surgeon, at a specified location on 24 April 2013. (T6) The applicant signed an Appointment Acknowledgement Form, dated 21 February 2013, whereby he confirmed that he would be attending the abovementioned medical appointment. (T8) By letter dated 23 April 2013 an officer of the respondent informed the applicant that she had received a telephone call from Mr Alexeeff’s rooms advising that the applicant had cancelled the abovementioned appointment with Mr Alexeeff because of ill health, and requested the applicant to provide, within 14 days, medical evidence substantiating his incapacity to attend that appointment. (T9) By letter dated 16 May 2013 to the applicant, an officer of the respondent noted that they had not received a response to the abovementioned letter of 23 April 2013, and notified the applicant that, pursuant to s 57 of the SRC Act, a further arrangement had been made for him to undergo a medical examination by Mr Alexeeff on “Wednesday [sic] 24th June 2013 at 11.00 am”. (T10) The applicant signed an Appointment Acknowledgement Form, dated 18 May 2013, whereby he confirmed that he would be attending the abovementioned medical appointment. He added, however, that, although he wished to attend that appointment, he could not guarantee that he would be well on the day of the appointment. (T11)

Decision

Reasons for decision

It necessarily follows that the decision of the Reconsideration Officer, dated 18 July 2013, affirming the abovementioned determination, although expressly purporting to be made under s 62 of the SRC Act, was not authorised by that section. Accordingly, that decision is not a decision that was validly made under s 62 of the SRC Act.Does the Tribunal have jurisdiction to review the decision of 18 July 2013? Section 25(1) of the AAT Act relevantly provides:“ An enactment may provide that applications may be made to the Tribunal … for review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by that enactment.”Section 25(4) of the AAT Act provides:“ The Tribunal has power to review any decision in respect of which application is made to it under any enactment.” Section 64(1) of the SRC Act relevantly provides:“ Application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of a reviewable decision may be made by:(a) the claimant; or…”The phrase “reviewable decision” is defined in s 60(1) of the SRC Act to mean (relevantly):“ a decision made under … section 62”. In the present case an application has been made by the applicant to the Tribunal for review of the decision of 18 July 2013. Although the decision of 18 July 2013 was purportedly made in exercise of the power conferred by s 62 of the SRC Act, that decision (for the reasons explained in paragraphs 33–35 above) was not authorised by s 62 and, accordingly, was not validly made in exercise of the power conferred by that section. That conclusion, however, does not, of itself, necessarily lead to the result that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the decision of 18 July 2013. In Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd (1979) 24 ALR 307 a majority of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia held that the phrase “decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by that enactment” in s 25(1) of the AAT Act includes, not only a decision which has validly been made in the exercise of power conferred by the relevant enactment, but also a decision which has in fact been made in the purported exercise of power conferred by the relevant enactment, although not validly made. Likewise, the phrase “reviewable decision” in s 64(1) of the SRC Act includes, not only a decision which has validly been made under s 62 of that Act, but also a decision which has in fact been made in the purported exercise of the power conferred by s 62, although not validly made under s 62: see Secretary, Department of Social Security v Alvaro (1994) 50 FCR 213 at 218–219; Woodbridge v Comcare (1994) 20 AAR 196 at 207–209. Accordingly, the decision of 18 July 2013 constitutes a decision in respect of which, pursuant to s 25(1) of the AAT Act, an enactment may provide that application may be made to the Tribunal for review. That decision, furthermore, constitutes a “reviewable decision” in respect of which s 64(1) of the SRC Act provides that application may be made to the Tribunal for review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.