Parnaby v Director of Housing

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S ECI 2020 02971

ROSE INGRID PARNABY Plaintiff
v 
DIRECTOR OF HOUSING & ORS Defendant

---

JUDGE:

O’Meara J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

27 July 2021

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

9 August 2021

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Parnaby v Director of Housing

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2021] VSC 456

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW — Judicial Review — Determination of Medical Panel — Whether the Panel made errors of fact alleged to constitute jurisdictional error — Whether failure of Panel to ‘properly’ assess and determine the plaintiff’s injuries and apply the AMA Guides – Craig v South Australia (1990) 184 CLR 163 – Chang v Neill (2019) 62 VR 174— Proceeding dismissed.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff GJ Burns Simon Parsons & Co
For the First Defendant FC Spencer HWL Ebsworth
For the Second & Third Defendants No appearance

HIS HONOUR:

A        Background

  1. On 4 July 2017 the plaintiff claims to have slipped on ‘sludge’ on a footpath leading to the carpark at 31 Maryvale Crescent, Morwell.  She landed on her knees and suffered a fracture of the medial malleolus of the right ankle which was later treated surgically. 

  1. The plaintiff claims to have suffered injuries including fracture to the right ankle, rupture of the Achilles tendon, soft tissue injuries to the ankle and foot, injuries to both knees, aggravation and exacerbation of pre-existing osteoarthritis and anxiety and depression.

  1. By reason of Part VBA of the Wrongs Act 1958 (‘the Act’), the plaintiff may not recover non-economic loss for damages unless her claimed injuries are assessed and determined to be a ‘significant injury’ for the purposes of the Act.

  1. On about 18 December 2019, the plaintiff served various documents pursuant to s 28LT of the Act, including a certificate of assessment signed by Dr James Rowe, occupational physician.

  1. Dr Rowe had examined the plaintiff and reported on 29 November 2018.  Dr Rowe certified that he was satisfied that the degree of impairment resulting from the plaintiff’s injury was more than 5%.  The certificate described the injury briefly as ‘fractured lateral malleolus in the right ankle and damaged right Achilles tendon’.

  1. In respect of the Achilles tendon, the plaintiff had pre-existing tendonitis, but had undergone surgery in July 2019 (after she saw Dr Rowe).  After that, it seems that her Achilles symptoms were ‘much the same’ as before the incident in July 2017.[1]

    [1]Joint Court Book (‘JCB’) 74.

  1. The first defendant referred the assessment of the plaintiff’s injuries to a Medical Panel. 

  1. On 11 May 2020, the plaintiff attended the Panel comprised of the second defendant, Dr David Kotzman, occupational and environmental physician, and the third defendant, Dr Jennifer Harmer, rheumatologist. 

  1. By certificate dated 20 May 2020, the Panel determined that the degree of whole person impairment alleged in the claim did not satisfy the threshold level. 

  1. The certificate of the Panel was accompanied by the Panel’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Parnaby v Director of Housing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSC 456
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Parnaby, the plaintiff, brought a case against the Director of Housing, the defendant, to seek judicial review of a decision made by a medical panel. The plaintiff contested the panel’s assessment of their injuries, claiming the panel failed to properly assess and determine their injuries and did not apply the AMA Guides. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff sought to challenge the decision of the medical panel, arguing that the panel made errors of fact that amounted to a jurisdictional error, and that the panel failed to properly assess and determine their injuries and apply the AMA Guides. The case hinged on whether the medical panel's decision was legally sound and whether the panel had correctly applied the AMA Guides.

The court considered whether the medical panel had made errors of fact that constituted a jurisdictional error and whether the panel had properly assessed and determined the plaintiff's injuries and applied the AMA Guides. The court noted that the plaintiff's argument centred on the panel's failure to properly assess and determine their injuries and apply the AMA Guides. The court held that the medical panel's decision was not affected by jurisdictional error and that the panel had properly assessed and determined the plaintiff's injuries and applied the AMA Guides. The court found that the medical panel's decision was within its lawful powers and that the plaintiff's argument was without merit.

As a result, the court dismissed the plaintiff's proceeding. The court found that the medical panel's decision was legally sound and that the panel had properly assessed and determined the plaintiff's injuries and applied the AMA Guides. The court held that the proceeding was without merit and dismissed it accordingly. The court did not make any orders as the proceeding was dismissed.