PAPPAS & PAPPAS

Case [2018] FamCA 297


FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PAPPAS & PAPPAS [2018] FamCA 297
FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Interim – Where the wife seeks interim costs and partial property settlement – Where the husband seeks funds from a controlled monies account to be directed to the payment of capital gains tax – Where the wife seeks for the mortgage over a jointly owned property to be discharged and the husband opposes that order – Where there is no current assessment of capital gains tax – Court finds that making orders in relation to payment of capital gains tax would be premature – Order made establishing a mechanism for regular mortgage repayment – Order made for both parties to receive a payment from the controlled monies account – Order made for the wife to receive a partial property settlement
APPLICANT: Ms Pappas
RESPONDENT: Mr Pappas
FILE NUMBER: SYC 7631 of 2016
DATE DELIVERED: 8 May 2018
PLACE DELIVERED: Sydney
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: Stevenson J
HEARING DATE: 23 April 2018

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Ms Eldershaw
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: York Law
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Cook
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Anderson Lawyers

Orders

By consent it is ordered that:

  1. Order 8 made on 5 December 2016 is discharged.

  2. Within 14 days, the parties do all acts and things to establish an offset


    account to operate in conjunction with the home loan account for a


    property owned jointly by the parties at F Street, Suburb D with the CBA (Loan Account BSB …;  No….05), such account to be operated on the signatures of both parties or by further order of the Court and each party shall be restrained from operating upon, or drawing down on such account except with the express written consent and co-signature of the other party or Court order (“Offset Account”) or for the purpose of making loan repayments as and when they fall due.

  3. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the parties will do all acts and


    things to cause the whole of the balance of NAB Account BSB … Account …45 to be transferred to the abovementioned Offset Account.

It is further ordered that:

  1. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, a sum equal to the arrears owing in respect of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia mortgage on the title to the Suburb D property in an amount of approximately $14,000 will be transferred from a Controlled Monies Account held in the name of York Law Family Law Specialists P/L and ITF Mr Pappas and Ms Pappas, be transferred to the Offset Account.

  2. Time for the husband to comply with orders and directions of Senior Registrar Campbell on 12 February 2018 is extended to a date 14 days from the date of these Orders as to the filing and service of an Undertaking as to Disclosure and provision of an inventory of antiques and artworks and furniture in the possession, custody or control of the husband (whether owned by the husband…

Continue reading PAPPAS & PAPPAS

Sign in free to access the full text

Details
AGLC
PAPPAS & PAPPAS [2018] FamCA 297
Case
[2018] FamCA 297
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Pappas & Pappas*, Stevenson J made orders by consent between the parties. The dispute concerned the division of property and financial matters, including the management of a jointly owned property and the settlement of outstanding financial obligations.

The court was required to determine the terms of consent orders relating to the discharge of a previous order, the establishment and operation of an offset account for a joint home loan, the transfer of funds to this offset account, and the payment of mortgage arrears. Further issues addressed included the extension of time for the husband to comply with previous disclosure orders, the provision of specific financial documents and inventories, and the authorisation for accountants to collaborate on tax return preparation. The court also needed to order the distribution of funds from a controlled monies account as partial property settlement.

Stevenson J applied the principles of consent orders, reflecting the agreement of the parties on the resolution of their financial matters. The reasoning involved structuring the orders to ensure the orderly management of the joint property and loan, the timely payment of arrears, and the facilitation of full financial disclosure. The court also addressed the practicalities of property settlement by directing specific payments from a controlled monies account to both parties.

By consent, the court ordered the discharge of a previous order and the establishment of an offset account for the parties' joint home loan, requiring both parties' signatures for operation except for loan repayments. Funds from a NAB account were to be transferred to this offset account, and approximately $14,000 in mortgage arrears was to be paid from a controlled monies account. The husband's time to comply with previous disclosure orders was extended, and he was directed to provide various financial documents and inventories. The parties were also ordered to facilitate payments from the controlled monies account, with $150,000 to the husband and $300,000 to the wife as partial property settlement.

Orders

Orders of the court

By consent it is ordered that:

1.

Order 8 made on 5 December 2016 is discharged.

2.

Within 14 days, the parties do all acts and things to establish an offset

account to operate in conjunction with the home loan account for a

property owned jointly by the parties at F Street, Suburb D with the CBA (Loan Account BSB …; No….05), such account to be operated on the signatures of both parties or by further order of the Court and each party shall be restrained from operating upon, or drawing down on such account except with the express written consent and co-signature of the other party or Court order (“Offset Account”) or for the purpose of making loan repayments as and when they fall due.

3.

Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the parties will do all acts and

things to cause the whole of the balance of NAB Account BSB … Account …45 to be transferred to the abovementioned Offset Account.

It is further ordered that:

4.

Within 14 days of the date of these orders, a sum equal to the arrears owing in respect of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia mortgage on the title to the Suburb D property in an amount of approximately $14,000 will be transferred from a Controlled Monies Account held in the name of York Law Family Law Specialists P/L and ITF Mr Pappas and Ms Pappas, be transferred to the Offset Account.

5.

Time for the husband to comply with orders and directions of Senior Registrar Campbell on 12 February 2018 is extended to a date 14 days from the date of these Orders as to the filing and service of an Undertaking as to Disclosure and provision of an inventory of antiques and artworks and furniture in the possession, custody or control of the husband (whether owned by the husband personally or as trustee for the Pappas SMSF); copies of all invoices and valuations in relation to all antiques, artworks, furniture and jewellery in his possession, custody or control; and an inventory of antiques and artworks and furniture sold by the husband together with all documents evidencing the sale date and sale price, whether owned by the husband personally or the Pappas SMSF for the period 1 September 2009 to date; depreciation schedule for the Pappas SMSF for the financial years 2009 to 2017.

6.

The husband authorise and direct his accountant to work with the wife’s accountant, Mr F of F & Co Pty Ltd for the purpose of enabling Mr F to prepare any outstanding tax returns for the wife.

7.

Each of the parties will do all things necessary to cause the following payments to be made from the Controlled Monies Account held in the name of York Law Specialisation Pty Ltd and ITF Mr Pappas and Ms Pappas by way of partial property settlement:

(a) A sum of $150,000 to the husband

(b) A sum of $300,000 to the wife.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.