Patton v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
DETERMINATION OF MERIT REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Patton v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPICMRP 3
CLAIMANT: Jason Patton
INSURER: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited
MERIT REVIEW PANEL MEMBERS:

Elizabeth Medland

Hugh Macken

Terrence Stern

DATE OF DECISION: 11 August 2023
CATCHWORDS: 

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; Merit Review Panel review of a single Merit Reviewer regarding a determination in respect of the amount of statutory benefits payable as weekly payments under Division 3.3; specifically, the calculation of the claimant’s pre-injury average weekly earnings (PAWE); complex financial situation involving business structures including discretionary trust; dispute as to what should be considered as earnings; whether distributions to trust beneficiaries other than the claimant should be included in calculation of PAWE; dispute as to whether superannuation and leave entitlements should be included in PAWE; Held – original certificate issued by single merit reviewer is affirmed.

DETERMINATIONS MADE: 

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

Issued under s 7.15(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

1.     In relation to the merit review decision by a single Merit Reviewer, the Merit Review Panel confirms the decision/certificate (M10539825/22) of the single Merit Reviewer dated
21 December 2022.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. There is a dispute between Jason Patton (the claimant) and Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (the insurer) about statutory benefits payable as weekly payments under Division 3.3 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 (MAI Act).

  2. The claimant was injured in a motor accident on 11 December 2020 and subsequently lodged an application for statutory benefits on the insurer.

  3. There have been two separate disputes lodged with the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) by the claimant in respect of the amount of weekly statutory benefits he is entitled to.  A determination (M10509282/22) was issued by Merit Reviewer Ruschen on


    26 July 2022 which directed that the claimant provide further information and the insurer to re-determine the claimant’s pre accident weekly earnings (PAWE). 

  4. On 30 August 2022 the insurer re-determined the claimant’s PAWE as nil.   An internal review decision of the insurer dated 30 August 2022 affirmed the original decision.

  5. Thereafter, the claimant lodged a further application for merit review with the Commission.  The application was allocated to Merit Reviewer Ruschen for determination.  In a determination dated 21 December 2022 (M10539825/22), Merit Reviewer Ruschen set aside the reviewable decision and certified the claimant’s PAWE to be $1,080.62.

  6. The claimant applied to the Commission for a review panel to reconsider the merit review.

  7. The President’s delegate decided there was reasonable cause to suspect an error in the Merit Reviewer’s decision.

  8. The Commission's President constituted a Review Panel (the Panel) to review the Merit Reviewer's decision.

REVIEW CONDUCT

  1. The Merit Review Panel (the Panel) met on 3 March 2023.  It was noted that the insurer’s representative had lodged further written submissions shortly prior, and as such it was determined that the claimant be provided with further opportunity to address the content of such submissions. 

  2. The claimant provided further written submissions.

  3. The Panel met again on 20 April 2023.

DOCUMENTATION

  1. As…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patton v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMRP 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Patton v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited involves a dispute over the amount of statutory benefits payable as weekly payments under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act). The claimant, Patton, is contesting the determination made by a single Merit Reviewer regarding the calculation of his pre-injury average weekly earnings (PAWE). The primary issues at hand are whether distributions to trust beneficiaries other than the claimant and superannuation and leave entitlements should be included in the calculation of PAWE.

The court had to decide whether certain distributions to the trust beneficiaries and superannuation and leave entitlements should be included in the calculation of the claimant's PAWE. The claimant argued that all income generated by the trust should be considered in the calculation, including distributions to family members and superannuation and leave entitlements. The court examined the statutory provisions and the interpretation of the term "received by the earner" in Schedule 1, clause 4(1) of the MAI Act. The Panel held that the term "received by the earner" should be interpreted literally, meaning that only the distributions actually received by the claimant should be considered.

The court affirmed the original certificate issued by the single Merit Reviewer, finding that the claimant's argument that all income generated by the trust should be considered in the calculation of PAWE was not supported by the wording of the MAI Act. The court also found that superannuation and leave entitlements are not to be taken into account for the purposes of calculating PAWE. The Panel concluded that the Merit Reviewer's findings were correct and that there was no error in the reasons provided.

The final orders of the court affirmed the original certificate issued by the single Merit Reviewer, confirming that the claimant's pre-injury average weekly earnings were correctly calculated without including the distributions to other trust beneficiaries and superannuation and leave entitlements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Having considered the evidence, submissions and the reviewable decision, the Panel is in agreement with the findings of Merit Reviewer Ruschen in that cl 4(2)(1) applies. Specifically, the Panel agrees that cl 4(2)(a1) only applies with there were no earnings in the 12 months immediately before the day of the accident (being the period 11 December 2019 to 10 December 2020). The claimant clearly obtained earnings from the trust company as set out in the documentation and accordingly cl 4(2)(a1) does not apply. Neither party specifically address the Merit Reviewer’s findings in respect of superannuation and leave entitlements. In essence, it was found that such amounts are not to be taken into account for the purposes of calculating PAWE. The Panel has considered Merit Reviewer’s reasons in this regard, and adopts same. The Panel finds that superannuation payments and leave entitlements are not to be taken into account for the purposes of calculating PAWE. The Panel has considered the findings of Merit Reviewer Ruschen from paragraph 55 as to the calculation of the PAWE, in the context of all material provided. The Panel finds no error in the reasons of the Merit Reviewer and accordingly adopts same. Whilst the claimant suggests that the PAWE should be calculated on the basis of the whole of the income generated by the trust, the Panel does not accept that this is a proper interpretation of the legislation. The claimant appears to suggest that Schedule 1 should not be interpreted in a ‘prescriptive’ way and rather the objects of the Act should be read prescriptively and effectively the wording of the Schedule should be put to the side. The Panel has confirmed the Merit Reviewer’s findings that Schedule 1, cl 4(1) of the MAI Act applies to the meaning of PAWE. Such subclause provides that the PAWE includes the gross earnings “received by the earner”. The claimant suggests that the “received by the earner” should be construed to include the distributions to family members, as well as distributions to him. The claimant refers to the case of Husher in making such submission. The case of Husher did not involve the application of a statutory benefits scheme, which is the case in this dispute. The calculation of PAWE is to be carried out in accordance with the wording contained within Schedule 1 of the MAI Act. Whilst the claimant may well have a reasonable basis upon which to rely on such case in any claim for damages that he may have, given the wording of Schedule 1(4)(1) the Panel does not accept the claimant’s argument that all income derived by the trust should be utilised in the calculation of PAWE. In this regard, the Panel considers the words “received by the earner” to mean exactly that. That is, the distributions that have been received by the claimant. The Panel finds that the words “received by the earner” are not synonymous with “earned,” even if it were accepted that the claimant generated more income for the trust than what was distributed to him.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established