Patrick v The State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

PATRICK v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2025] SASCA 108

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice Bleby and the Honourable Justice Stanley)

25 September 2025

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - STATUTORY APPEALS FROM ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES TO COURTS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - FREEDOM OF INFORMATION - REVIEW OF DECISIONS - OTHER STATES AND TERRITORIES

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - FREEDOM OF INFORMATION - EXEMPT DOCUMENTS - CABINET AND EXECUTIVE COUNCIL DOCUMENTS

Appeal against a decision of the President of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘Tribunal’), affirming a decision of the Ombudsman to refuse access to documents pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act 1991 (SA) (‘FOI Act’).

The applicant sought documents relating to the Northern Water Supply Project from the Department of the Premier and Cabinet (‘Department’) under the FOI Act. The Department identified 18 documents in response to the application. The Department determined that the documents were exempt from release under cl 1(1)(a) and cl 1(1)(e) of the FOI Act on the grounds that they were prepared specifically for submission to Cabinet and/or would disclose information concerning deliberations or decisions of Cabinet.

The applicant sought an internal review by the Department and then an external review by the Ombudsman. Both affirmed the Department’s decision in substance. The applicant then sought review of the Ombudsman’s decision by the Tribunal. This appeal concerns the Tribunal’s order affirming the Ombudsman’s decision, in relation to documents 6, 14 and 15.

The grounds of appeal complain that the President erred in finding Documents 6, 14 and 15 to be exempt from disclosure on the basis that:

1.Document 15, as an attachment to a document submitted to a Cabinet taskforce meeting, had been specifically prepared for submission to Cabinet, pursuant to cl 1(1)(a);

2.Document 15 contained matter that would, if disclosed, disclose information concerning a deliberation or decision of Cabinet in the sense in which that expression is used in cl 1(1)(e);

3.Document 6, as an attachment to a document submitted to a Cabinet taskforce meeting, had been specifically prepared for submission to Cabinet, pursuant to cl 1(1)(a);

4.Document 6 contained matter that would, if disclosed, disclose information concerning a deliberation or decision of Cabinet in the sense in which that expression is used in cl 1(1)(e); and

5.Document 14 contained matter that would, if disclosed, disclose information concerning a deliberation or decision of Cabinet in the sense in which that expression is used in cl 1(1)(e).

Held (by the Court), dismissing the appeal:

1.The word ‘concerning’ in cl 1(1)(e) of the FOI Act extends the reach of the exemption beyond documents the disclosure of which would disclose the actual deliberations or decisions of Cabinet.

2.Documents disclosing information that is the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations may be exempt if it is identifiable as the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations.

3.Identification may be made on the face of the document or by reference to publicly available extrinsic information which, when…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patrick v The State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia regarding an application made under the Freedom of Information Act 1991 (SA) for access to documents related to the Northern Water Supply Project. The applicant sought various ministerial briefings and correspondence concerning a desalination plant for Port Lincoln, as well as substantive reports generated by Infrastructure SA. The Department of Premier and Cabinet identified 18 documents responsive to the request, but claimed some were exempt from disclosure.

The primary legal issues before the Court were the proper construction of clause 1(1)(e) of Schedule 1 of the Freedom of Information Act 1991 (SA), which exempts documents "concerning any deliberation or decision of Cabinet," and the application of this clause, along with clause 1(1)(a), to the specific documents in contention. The Court was required to determine the scope of the exemption and whether the documents, or information within them, qualified as being "concerning any deliberation or decision of Cabinet."

The Court applied established principles of statutory construction, emphasising that interpretation must begin and end with the statutory text, considered in its context. It found that the word "concerning" in clause 1(1)(e) extended the exemption beyond documents that directly disclosed Cabinet deliberations or decisions. Information that informed Cabinet deliberations was capable of being covered by the exemption, provided it could be identified as the subject matter of those deliberations. This identification could be made from the face of the document or from publicly available extrinsic information. The Court also considered the Infrastructure SA Assurance Framework as relevant context for characterising the documents.

