Paek and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 747

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No   N2000/228

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      SEUNG MIN PAEK           
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon Mr R N J Purvis, QC, Deputy President         

Date25 August 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is set aside.            

[Sgd]  R N J Purvis
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – deportation – manslaughter conviction – serious nature of crime – risk of recidivism very low – expectations of the Australian community that non-citizens who are convicted of crimes that are abhorrent will be removed from Australia – no general deterrence under the circumstances – hardship to deportee and deportee's family – expectations of community outweighed by other considerations.
Migration Act 1958-s200
Whittaker v. Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 425.

REASONS FOR DECISION

25 August 2000                The Hon Mr R N J Purvis, QC, Deputy President         

THE APPLICATION:

  1. This is an application by Seung Min Paek also known as Simon Paek ("the Applicant") seeking review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs ("the Respondent") on 8 February 2000 to order deportation of the Applicant under section 200 of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act").

  2. The relevant Deportation Order inter alia stated:

    "…
    AND WHEREAS the said SEUNG MIN PAEK was convicted at the Supreme Court of New South Wales on the eighteenth day of December 1998 of an offence, namely manslaughter, which he committed on the thirtieth day of April 1997, for which he was sentenced to penal servitude for a minimum term four years with an additional term of three years.
    AND WHEREAS the said SEUNG MIN PAEK appealed the severity of the said conviction and on the fifteenth day of October 1999 at the Court of Criminal Appeal, leave to appeal was granted, the appeal allowed with sentences being reduced to a minimum term of two years and nine months with an additional term of two years and nine months.
    AND WHEREAS at the time of the commission of the said offence the said SEUNG MIN PAEK was not an Australian citizen and had been present in Australia as a permanent resident, or as a New Zealand citizen exempt non-citizen, or special category visa holder for less than ten years.
    …"   (T1, p8)

  1. In the Statement of Reasons given for the making of the Deportation Order it was stated:

    "4         I found the following factors weighing against deportation:
          q     Mr Paek's risk of recidivism is assessed as being low;

    ·If deported from Australia Mr Paek will suffer a significant degree of emotional hardship;

    ·Mr Paek's father will suffer emotional hardship if his son is deported from Australia.

    5          I found that the following factors weighed in favour of deportation:

    ·The nature of Mr Paek's offence is one which is considered to be very serious and may lead to deportation as listed in the Government's…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paek and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 747
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Paek and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the Tribunal was tasked with considering the deportation of Paek, a non-citizen convicted of manslaughter, under the Migration Act 1958. The primary issue for the court was whether Paek's crime was of such a serious nature that it warranted deportation, despite other mitigating factors, including the low risk of recidivism and the hardship deportation would cause to Paek and his family.

The court examined the seriousness of the crime and the expectations of the Australian community that non-citizens convicted of abhorrent crimes should be removed. However, the court also considered the low risk of recidivism and the significant hardship deportation would impose on Paek and his family. The court found that, while the crime was serious, it did not rise to the level of being abhorrent, especially considering the mitigating circumstances such as Paek's lack of intent, his age at the time of the offence, and his demonstrated remorse and efforts towards rehabilitation. The court concluded that these factors outweighed the community's expectation of deportation.

