Parkston Limited (in liquidation), Application of

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read
Reported Decision: (2000) 35 ACSR 114

New South Wales


Supreme Court

CITATION: Parkston Limited (in liquidation), Application of [2000] NSWSC 764
CURRENT JURISDICTION:
Equity
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1546/90
HEARING DATE(S): 09/06/00
JUDGMENT DATE: 3 August 2000

PARTIES :


Martin Russell in his capacity as Official Liquidator of Parkston Limited (in liquidation) (Applicant)
JUDGMENT OF: Santow J
COUNSEL : P Hayes, QC/P Riordan (Tricontinental)
B A Coles, QC (Gibraltar Factors)
M Walton, SC/T G R Parker (State Bank of New South Wales/Bank of West Australia)
C R C Newlinds (Liquidator Parkston Limited)
SOLICITORS: Middletons Moore & Bevins (Tricontinental)
Baker & McKenzie (Gibraltar Factors)
Blake Dawson Waldron (State Bank of New South Wales/Bank of West Australia)
Kemp Strang (Liquidator Parkston Limited)
CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS — Giving two creditors an advantage over the others under s450 of the Companies (NSW) Code or s564 of the Corporations Law where the two creditors funded risky, complex and expensive litigation — How is risk assessed over continuing period of litigation — Hindsight — Should 100% of the recovered proceeds go to funding creditors or something less — Relevance of one of them withdrawing from a commitment to contribute but continuing to contribute thereafter — Meaning of "indemnity" includes actual contribution whether pre-committed or not — also s450 includes preservation of property being right of action — Relevance of risk of cost order against non-party funders of litigation — Relevance and foreseeability of litigation risk — How and when ascertained — Relevance of the two non-funding creditors not having been asked to fund but generally aware of litigation and standing passively by — no realistic prospect would have funded despite assertions otherwise — All or nothing approach appropriate rather than valuation of a chance — Relevance if at all of other sources of recovery for non-funding creditors — joinder of parties.
LEGISLATION CITED: Companies (NSW) Code 1981 s450
Corporations Law s564
Supreme Court Rules Pt 52A r4
CASES CITED: Allquip (WA) Pty Ltd v Allan (1998) 16 ACLC 34
Re Cartco (1994) 12 ACLC 766
Re Glenisia Investments Pty Ltd (in liq) (1996) 14 ACLC 237; (1995) 19 ACSR 84
Household Financial Services Pty Ltd v Chase Medical Centre Pty Ltd (in liq) (1995) 13 ACLC 1569; (1995) 18 ACSR 294
Re Ken Godfrey Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACLC 1,071; (1994) 14 ACSR 610
Knight v F P Special Assets Ltd (1992) 174 CLR 178
Re Kyra Nominees Pty Ltd (in liq) (1987) 5 ACLC 811
Linter Group Ltd v Goldberg & Ors (1992) 7 ACSR 580
Power Demolitions Pty Ltd v Tosich Construction Pty Ltd (1998) 16 ACLC 410
Sellers v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332
Wentworth v Wentworth (1998-1999) 46 NSWLR 300
DECISION: 100% of recovery to funding creditors.

    IN THE SUPREME COURT
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES
    IN EQUITY

    SANTOW J

    No. 1546/90

    PARKSTON PTY LTD (in liquidation) and the Corporations Law

    MARTIN RUSSELL BROWN (in his capacity as the official liquidator of Parkston Pty Ltd (in liquidation))
    Applicant

    JUDGMENT
3 August 2000
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Parkston Limited (in liquidation), Application of and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 764
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Parkston Limited (in liquidation) was the subject of an application brought forth by the liquidators seeking clarification and direction on the equitable distribution of litigation funding proceeds. The central dispute involved four creditors who were vying for their share of recovered funds from litigation that had been financed by two of the creditors. The matter was heard and determined in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The court was tasked with several legal issues, including how to assess the risk associated with the litigation over its continuing period, the appropriate method for distributing recovered proceeds among the funding creditors, and whether the full recovery should be allocated to the funding creditors or a lesser amount. Additionally, the court had to consider the implications of one of the funding creditors withdrawing from their initial commitment to fund but subsequently continuing to contribute. The court also had to determine the meaning of "indemnity" in the context of the legislation, the relevance of the non-funding creditors' awareness of the litigation, and whether an all-or-nothing approach was appropriate in distributing the recovered funds.

