PARKER and DIRECTOR GENERAL OF TRANSPORT

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   COMMERCIAL & CIVIL

ACT: ROAD TRAFFIC ACT 1974 (WA)

CITATION:   PARKER and DIRECTOR GENERAL OF TRANSPORT [2012] WASAT 151

MEMBER:   MS NATASHA OWEN-CONWAY (MEMBER)

HEARD:   13 APRIL 2012

DELIVERED          :   20 JULY 2012

FILE NO/S:   CC 1685 of 2011

BETWEEN:   DAVID CHARLES PARKER

Applicant

AND

DIRECTOR GENERAL OF TRANSPORT
Respondent

Catchwords:

Ability to control a motor vehicle - Medical conditions - Reason to believe - Treatment of conditions - Effect of conditions and/or medication on ability to control a motor vehicle - Whether ability is impaired

Legislation:

Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA), reg 7, reg 16(4)(b), reg 25, reg 25(b), reg 28(2), reg 28(3), reg 28(4), reg 41, reg 42, reg 42(c), s 42(1)(f)
Road Traffic Act 1974 (WA), s 6, s 6A, s 42, s 42A, s 48
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 17, s 27, s 27(2), s 28(1), s 28(2)

Result:

Application successful

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Mr P Busby (Acting as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicant:     N/A

Respondent:     Department of Transport

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) 203 CLR 194

NEAT Domestic Trading Pty Ltd v AWB Limited (2003) 216 CLR 277

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex Parte Miah (2001) 206 CLR 57

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. Mr Parker made an application to the Director General of Transport for a 'F' extension to his MR and HR driver's licences pursuant to the Road Traffic Act 1974 (WA) and the Road Traffic (Authority to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA).  The question arose as to whether Mr Parker suffered nocturnal seizures.  Mr Parker suffered from depression, mood disorder and borderline personality disorder.  Mr Parker had been prescribed Epilim to treat his mood disorder, depression and borderline personality disorder by his psychiatrist.  Epilim is an anti­convulsive medication commonly used to treat epilepsy and seizure sufferers.  Mr Parker had suffered a pseudo seizure provoked by arousal from general anaesthetic following an operation in 2008 and then again in 2010.  Mr Parker had also suffered episodes of night­time tremulousness from time to time during a period when he suffered extreme stress in his day­to­day life.  Mr Parker's treating medical specialist informed the Director General's appointed medical practitioner that Mr Parker suffered 'nocturnal seizures'.  The Director General refused Mr Parker's application for a 'F' extension to his MR and HR driver's licences and also suspended Mr Parker's MR and HR driver's licences, resulting in Mr Parker not being able to drive either a medium or heavy truck.  The Director General undertook an internal review and affirmed his decision to suspend Mr Parker's MR and HR driver's licences.

  2. The Tribunal, upon a review, concluded that, after reviewing the medical evidence produced by Mr Parker's treating medical specialists, on the balance of probabilities, Mr Parker did not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PARKER and DIRECTOR GENERAL OF TRANSPORT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASAT 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Parker v Director General of Transport involved the applicant, who held multiple driver's licences, including MR and HR class licences, which allowed him to operate medium and heavy trucks. The Director General of Transport sought to suspend these licences based on the applicant's medical conditions and treatment, asserting that they could impair his ability to control a motor vehicle. The matter was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of statutory provisions that permit the Director General to suspend or refuse a licence if there is a reason to believe that the applicant's ability to control a motor vehicle is impaired due to a medical condition or treatment. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine whether the Director General could rely on a belief or decision made by another person to exercise the statutory power and whether the Director General was required to assess the particular licence holder's condition in relation to any possible impairment.

The Tribunal found that the Director General could not exercise the statutory power by adopting another person's belief or decision. Instead, the Director General must form an independent belief about the licence holder's condition and its potential impact on their ability to control a vehicle. The Tribunal emphasised that the prescribed belief must relate directly to the licence holder and their specific circumstances, rather than general conditions or treatments. As such, the Tribunal held that the Director General's decision was flawed because it did not properly assess the applicant's individual circumstances and condition.