The Court concluded that while the choice of the word "concerning" broadened the exemption, the mere submission of a document to Cabinet was insufficient to render its contents exempt. The information had to be identifiable as the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations. The Court then proceeded to apply this construction to the remaining documents in contention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal raises issues of construction of cl 1(1)(e) and the application of that clause, and of cl 1(1)(a), to the three documents. Background On 8 June 2023, the applicant, jointly with Eyre Peninsula Seafoods, applied to the Department of Premier and Cabinet (‘the FOI request’) pursuant s 13 of the FOI Act requesting documents relating to:1.Any ministerial briefings received by the Department of Premier and Cabinet (either for the Department or the Premier) since 21 March 2022 that relate to a Desalination plant to meet Port Lincoln’s immediate water needs. 2.Any correspondence received from or sent to the Minister for Climate, Environment and Water since 21 March 2022 that relate to a Desalination plant to meet Port Lincoln’s immediate water needs.3.Any substantive reports/briefs generated by Infrastructure SA in relation to the Northern Water Supply Project. …Date range - 21/03/2022 to 08/06/2023 The documents sought by the applicant in these categories relate to the Northern Water Supply Project (‘the Project’). The Department indicated that it held 18 documents answering the request. The Project involves planning for the construction and operation of desalination infrastructure, water transfer pipelines and ancillary infrastructure for the supply of water to a range of consumers from the Eyre Peninsula to the Upper Spencer Gulf. The Project includes a proposal for a desalination plant to service the City of Port Lincoln. Infrastructure SA is a statutory agency and the lead agency in relation to the Project. Section 5(1) of the Infrastructure SA Act 2018 (SA) provides that the objects of Infrastructure SA include: (a) to promote such efficient, effective and timely coordination, planning, prioritisation, delivery and operation of infrastructure as is necessary for the economic, social or environmental benefit of the State; and (b) to promote the adoption and use of policies, practices, information and analysis to support sound decision-making in relation to infrastructure. The Infrastructure SA Assurance Framework (‘Assurance Framework’) is a publicly available document. This assumed some significance on the appeal as providing relevant context for the characterisation of the documents. The Assurance Framework articulates Infrastructure SA’s function of reviewing, analysing and providing advice on a continuing basis to ensure Cabinet can make informed decisions relating to large major projects. In this capacity, Infrastructure SA provided analysis, recommendations and advice to Cabinet and its committees through the progression of the Project. The documents relate to planning and proposals before the making of final decisions by Cabinet in regard to the Project. Documents 1-8, 10 and 15‑18 are Cabinet Submissions or Cabinet Notes and their attachments. They were considered at identified meetings of Cabinet or one of its committees or taskforces. The documents relevant to this appeal may be described as follows:Document 6: Strategic Case for Water Supply Document 14: ISA-02-06 NWSP Desalination Plant Relocation to Cape Hardy – R1- Final, Attachment to Document 9Document 15: Report – Northern Water Business Case

