Pantelis v AAI Limited trading as GIO

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Pantelis v AAI Limited trading as GIO [2021] NSWPIC 446

CLAIMANT: Faneromeni Pantelis
INSURER: AAI Limited trading as GIO
MEMBER: Alexander Bolton
DATE OF DECISION: 5 November 2021
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS -   Settlement approval; 71 year old female pedestrian travelling against pedestrian don’t walk sign injured in a collision with a car; periprosthetic fracture of left femur and left ankle fracture; admitted to hospital for 28 days; Claimant had significant pre-accident medical history; 20% whole person impairment assessment; liability admitted but 20% contributory negligence agreed and Cheetham v Bau discussed; RACQ Insurance Limited v Motor Accidents Authority of NSW and Reece v Reece considered regarding assessment of non-economic loss and claimant’s age; Held - proposed settlement is just, fair and reasonable; settlement approved.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.    This proposed settlement is approved.

2. The proposed settlement is approved under s 6.23(2)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

Background

  1. Mrs Panetlis is 71 years old and a pensioner.

  2. She was involved in an accident on 15 March 2019 at approximately 8.15am when she was a pedestrian crossing an intersection and a car ran into her.

  3. The insurer accepted liability but initially alleged contributory negligence of 60% by letter of 29 April 2021.

  4. Mrs Pantelis suffered the following injuries:

    (a)    periprosthetic fracture of the left femur, and

    (b)    left ankle fracture.

  5. Mrs Pantelis had a significant pre-accident medical history including:

    (a)    six surgeries to left knee;

    (b)    bilateral total knee replacements;

    (c)    chronic back pain;

    (d)    chronic renal impairment;

    (e)    type 2 diabetes;

    (f)    atrial fibrillation;

    (g)    hearing impairment;

    (h)    hypertension, and

    (i)    diverticulitis.

  6. The claimant requests that the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) approve the proposed settlement. Mrs Pantelis is not legally represented. The parties have entered into negotiations and have concluded a settlement. The claim comes before me for approval.

Reasons

Treating medical evidence

  1. Immediately after the accident, Mrs Pantelis was taken by ambulance to Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (RPAH). She came under the care of Dr Guzman, orthopaedic surgeon. She underwent an open reduction and internal fixation, left femoral supracondylar fracture, that is, of the lateral plate. Complications during the admission from 15 March 2019 to 12 April 2019 included a pulmonary embolism.

  2. Mrs Pantelis was non-weight bearing for three months post accident. Her ankle fracture was in a plaster cast for six weeks.

  3. Following discharge from RPAH, Mrs Pantelis was transferred to Metro Rehabilitation Hospital for further rehabilitation. Finally, she returned home in about August 2019.

Medical evidence for the insurer

  1. Mrs Pantelis was examined on behalf of the insurer by Dr Rimmer, orthopaedic surgeon, on 18 November 2020. He provided a report of 1 December 2020.

  2. Mrs Pantelis described a weakness of her left knee and an inability to walk without a frame. Even with a frame, she can only walk short distances. Prior to the accident, she walked with the aid of a stick only.

  3. While Mrs Pantelis has stiffness in her left ankle, she has no pain.

  4. A very…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pantelis v AAI Limited trading as GIO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWPIC 446
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pantelis, the claimant, brought an action against AAI Limited trading as GIO, the insurer of the defendant driver, seeking approval of a settlement. The claimant, a 71-year-old woman, was injured in a motor accident when she was struck by a car while crossing against a pedestrian don’t walk sign. She sustained a periprosthetic fracture of her left femur and a left ankle fracture, and was hospitalised for 28 days. The claimant had a significant medical history prior to the accident, which included osteoarthritis, diabetes, and hypertension. Following the accident, the claimant was assessed to have a 20% whole person impairment. The defendant driver admitted liability but argued for a 20% contributory negligence, citing the claimant’s actions in crossing against the pedestrian don’t walk sign. The court needed to determine whether the proposed settlement was just, fair, and reasonable.

The court considered the legal issues surrounding the assessment of non-economic loss and the claimant's age, referencing relevant case law. The court examined Cheetham v Bau for guidance on contributory negligence in pedestrian accidents and RACQ Insurance Limited v Motor Accidents Authority of NSW and Reece v Reece for the principles governing non-economic loss assessment. The court needed to weigh the claimant’s age and pre-existing medical conditions against the nature and extent of the injuries sustained in the accident. The court also had to consider whether the proposed settlement amount reflected the true value of the claimant’s loss, taking into account all relevant factors.

In approving the settlement, the court found that the proposed settlement amount was just, fair, and reasonable. The court considered the claimant’s age, pre-existing medical conditions, and the severity of the injuries sustained. The court determined that the 20% contributory negligence was appropriate given the claimant’s actions in crossing against the pedestrian don’t walk sign. The court also found that the assessment of non-economic loss appropriately reflected the impact of the accident on the claimant’s life. The court concluded that the settlement amount was a fair reflection of the claimant’s loss and approved the settlement.

The court’s final order was that the proposed settlement between the claimant and the insurer of the defendant driver was just, fair, and reasonable. The settlement was approved, and the claimant was entitled to the settlement amount as compensation for her injuries and losses resulting from the motor accident.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.