Ultimately, the Tribunal decided not to deport Paek, acknowledging the gravity of the crime but giving greater weight to the low risk of recidivism, Paek's remorse, and the significant personal and familial hardship that deportation would entail. This decision reflects a balanced approach that considers both the community's expectations and the individual circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is minded of the impact that the death of their son had upon Mr and Mrs Morcos and the anguish and sorrow experienced by the boy's sisters. It is not necessary in these reasons to reiterate the feelings documented in the statements contained in the material before the Tribunal. It is relevant to note that the Applicant was and is very aware of this consequence of his unfortunate conduct. SUBMISSIONS AND DECISION: The Respondent primarily submits that the Applicant's offence is such that the Australian community would expect that he be deported from this country. The Minister's Direction does not create an obligation on a delegate or the Tribunal to order deportation in the case of every "abhorrent crime" but this consideration is primary and is put at the highest level of concern for the community expects that non-citizen perpetrators of crimes abhorrent to the community should not be allowed to remain in the community "irrespective of all other considerations, unless these are outweighed in the balance by other primary and secondary considerations" (Whittaker, supra, para 38). The offence committed by the Applicant has been earlier described; it was indeed very serious. However, as noted by the Sentencing Judge and the Court of Criminal Appeal, it was at the lower end of the offence of manslaughter and indeed the reduction in sentence by the Appeal Court is indicative of that court so regarding it. The Tribunal is very much aware of the circumstances in which the offence was committed, the lack of intent on the part of the Applicant to commit the offence and the fact that it was he who was initially the victim of aggression. Taking these matters into account, the offence and the commission of it, while serious and to be very much regretted, cannot be classified as abhorrent that is such as to warrant, in the absence of other relevant considerations, a person being deported from Australia. The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant has suffered great remorse and feelings of guilt on account of his criminal activity, the impact it had on the family of the victim and the shame it brought to his own family. He does genuinely want to do "the right thing" and change his form of past behaviour (T28, p181). On behalf of the Applicant, Mr Kessels submitted that the Tribunal should not find the offence so abhorrent as to outweigh all other considerations. In detailing the various reports as to the likelihood or otherwise of the Applicant re-offending it was submitted that they all, even those tendered at the time of sentence, indicate a change taking place in the psychology of the Applicant, his appreciation of what his life should be and the direction it should take. All of the reports are positive as to the likelihood of recidivism being low. His rehabilitation, it was put, is well on the way and the incidents referred to in the misbehaviour reports are not indicative of any regression in this regard. It was submitted that whilst admitting the need in a general sense to protect the Australian community that there is minimal if any risk of harm in the event of the Applicant becoming again a free member of that community. There is not an element of risk to be put in the balance. The Applicant was only 17 when he committed the offences, after having arrived in Australia at the age of 14, struggling with educational institutions and experiencing trouble and disputation at home with his father. He was a rebellious teenager and daily user of marijuana but he had not set out to cause the victim any harm, being set upon in the dark without warning. The Applicant's prospects for complete rehabilitation are, it was submitted, extremely high and his likelihood of making a positive contribution to the Australian community, if he is not deported, apparent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant and his brother initially found it difficult to adjust to life in Australia. This was compounded by their lack of knowledge of English and cultural differences. They attended school and underwent intensive English language courses. However, for one reason or another and in the absence of his father overseas on business, the Applicant began to deviate, to not attend school, use marijuana and associate with persons of a similar bent. The Applicant became uninterested in study and, to use his own words, "became a bad boy", hung around with friends, wasting time and missing school. His use of marijuana increased until it became a daily habit. He began to argue with his father, rejected criticism and any form of discipline. He left his father's home, lived with friends including a girlfriend and maintained the lifestyle of not attending school, using drugs, drinking and staying out at night. In due course he returned to his father's home, enrolled at Bradfield College and commenced a design course. However, unbeknown to his father and stepmother he continued using marijuana and spending time with his associates. It was at this time that the offence occurred and his incarceration shortly thereafter commenced. During the course of his cross-examination the Applicant acknowledged that he had lied to his father about school and use of drugs and that at that time he was not prepared to listen to anyone. THE OFFENCE, SENTENCE AND INCARCERATION: The Applicant on 18 December 1998 pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of Justin Charles Morcos. The court at that time was asked to take into account, in sentencing him, the fact that on 30 April 1997 he obtained $2,000.00 by deception. The court duly sentenced the Applicant to a minimum term of four years penal servitude with an additional term of three years. On appeal to the Court of Criminal Appeal the appeal was allowed, the above sentence quashed and the Applicant sentenced to penal servitude for five and a half years to comprise a minimum term of two years nine months, commencing 14 May 1997, with an additional term of two years nine months. The facts pertaining to the committal of the offence as briefly stated by the Court of Criminal were:"In the early hours of 30 April 1997 the applicant went to the house of a friend, Justin Wong, intending to buy marijuana. The deceased, another young man whom he did not know, was also at the house. There was some unpleasantness of no particular consequence between the applicant and Mr Wong, on the one hand, and the deceased, on the other. The deceased left the home, as did the applicant some time later.His Honour's findings about what then occurred are these. The applicant walked towards his car, which was parked in a nearby street. It was quite dark. The deceased was hiding behind a tree, armed with a knife. He grabbed the applicant and threw him to the ground. The applicant also had a knife, which was a small, folding knife. It fell out of his pocket, and he picked it up and opened it. As the deceased came towards him, he stabbed him in the neck and the head. The stab wound to the neck penetrated his upper spinal cord, causing his death." (T19, pp50-51)