The Tribunal quashed the decision of the Director General and remitted the matter back for reconsideration in light of the Tribunal's findings. The Tribunal's decision underscored the importance of an independent assessment of the licence holder's condition and its potential impact on their driving ability, rather than relying on generalised beliefs or decisions made by others.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, in discharge of the power conferred by reg 25(b) and reg 41 of the Regulations, the respondent cannot purport to exercise the statutory power by adopting another person's belief or decision. To do otherwise is to misconceive the exercise of the power, and will amount to a constructive failure on the part of the respondent to exercise the discretion: see Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) 203 CLR 194; Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex Parte Miah (2001) 206 CLR 57. The prescribed belief must be in relation to the licence holder (in this proceeding, the applicant). In the Tribunal's opinion on the law, the respondent is not entitled to formulate a belief in respect of the type of condition or treatment in issue alone. What is required of the respondent is an assessment of the particular licence holder and that person's condition or treatment in relation to any possible resultant impairment of the person's control of a motor vehicle which the licence authorises the person to drive. The applicant is currently 46 years old. He is the holder of a C class driver's licence, authorising him to drive a motor vehicle (other than a motorcycle or motor carrier) that has a gross vehicle mass not exceeding 4.5 tonnes and that is equipped to seat not more than 12 adults, including a driver. He is also the holder of an R class driver's licence, authorising him to drive a motorcycle or motor carrier. He also holds an LR class driver's licence, authorising him to drive a motor vehicle (other than a motorcycle or motor carrier) that exceeds 4.5 tonnes but does not exceed 8 tonnes. These facts are not in issue and the Tribunal finds these facts to be true. Since sometime in or about 1983, the applicant applied for, and was granted, and has continuously held until October 2011, a MR and HR driver's licence, which licences authorise the applicant to drive, in the case of a MR driver's licence, any motor vehicle (other than a motorcycle or motor carrier) that has two axles and a gross vehicle mass of 8 tonnes (medium truck), and in the case of a HR driver's licence, any motor vehicle (other than a motorcycle or motor carrier) that has three or more axles and a gross vehicle mass exceeding 8 tonnes (heavy truck). Again, these facts are not in issue and the Tribunal finds these facts to be true. The applicant gave evidence to the Tribunal, and it was not challenged by the respondent, that he has never been involved in a motor vehicle collision. There was no evidence before the Tribunal contradicting the applicant's evidence and the Tribunal finds this fact to be true. The applicant gave evidence concerning his background and personal circumstances, none of which evidence was challenged and most of which is recorded in the reports of the applicant's treating medical practitioners. The Tribunal finds these following facts to be true.1)During the period of his life when his father operated a farming business near Northampton, the applicant assisted his father by driving a medium or heavy truck to cart wheat and canola grain, amongst other goods, to the depot in Northampton in the State. This work involved a 40 minute journey each way. At some later point in time, the applicant acquired the farm and the farming business from his father, and continued the same business on his own account. The farm had been in the applicant's family for five generations. He continued to drive a truck to cart wheat and canola grain and other goods to the depot at Northampton in the State. The applicant acquired and used his MR and HR driver's licences for this type of work until about 2007.2)In 2007, the applicant commenced working off the farm (all the while farming the property), and was engaged in cartage work and using his front end loader on building sites, which required him to cart the front end loader on his truck. He was also involved in labouring occupations. Since 2008, the applicant has used his MR and HR driver's licences to obtain gainful employment as he had ceased all farming operations on his own account.3)From 2004 to 2010, the applicant experienced periods of physical, emotional and financial distress and hardship. He asserts all of these influences affected his physical and mental heath, from time to time, to a greater or lesser degree. He asserts that during this period, he continued to drive medium and heavy trucks without incident. He asserts that he has received treatment for his various conditions, is in relatively good health, and that his conditions are under management by way of treatment supervised by his medical practitioners. He asserts that, in fact, none of his conditions, temporary or permanent, or the treatment thereof has impaired his ability to control a medium or heavy truck. He says that, based on that fact, and on a proper consideration of all of the medical information, there is no reason to believe that his conditions and/or the treatment thereof will likely impair his ability to control a medium or heavy truck.4)The applicant suffered childhood sexual abuse by an elder family member, and has a history of childhood physical and emotional abuse by his father. There is evidence before the Tribunal that during the applicant's early teens, his torment manifested itself in an extreme fashion and he attempted suicide. There is some evidence that this occurred in 2005 as well.5)In 2004, the applicant underwent investigative treatment to identify the cause of severe back pain. By 2006, the cause of the applicant's back pain had been identified and treated by Mr McCloskey, orthopaedic surgeon, which resulted in the applicant's back being pain­free.6)In 2005, the applicant's crop failed and the applicant's finances became strained. In 2006, a drought struck the applicant's farming operations and the applicant's finances deteriorated. By 2006, the applicant had become depressed as a consequence of the back pain he had experienced, his weakened financial position and difficulties experienced in his marriage. He was referred to Dr Kumar, psychiatrist, who diagnosed that the applicant suffered depression, dysthymia or mood disorder, and borderline personality disorder. The applicant's symptoms, at this point in time, were severe and manifested themselves in a number of extreme ways, and the applicant experienced periods of suicidal idealation.7)In 2007, a further drought struck the applicant's farming operations and the applicant's financial circumstances became precarious. In or about 2007 and in the course of the treatment of his conditions, Dr Kumar prescribed induction of sodium valproate by the applicant 'as a mood stabiliser'. The applicant was also treated by a psychologist upon referral by Dr Kumar.8)In 2008, the applicant's farming business ceased operation as it was no longer viable, and the applicant looked to find gainful employment away from the farm to support himself, his then wife and their four children. He relied upon being able to find gainful employment using his MR and HR driver's licences, and he continues to rely on his MR and HR driver's licences to support himself and his family.9)In 2009, the applicant's farm was sold as he was unable to financially service the liabilities he had incurred during the periods of drought which, he informed the Tribunal, amounted to more than $1,000,000. By 2009, the applicant's marriage had broken down irretrievably.10)The applicant experienced a very high level of stress between 2004 and 2010, for which he received treatment from Dr Kumar and on referral by Dr Kumar. In 2008, the applicant continued to induct sodium valproate, although, by that stage, his dosage had been reduced. By 2008, the trade name of the sodium valproate taken by the applicant was known as 'Epilim'.