Parkin v Alliance Airlines Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Parkin v Alliance Airlines Pty Limited [2023] FCA 386

File number(s): SAD 73 of 2022
Judgment of: O'SULLIVAN J
Date of judgment: 2 May 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE –application for leave to file an amended statement of claim and amended originating application – where pleading does not disclose a reasonable cause of action – leave refused – applicant to be given further opportunity to file amended statement of claim
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 342, 351

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 16.21(1)

Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth), s 170DE

Public Service Act 1922 (Cth), s 56(a)

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), ss 7, 9

Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld), ss 8, 9(1)(h), 17(c), 20, 25, 58, 59

Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), ss 19, 47

Cases cited:

Agar v Hyde [2000] HCA 41; (2000) 201 CLR 552

Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & NZ Banking Group Ltd [1994] FCA 636, (1994) 217 ALR 226

Austal Ships Pty Ltd (unreported, AIRCFB, 13 August 1997)

Banque Commerciale SA (En Liquidation) v Akhil Holdings Ltd [1990] HCA 11; (1990) 169 CLR 279

Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners [1949] HCA 1; (1949) 78 CLR 62

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) [1964] HCA 69; (1964) 112 CLR 125

McManus v Scott-Charlton [1996] FCA 904; (1996) 70 FCR 16

Polar Aviation Pty Ltd v Civil Aviation Safety Authority and Ors [2012] FCAFC 97; (2012) 203 FCR 325

Radisich v McDonald [2010] FCA 762; (2010) 198 IR 244

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: South Australia
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 67
Date of last submission/s: 29 July 2022
Date of hearing: 29 June 2022
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr R Grealy for JKR Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr S Mackie
Solicitor for the Respondent: HR Law

ORDERS

SAD 73 of 2022
BETWEEN:

JONATHAN PARKIN

Applicant

AND:

ALLIANCE AIRLINES PTY LIMITED

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

O'SULLIVAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 MAY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave to the applicant to file an amended statement of claim and originating application in the form annexed to the affidavit of Robert Grealy sworn 28 June 2022 is refused.

2.Leave to the applicant to file an amended statement of claim and amended originating application by on or before 30 May 2023.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’SULLIVAN J:

  1. When faced with an application to strike out his statement of claim, the applicant annexed an amended statement of claim and amended originating application in the form annexed to the affidavit of Robert Grealy sworn on 28 June 2022 (Grealy affidavit).  No interlocutory application seeking leave to file an amended statement of claim and amended originating application appears to have been filed.

  2. In any event, when the matter was called on, by agreement between the parties, the amended statement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Parkin v Alliance Airlines Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 386
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Parkin v Alliance Airlines Pty Limited, the applicant sought leave to amend his statement of claim and originating application. The applicant, who was previously employed by the respondent, alleged that his employment was terminated due to his non-compliance with the respondent's COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination Policy. The court had to determine whether the applicant should be granted leave to amend his pleadings, considering that the proposed amended statement of claim and originating application did not disclose a reasonable cause of action.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the proposed amended statement of claim and originating application disclosed a reasonable cause of action. The court considered the principles of striking out a pleading, which include ensuring procedural fairness and defining the issues for decision. The court also examined the authorities on the power to strike out a pleading because it disclosed no reasonable cause of action, which is exercised only in plain and obvious cases where no reasonable amendment can cure the alleged defect.

The court held that the proposed amended statement of claim did not disclose a reasonable cause of action as it was not clear that the Vaccination Policy was unlawful or unreasonable. However, the court was not satisfied that the defect could not be remedied and granted the applicant a further opportunity to file an amended statement of claim and originating application by a specified date. The court ultimately refused leave to file the amended statement of claim and originating application in the form annexed to the affidavit of Robert Grealy sworn on 28 June 2022, but granted leave to the applicant to file an amended statement of claim and amended originating application by 30 May 2023.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to the applicant to file an amended statement of claim and originating application in the form annexed to the affidavit of Robert Grealy sworn 28 June 2022 is refused.