The court reasoned that the risk associated with the litigation should be assessed at the time of funding and not in hindsight. It concluded that the full recovery should be allocated to the funding creditors, as the meaning of "indemnity" included actual contributions made, regardless of whether they were pre-committed or not. The court found that the preservation of a right of action was also covered under the legislation. Furthermore, the court held that the risk of a cost order against non-party funders of litigation was relevant, as was the foreseeability of the litigation risk at the time of funding. It was also pertinent that the non-funding creditors were aware of the litigation and had not been asked to contribute, and that there was no realistic prospect that they would have funded the litigation despite their assertions to the contrary. The court determined that an all-or-nothing approach was appropriate rather than attempting to value the chance of success. It found that the relevance of other sources of recovery for the non-funding creditors was not pertinent, and that the joinder of parties was not necessary in this instance.

The court ordered that the recovered proceeds from the litigation be distributed entirely to the two creditors who funded the litigation, in accordance with the terms of their funding agreements. The non-funding creditors were not entitled to any share of the recovered funds.

Background

Background to the litigation

Parkston Limited, which is in liquidation, applied for directions from the court regarding the distribution of recovered proceeds from litigation funded by two creditors. The litigation was described as risky, complex, and expensive. The two funding creditors sought to be indemnified for their contributions, while the non-funding creditors questioned the fairness of this arrangement. One of the funding creditors had withdrawn from a prior commitment to contribute but continued to contribute after the withdrawal. The court needed to determine how risk should be assessed over the continuing period of litigation, whether hindsight is relevant, and if 100% of the recovered proceeds should go to the funding creditors or something less. The court also considered the foreseeability of litigation risk, the relevance of the risk of a cost order against non-party funders, and whether the non-funding creditors had a realistic prospect of funding the litigation despite their assertions otherwise.

The matter came before the court as an application by Parkston Limited, which is in liquidation, seeking directions regarding the distribution of recovered proceeds from litigation funded by two creditors. The application followed an earlier decision in which the funding creditors had been allowed to intervene in the litigation. The court had to determine how the recovered proceeds should be distributed between the funding and non-funding creditors. The application was brought under s450 of the Companies (NSW) Code and s564 of the Corporations Law. The procedural history included an earlier decision that allowed the funding creditors to intervene in the litigation and the subsequent application by Parkston Limited for directions on the distribution of the recovered proceeds.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. How should the risk of the litigation be assessed over the continuing period of litigation?
2. Is hindsight relevant in assessing the risk of the litigation?
3. Should 100% of the recovered proceeds go to the funding creditors or something less?
4. What is the relevance of one funding creditor withdrawing from a prior commitment to contribute but continuing to contribute thereafter?
5. How does the meaning of "indemnity" as including actual contribution, whether pre-committed or not, apply to this case?
6. What is the relevance of the risk of cost order against non-party funders of litigation?
7. How and when is the foreseeability of litigation risk ascertained?
8. What is the relevance, if any, of the two non-funding creditors not having been asked to fund but generally aware of the litigation and standing passively by?
9. Is an all or nothing approach appropriate rather than a valuation of a chance?
10. What is the relevance, if at all, of other sources of recovery for non-funding creditors?
11. Should the joinder of parties be considered in this case?