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

We accept that this history shows a deliberate choice to prefer the New South Wales drafting over the Commonwealth and Victorian drafting. We are not persuaded that it goes any further. The parties did not point to any extrinsic material capable of supporting an inference that, for example, Parliament was reacting positively or negatively to the approach of the courts throughout the 1980s. The respondent submitted that Parliament’s choice should be given effect by construing cl 1(1)(e) according to its natural meaning. We would go no further than to say that there is nothing in the history leant on by both parties to suggest that the word ‘concerning’ should be accorded anything other than its natural meaning.Conclusions on the construction question The necessary exercise of construction of cl 1(1)(e) in this case is ultimately directed to resolving the application of the clause to certain documents. In contrast to the approach of the parties below, the Court is not faced with glaringly contrasting contentions of construction that it has been asked to resolve. Rather, the ‘construction’ question requires the Court to explain its approach to applying the exemption in its terms. In the present case, this amounts to an explanation of the scope of application of the exemption in cl 1(1)(e) at a level of abstraction that is descriptively sufficient to resolve the questions of application of the exemption to the documents in question. Having regard to that need, for the reasons appearing above, we reach the following conclusions, on the construction of cl 1(1)(e):·the choice of the word ‘concerning’ extends the reach of the exemption beyond documents the disclosure of which would disclose the actual deliberations or decisions of Cabinet;·information that is the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations in the sense that it has informed those deliberations is capable of being ‘information concerning any deliberation or decision of Cabinet’;·however, the mere fact that a document was submitted to Cabinet is insufficient to qualify the information within it as the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations;·rather, to meet the terms of the exemption, the information disclosed by the document must be identifiable as the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations; and·an identification may be made from the face of the document containing the information. However, it may also be made from publicly available, extrinsic information that, when read together with the document, reveals the material to be the subject matter of Cabinet deliberations. We turn to the application of the clause, so construed, to the documents that remain in contention.Whether the documents are exempt It is first necessary to consider various publicly available documents that the respondent incorporated into its submissions. The first of these is the Assurance Framework, discussed earlier. The Assurance Framework announces its purpose as follows:PurposeInfrastructure SA [ISA] has been established under the Infrastructure SA Act 2018 [the Act] to improve infrastructure planning, prioritisation, operation and implementation.The Act creates a requirement for ISA to:·review and evaluate proposals for major infrastructure projects by public sector agencies·assess the risks involved in planning, funding, delivering and managing infrastructure, and the management of those risks, and·monitor the delivery of major infrastructure projects and other infrastructure projects identified in strategies, statements or plans adopted by the Minister [Premier] and any other infrastructure project at the request of the Minister.The Infrastructure SA Assurance Framework [ISAAF] fulfills these roles. It outlines the approaches, requirements and tools to aid this function and deliver benefits for South Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 3A sets out the principles relevant to the administration of the Act, which are to assist in its construction:3A—Principles of administration(1) It is the intention of the Parliament—(a) that this Act should be interpreted and applied so as to further the objects of this Act; and(b) that a person or body exercising an administrative discretion conferred by this Act exercise the discretion, as far as possible, in a way that favours the disclosure of information of a kind that can be disclosed without infringing the right to privacy of individuals.(2) Agencies are to give effect to this Act in a way that—(a) assists members of the public and Members of Parliament to exercise rights given by this Act; and(b) ensures that applications under this Act are dealt with promptly and efficiently. Section 12 provides that a person has a legally enforceable right to be given access to an agency’s documents in accordance with the Act. Section 13 sets out requirements of an application to access an agency’s documents. Section 19 requires that on receiving an application for access to documents, an agency is to determine whether to grant access to the documents sought, or to refuse access. Section 20 provides that the agency may withhold a document if it is an exempt document. Schedule 1 of the Act sets out the categories of documents which are exempt from disclosure. As discussed earlier, this appeal primarily concerns the interpretation and application of cll 1(1)(a) and 1(1)(e) of Schedule 1, set out earlier.The appealThe construction of cl 1(1)(e) The first question for determination relates to the proper construction of cl 1(1)(e) and, in particular, of the phrase, ‘information concerning any deliberation or decision of Cabinet’. This is, primarily, a question of scope. It became apparent during the course of argument that there was little, if anything, between the parties on the question of construction. The respondent submitted, and it may be the case, that the applicant’s submissions on construction had changed from those made before the Tribunal. In any event, it is necessary for this Court to indicate its view of the scope of the exemption in order to explain its conclusions on the application of the exemptions to the remaining documents in contention. The general principles governing statutory construction are well established. Section 14 of the Legislation Interpretation Act 2021 (SA) provides that the interpretation that best achieves the purpose or object of the act is to be preferred against any other interpretation. In Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd, the High Court said:[11]This Court has stated on many occasions that the task of statutory construction must begin with a consideration of the [statutory] text. So must the task of statutory construction end. The statutory text must be considered in its context. That context includes legislative history and extrinsic materials. Understanding context has utility if, and in so far as, it assists in fixing the meaning of the statutory text. Legislative history and extrinsic materials cannot displace the meaning of the statutory text. Nor is their examination an end in itself. (Footnote omitted)[11] (2012) 250 CLR 503 at [39].