[2016] FWCFB 1199
DECISION
| Fair Work Act 2009 |
| s.604 - Appeal of decisions |
| Parmalat Food Products Pty Ltd |
| v |
| Christopher Tran |
| (C2015/6098) |
| VICE PRESIDENT WATSON |
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT HAMILTON |
MELBOURNE, 29 MARCH 2016
COMMISSIONER JOHNS
Appeal against decision [2015] FWC 5535 of Deputy President Lawrence at Sydney on 27
August 2015 in matter number U2015/4581 – Nature of factor regarding valid reason –
Requirement to give weight and make findings about each of the factors – Fair Work Act, ss.
387, 394, 400, 604 and 607.
Introduction
1
| [1] | On 6 November 2015 we issued a decision | in which we granted permission to appeal. |
We issued directions for further submissions on whether or not the appeal should be granted
and if so what remedy if any should be granted by the Full Bench pursuant to s.607 of the
Act. Written submissions were filed in accordance with the directions and the matter was
heard on 23 February 2016.
Consideration
[2] The task of the Commission in this matter is to determine whether the termination is
harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The Commission is required to apply the terms of s.387 of the
Act in considering that question. Section 387 states that:
“387 Criteria for considering harshness etc.
In considering whether it is satisfied that a dismissal was harsh, unjust or
unreasonable, the FWC must take into account:
(a) whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the person’s capacity or conduct (including its effect on the safety and welfare of other
employees); and
(b) whether the person was notified of that reason; and
[2016] FWCFB 1199
(c) whether the person was given an opportunity to respond to any reason related to the capacity or conduct of the person; and
(d) any unreasonable refusal by the employer to allow the person to have a support person present to assist at any discussions relating to dismissal; and
(e) if the dismissal related to unsatisfactory performance by the person— whether the person had been warned about that unsatisfactory performance
before the dismissal; and
(f) the degree to which the size of the employer’s enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal; and
(g) the degree to which the absence of dedicated human resource management specialists or expertise in the enterprise would be likely to impact on the
procedures followed in effecting the dismissal; and
(h) any other matters that the FWC considers relevant.”
[3] Subsection 387(a) refers to whether or not there is a valid reason related to the
dismissed employee’s capacity or conduct. This, on its face, could be a relatively unimportant
valid reason, or one which is of much greater importance. The subsection does not require the
Commission to find that the valid reason is serious, or sufficiently serious to justify a warning
or dismissal. This interpretation is consistent with the discussion of the term ‘valid reason’ by
2
| Northrop J in Selvachandran v Petron Plastics Pty Ltd | , in relation to the then s.170DE… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Parmalat Food Products Pty Ltd v Tran and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FWCFB 1199
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Full Bench found that the Commission had erred by conflating the requirement to make a finding as to whether there was a valid reason for termination with the requirement to determine if the termination was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. The Full Bench held that the Commission was required to make a finding about the existence of a valid reason independently, and then give due weight to this finding along with other factors when making its overall assessment. The Full Bench noted that the evidence, as found by the Commission itself, supported a finding that there was a valid reason for dismissal due to the breach of safety policies. The Full Bench concluded that the Commission's failure to separately assess the existence of a valid reason, and its subsequent distortion of the overall fairness assessment, amounted to an error of law. Consequently, the Full Bench allowed the appeal, quashed the original decision, and remitted the matter to a Commissioner for further determination.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi