Packer v Tall Ship Sailing Cruises Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Packer v Tall Ship Sailing Cruises Australia Pty Ltd [2015] QCA 108

PARTIES:

JAY PHILLIP PACKER
(appellant)
v
TALL SHIP SAILING CRUISES AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 069 796 514
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 8824 of 2014
SC No 13523 of 2009

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2014] QSC 212

DELIVERED ON:

19 June 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 May 2015

JUDGES:

Gotterson JA and Boddice and Flanagan JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1.   The appeal be dismissed.

2.   The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on a standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTIONS FOR NEGLIGENCE – DUTY OF CARE – where it was accepted that a duty of care can exist on the operator of licensed premises, for injuries suffered as a consequence of the criminal actions of another which arose from disorder created by that operator – where it was accepted that the form of that duty depended on whether the particular circumstances supported a conclusion the harm arose out of disorder as part of a state of affairs created by that operator – where the operator had a liquor license and had served alcohol to the assailant – where the trial judge found that the scope of the duty of care owed by the respondent required consideration of the circumstances on the day in question was correct – whether the trial judge erred in that decision

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTIONS FOR NEGLIGENCE – DUTY OF CARE – REASONABLE FORESEEABILITY OF DAMAGE – where the appellant had sought a finding it was reasonably foreseeable the assailant would become violent, as he was part of the group which was swearing and oblivious to the presence of children – where the trial judge declined to do so on the basis that the issue of foreseeability required a consideration of all of the surrounding circumstances – whether the trial judge erred in that decision

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTIONS FOR NEGLIGENCE – where the operator had two groups on board a catamaran – where the operator had a liquor license and had served alcohol to the assailant – where the assailant’s group had been loud and boisterous while consuming alcohol, and had sworn in the presence of children – where the respondent had asked the assailant’s group to cease swearing and had been rebuffed – where the respondent had ten crew members but had not engaged specialist crowd controllers – where the appellant submitted that the respondent should have had specialist crowd controllers or other crew available – where the trial judge found that even if the crew member had heard the group that was behaving loudly and swearing rebuff the appellant’s initial approach, they would not have identified there was a risk…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Packer v Tall Ship Sailing Cruises Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCA 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Packer v Tall Ship Sailing Cruises Australia Pty Ltd, the appellant sought to appeal against a decision of the District Court of Queensland which dismissed his claim for damages in negligence against the respondent, the operator of a catamaran. The appellant had been injured during a Christmas party cruise organised by his employer, when an altercation occurred between the assailant, a member of a separate group on board, and another passenger. The appellant claimed that the respondent owed him a duty of care to ensure his safety while on board the vessel, and that this duty was breached by the respondent’s failure to control the behaviour of the assailant and his associates. The respondent argued that it had taken all reasonable steps to ensure the safety of its passengers, and that it could not have reasonably foreseen the risk of violence posed by the assailant. The primary judge found that the respondent had not breached its duty of care, and dismissed the appellant’s claim. The appellant appealed against this decision.

The primary issue before the court was whether the trial judge erred in finding that the respondent had not breached its duty of care owed to the appellant. This involved considering whether the respondent had a duty of care to control the behaviour of the assailant, and whether this duty was breached by the respondent’s failure to do so. The court also had to consider whether the trial judge erred in finding that it was not reasonably foreseeable that the assailant would become violent. Finally, the court had to determine whether the trial judge was correct in finding that the respondent had taken all reasonable steps to ensure the safety of its passengers.

