Palenzuela v Palaje

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Palenzuela v Palaje [2008] NSWCA 349

FILE NUMBER(S):
40152/08

HEARING DATE(S):
2 December 2008

JUDGMENT DATE:
12 December 2008

PARTIES:
Nelia David Palenzuela
Maria Concepcion Palaje
Emily Palaje
Antonio Mauceri

JUDGMENT OF:
Giles JA Tobias JA Gyles AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
SC 1226/07

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Barrett J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
30 May 2008

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Palenzuela v Palaje [2008] NSWSC 527

COUNSEL:
A: M W Sneddon
R: T Atkin

SOLICITORS:
A: McLaughlin & Riordan, Sydney
R: S M Boyle & Co, Cronulla

CATCHWORDS:
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – Failure to assess significance of certain documentary evidence – Whether document could be regarded as written confirmation of contractual commitment  – CONTRACTS – Whether contract of guarantee formed on facts

LEGISLATION CITED:
Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW)

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Elliott v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1804; (2001) 129 IR 251
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
Manly Council v Byrne [2004] NSWCA 123
Palenzuela v Palaje [2008] NSWSC 527
State Rail Authority v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd (In liq) [1999] HCA 3; (1999) 73 ALJR 306; (1999) 160 ALR 588

TEXTS CITED:

DECISION:

  1. Appeal allowed.

  2. Set aside the orders made by Barrett J on 30 May 2008.

  3. Order that there be a new trial of the proceedings.

  4. Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 if otherwise qualified.

  5. Order that the costs of the first trial abide the result of the second trial.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40152/08

GILES JA
TOBIAS JA
GYLES AJA

Friday 12 December 2008

NELIA DAVID PALENZUELA v MARIA CONCEPCION PALAJE & ANOR

Judgment

  1. GILES JA:  I agree with Tobias JA.

  2. TOBIAS JA: By her Amended Statement of Claim filed on 11 February 2008, the appellant alleged that on or about 10 August 2004, the first respondent promised to guarantee the repayment to the appellant of all money owed to her by the first respondent’s daughter, the second respondent.  The relevant consideration moving from the appellant to the first respondent was her lending a further sum of $100,000 to the second respondent at the request of the first respondent, notwithstanding that some $75,000 was already outstanding.  The appellant further alleged that that guarantee was charged against three properties in which it was alleged the second respondent had an interest and which were referred to in the proceedings as the Pyrmont property, the Kurnell property and the Kensington property. 

  3. The proceedings were heard by Barrett J who, on 30 May 2008 rejected the appellant’s claims and dismissed the proceedings with costs: Palenzuela v Palaje [2008] NSWSC 527. The appellant appeals to this Court from that decision.

  4. For the purpose of reciting the facts and the submissions and without meaning any disrespect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Palenzuela v Palaje and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 349
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Nelia Palenzuela (the appellant) and Maria Palaje and her daughter Emily Palaje (the respondents) regarding loans made by Nelia to Emily. Nelia had lent Emily substantial sums of money, and Maria was aware of these transactions. A key element of the dispute was whether Maria had provided a guarantee for the repayment of these loans. The primary judge had made orders in favour of the respondents, which Nelia appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the primary judge had erred in failing to adequately assess the significance of certain documentary evidence, specifically a promissory note signed by Emily and witnessed by Maria. The central legal issue was whether, on the facts, a contract of guarantee had been formed between Nelia and Maria.

The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge had failed to properly consider the implications of the documentary evidence in relation to the alleged guarantee. The court reasoned that the promissory note, which Maria witnessed Emily signing, and the surrounding circumstances, including advice from Nelia's solicitor that a guarantee supported by a mortgage was required for further lending, warranted closer examination. The court concluded that there was a real question as to whether Maria's actions and the documentation constituted a contractual commitment to guarantee Emily's debts.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the primary judge, and ordered a new trial of the proceedings. The respondents were ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, with the costs of the first trial to abide the result of the second trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

(i) Appeal allowed. (ii) Set aside the orders made by Barrett J on 30 May 2008. (iii) Order that there be a new trial of the proceedings. (iv) Order that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 if otherwise qualified. (v) Order that the costs of the first trial abide the result of the second trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the purpose of reciting the facts and the submissions and without meaning any disrespect to the parties, it is convenient, as it was for the primary judge, to refer to the appellant as Nelia, the first respondent as Maria and her daughter, the second respondent, as Emily.The background facts The parties were of Filipino origin although they have been in Australia for many years. Maria is Emily’s mother; Nelia’s mother and Maria’s late husband were cousins. Nelia and Maria have known each for about 50 years. Their relationship is such that Nelia refers to Maria as “Tiang” (which is equivalent to “Aunty”). Nelia and Emily are approximately the same age. For reasons not presently relevant, Emily sought a number of loans from Nelia. The first was in early December 2003 when Nelia lent Emily $1,000 in order to pay off a debt. In mid-December 2003, at Emily’s request, Nelia lent her the further sum of $34,000 to assist in purchasing stock for a business that Emily was conducting at the time at Rozelle. Emily agreed to pay interest on that loan at the rate of 8% per annum. In early April 2004 Emily sought and was granted a further loan from Nelia in the sum of $40,000 to pay for further stock. Maria was aware of each of the loans and in respect of the last of them, was present when Emily requested Nelia to lend her the relevant sum. Soon after the April 2004 request for the loan of $40,000, Nelia prepared a form of promissory note. The “borrowers” were identified as Emily and her partner (the third respondent, who took no part in the proceedings) and the “lender” was identified as Nelia. The “principal” amount was stated to be $70,000 to be repaid within 15 days after the execution of the note, no later than 27 April 2004. The note provided for the payment of interest at 8.5% per annum. Emily signed the promissory note and Maria witnessed her signature. It is dated 13 April 2004. It was not suggested that Maria guaranteed the repayment of any of these loans at the time they were made. In late July or early August 2004 Emily again approached Nelia and requested a further loan of $100,000. According to Nelia, Emily had informed her (and Maria had confirmed) that they were refinancing the Kurnell property (in which both Maria and Emily had an interest) to raise the funds to repay Nelia the amount owed to her by Emily. Emily also explained that she needed the $100,000 to clear a loan on the Pyrmont property of which she was the sole owner, as otherwise a “liquidator” would take the property. According to Nelia, Maria explained that although the refinancing of the Kurnell property had been approved, the money would not be available in time to avert the “liquidator” proceedings. It was common ground that Nelia informed Emily and Maria that she wished to discuss this further loan with her solicitor, Mr Acar, who carried on practice at Blacktown. According to Mr Acar’s unchallenged evidence, in about late July 2004 the three women attended upon him. When the proposal for Nelia to lend Emily a further $100,000 was raised he said to Nelia, in the presence of Maria and Emily, words to the following effect:“Do not lend the lady any more money without obtaining a guarantee supported by a mortgage”. (Emphasis added)Although Maria denied in her affidavit the italicised portion of this statement, in cross-examination she conceded that it was correct.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances it is inappropriate to make any comment as to the correctness of this submission given my conclusion that there should be a new trial and the question of whether Emily gives evidence or not will no doubt again arise at that time.Conclusion For the foregoing reasons in my opinion the appeal should be allowed. I would therefore propose the following orders:(i) Appeal allowed.(ii) Set aside the orders made by Barrett J on 30 May 2008.(iii) Order that there be a new trial of the proceedings.(iv) Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise qualified.(v) Order that the costs of the first trial abide the result of the second trial. GYLES AJA: I agree with Tobias JA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.