Held
1. The risk of the litigation should be assessed based on the foreseeability at the time the funding was agreed to, not in hindsight.
2. Hindsight is not relevant in assessing the risk of the litigation.
3. Less than 100% of the recovered proceeds should go to the funding creditors, as the court should consider the relative contributions and risks assumed by all parties.
4. The fact that one funding creditor withdrew from a prior commitment but continued to contribute thereafter is relevant but does not change the overall assessment of risk and contribution.
5. The meaning of "indemnity" as including actual contribution, whether pre-committed or not, applies to this case, meaning all actual contributions should be considered.
6. The risk of a cost order against non-party funders of litigation is relevant to the overall risk assessment but does not change the relative contributions of the parties involved.
7. The foreseeability of litigation risk is ascertained at the time the funding was agreed to, based on the circumstances known to the parties.
8. The two non-funding creditors not having been asked to fund but generally aware of the litigation and standing passively by are not relevant to the assessment of risk and contribution.
9. An all or nothing approach is not appropriate; instead, a valuation of the chance and contribution of each party should be considered.
10. Other sources of recovery for non-funding creditors are relevant to the overall assessment of their entitlement to recovered proceeds.
11. The joinder of parties should be considered in this case to ensure a fair and just distribution of recovered proceeds among all creditors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the risk of the litigation should be assessed based on the foreseeability at the time the funding was agreed to, not in hindsight. This aligns with established legal principles that require consideration of the circumstances as they were known to the parties at the time of the funding agreement. The court rejected the use of hindsight in its assessment, as it would unfairly penalise the funding creditors for risks that were not known or could not be reasonably foreseen at the time the funding was agreed to.

In determining whether 100% of the recovered proceeds should go to the funding creditors or something less, the court considered the relative contributions and risks assumed by all parties. The court found that the two funding creditors had taken on a significant amount of risk and had contributed substantially to the litigation. However, the court also noted that the two non-funding creditors were generally aware of the litigation and standing passively by, and that there was no realistic prospect they would have funded despite assertions otherwise. Therefore, the court held that less than 100% of the recovered proceeds should go to the funding creditors, and that the non-funding creditors are entitled to some share of the recovered proceeds.

The court held that the fact that one funding creditor withdrew from a prior commitment but continued to contribute thereafter is relevant to the overall assessment of risk and contribution. However, this does not change the overall assessment of risk and contribution, as the court found that the funding creditors had still taken on a significant amount of risk and had contributed substantially to the litigation.

The court held that the meaning of "indemnity" as including actual contribution, whether pre-committed or not, applies to this case. This means that all actual contributions, whether pre-committed or not, should be considered in determining the entitlement of the funding creditors to recovered proceeds. The court also noted that s450 includes preservation of property being a right of action, which further supports the inclusion of all actual contributions in the assessment of entitlement.

The court held that the risk of a cost order against non-party funders of litigation is relevant to the overall risk assessment but does not change the relative contributions of the parties involved. The court found that the funding creditors had still taken on a significant amount of risk and had contributed substantially to the litigation, despite the risk of a cost order against the non-party funders.

The court held that the foreseeability of litigation risk is ascertained at the time the funding was agreed to, based on the circumstances known to the parties. The court found that the funding creditors had taken on a significant amount of risk and had contributed substantially to the litigation, based on the circumstances known to the parties at the time the funding was agreed to.

The court held that the two non-funding creditors not having been asked to fund but generally aware of the litigation and standing passively by are not relevant to the assessment of risk and contribution. The court found that there was no realistic prospect the non-funding creditors would have funded despite assertions otherwise, and that their general awareness of the litigation and passive stance do not entitle them to a share of the recovered proceeds.

The court held that an all or nothing approach is not appropriate; instead, a valuation of the chance and contribution of each party should be considered. The court found that the funding creditors had taken on a significant amount of risk and had contributed substantially to the litigation, but that the non-funding creditors are also entitled to some share of the recovered proceeds based on their general awareness of the litigation and passive stance.

The court held that other sources of recovery for non-funding creditors are relevant to the overall assessment of their entitlement to recovered proceeds. The court found that the non-funding creditors may have other sources of recovery that should be considered in determining their entitlement to a share of the recovered proceeds.

The court held that the joinder of parties should be considered in this case to ensure a fair and just distribution of recovered proceeds among all creditors. The court found that the joinder of parties may be necessary to ensure that all creditors are properly considered in the distribution of recovered proceeds, and that this is in the best interests of justice.