2. Leave to the applicant to file an amended statement of claim and amended originating application by on or before 30 May 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is for the reasons which follow that:(a)Leave to file an amended statement of claim and originating application in the form annexed to the Grealy affidavit is refused; and(b)Leave to the applicant to file an amended statement of claim and originating application on or before 30 May 2023.Background The background to this matter may be shortly stated. Where I describe the factual circumstances, it is taken from the draft amended statement of claim and draft amended originating application, and should be seen as me describing the allegation. From on or about 3 May 2010 until 22 December 2021, the applicant was employed by the respondent, most recently as a pilot. On 31 March 2021, the respondent introduced a COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination Policy, which required, inter alia, that:(a)Each of the respondent’s employees were required to receive two doses of an approved COVID-19 vaccine by 15 November 2021 in order to continue working for the respondent (the Vaccination Policy);(b)The applicant was required to provide the respondent with evidence of his vaccination status for inclusion in a record maintained by the respondent (the Vaccination Evidence Direction); and(c)Any employee who failed to comply with the Vaccination Policy or Vaccination Evidence Direction would not be allowed to work and would face disciplinary action. After implementing the Vaccination Policy, the respondent sent several emails to the applicant in relation to the Vaccination Policy and the applicant’s vaccination status. On or about 24 December 2021, the respondent sent correspondence to the applicant advising him that as he had not provided proof of his vaccination status as required by the Vaccination Policy, the respondent was considering terminating his employment. The respondent also sent the applicant an invitation to attend a meeting in relation to his vaccination status on 4 January 2022. On 4 January 2022, the applicant sent an email to the respondent, setting out that he considered the Vaccination Policy and Vaccination Evidence Direction to be unlawful. On 4 January 2022, the respondent cancelled the meeting in relation to the applicant’s vaccination status and sent the applicant notification that his employment had been terminated for non-compliance with the Vaccination Policy. Relevant principles Although this matter is an application to file amended pleadings and an originating application, nonetheless leave will be refused if the proposed pleading would be struck out. The principles applicable to striking out a pleading are well-settled. In Banque Commerciale SA (En Liquidation) v Akhil Holdings Ltd [1990] HCA 11; (1990) 169 CLR 279, 286, Mason CJ and Gaudron J describe the function of pleadings in the following terms:The function of pleadings is to state with sufficient clarity the case that must be met: Gould and Birbeck and Bacon v. Mount Oxide Mines Ltd. (In liq.) (25), per Isaacs and Rich JJ. In this way, pleadings serve to ensure the basic requirement of procedural fairness that a party should have the opportunity of meeting the case against him or her and, incidentally, to define the issues for decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On that basis, there is nothing currently pleaded to support the allegation that the Vaccination Policy was unlawful or unreasonable.Conclusion The authorities to which I have referred make it clear that the power to strike-out a pleading because it discloses no reasonable cause of action is only exercised in plain and obvious cases, where it is clear no reasonable amendment can cure the alleged defect, and there is no reasonable question to be tried. It is for the reasons I set out above that I do not consider the proposed amended statement of claim discloses a reasonable cause of action. Nonetheless, I am not satisfied that cannot be remedied and the applicant should be given a further opportunity to file an amended statement of claim. There will be orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The authorities also make it clear that the power to strike-out a pleading because it discloses no reasonable cause of action is only to be exercised in plain and obvious cases, where it is clear no reasonable amendment can cure the alleged defect, and there is no reasonable question to be tried: see Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & NZ Banking Group Ltd [1994] FCA 636, (1994) 217 ALR 226; Polar Aviation Pty Ltd v Civil Aviation Safety Authority and Ors (2012) 203 FCR 325; [2012] FCAFC 97, [40]-[43].The parties’ submissions and consideration The respondent relies on r 16.21(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), which relevantly provide at (d) and (e):(1)A party may apply to the Court for an order that all or part of a pleading be struck out on the ground that the pleading:…(d)is likely to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay in the proceeding; or(e)fails to disclose a reasonable cause of action or defence or other case appropriate to the nature of the pleading; Central to the applicant’s pleading is the Vaccination Policy. The applicant submits that the Vaccination Policy was both unlawful and unreasonable and that refusal to comply with an unlawful or unreasonable direction will not justify disciplinary action or dismissal, such that any adverse action by the employer will amount to a breach of the employment contract. Insofar as the Vaccination Policy is alleged to be unlawful, the particulars of that allegation are contained in [22]-[26] of the proposed amended statement of claim. Paragraph 25 pleads that it was a term of the Vaccination Policy, or alternatively the respondent’s intention that the respondent will not grant exemptions against vaccination with an available vaccine on political grounds or conscientious, moral, spiritual or religious grounds. At [26] the applicant alleges that the respondent had not accepted any employee’s request for exemption on religious, conscientious, spiritual or moral grounds or political grounds. The respondent submits that the proposed amended statement of claim is confusing and in parts nonsensical, such that it is likely to cause delay. The respondent also identifies issues with each cause of action in the proposed amended statement of claim said to sound in damages. The respondent also submits the applicant confuses his causes of action between contract, general protections and unfair dismissal. After pleading unlawfulness/unreasonableness, the applicant pleads various causes of action. As I understand the pleading, it is these causes of action which are said to give rise to the unlawful/unreasonable character of the Vaccination Policy.Breach of Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (QLD) and s 351 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) At [38]-[41] the applicant pleads unlawful discrimination against the respondent. The applicant pleads: at [40], [41] the Vaccination Policy was indirectly discriminatory contrary to:(a)ss 7 and 9 of the Anti-Discrimination Act1991 (Qld) (Anti-Discrimination Act); and(b)s 351 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act).