The court found that the trial judge did not err in his decision. The court held that the respondent did owe a duty of care to the appellant, but that this duty was not breached. The court found that the respondent had taken all reasonable steps to ensure the safety of its passengers, including asking the assailant’s group to cease swearing and providing a sufficient number of crew members to manage the passengers. The court also held that it was not reasonably foreseeable that the assailant would become violent, as there was no evidence to suggest that he was likely to do so. The court found that the trial judge did not err in his consideration of the surrounding circumstances when determining whether it was reasonably foreseeable that the assailant would become violent. The court concluded that the trial judge’s decision was correct, and dismissed the appellant’s appeal.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed, and that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on a standard basis. The court agreed with the orders proposed by the primary judge, and held that there was no material factual error or error of law in the primary judge’s decision. The court found that the trial judge correctly concluded that the appellant’s claim must be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on a standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 29 August 2014, the appellant’s claim against each of the respondents was dismissed, with costs. The appellant appeals that decision, insofar as it relates to the respondent, the operator of the ship.[1] At issue is whether the trial judge made factual errors as well as errors of law in finding there was no breach of duty by the respondent.[1]There is no appeal against the decision in respect of the appellant’s employer.Background In 2006, the respondent operated a pleasure cruising business on the waterways of Moreton Bay. That business included operating a venue on South Stradbroke Island, McLaren’s Landing, which contained bar and restaurant facilities. Patrons of the respondent’s business would be transported by ship to McLaren’s Landing, where they enjoyed various water activities, as well as food and alcohol. After some hours, patrons were transported by the ship back to the mainland. The respondent provided bar facilities on the ship. McLaren’s Landing was able to cater for dinners for large groups, including groups of up to 200 people. At McLaren’s Landing, there was a catering manager who was assisted by six other employees, in addition to crew members of the ship. These employees cooked and served meals, served drinks at the bar, and undertook cleaning or other duties (including assisting patrons at the venue). Both the ship and McLaren’s Landing were licensed premises under the Liquor Act 1992 (Qld).Evidence On 2 December 2006, the appellant’s employer engaged the respondent’s services to provide its employees and their families with a Christmas party cruise. The appellant was one such employee. He was 35 years of age, and employed as a waterproofing applicator. He had commenced working for his employer earlier that year. The appellant was accompanied on the cruise by his girlfriend and his two children. Present also that day, as part of this group, was the appellant’s friend, Mark Reece and Mr Reece’s wife and children. One of those children was in recovery from a recent surgery for a brain tumour. The ship used for the cruise on 2 December 2006 was a catamaran, the MV 2000. It was over 30 metres long. Its lower deck was able to carry a maximum of 184 passengers. Its upper deck was able to carry a maximum of 123 passengers. However, its overall maximum passenger capacity at any time was 270 persons. On 2 December 2006, the ship was staffed by a crew of 10. The crew comprised a manager (Mr Nicholls), a master or skipper, two senior crew members, five other crew members and one crew on duty person. The ship was controlled by its master. The crew wore identifiable uniforms. There were no special security arrangements. On 2 December 2006, the ship left the mainland carrying 111 passengers. All but four of those passengers belonged to one of two separate groups. The first group, comprising the appellant, his fellow employees and their families, consisted of 48 adults and 43 children. The second group, from a business known as Malouf Marine (“the Malouf group”), comprised around 20 adults. There was no designated separation of these groups on the ship.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

McLaren’s Landing was able to cater for dinners for large groups, including groups of up to 200 people. At McLaren’s Landing, there was a catering manager who was assisted by six other employees, in addition to crew members of the ship. These employees cooked and served meals, served drinks at the bar, and undertook cleaning or other duties (including assisting patrons at the venue). Both the ship and McLaren’s Landing were licensed premises under the Liquor Act 1992 (Qld).Evidence On 2 December 2006, the appellant’s employer engaged the respondent’s services to provide its employees and their families with a Christmas party cruise. The appellant was one such employee. He was 35 years of age, and employed as a waterproofing applicator. He had commenced working for his employer earlier that year. The appellant was accompanied on the cruise by his girlfriend and his two children. Present also that day, as part of this group, was the appellant’s friend, Mark Reece and Mr Reece’s wife and children. One of those children was in recovery from a recent surgery for a brain tumour. The ship used for the cruise on 2 December 2006 was a catamaran, the MV 2000. It was over 30 metres long. Its lower deck was able to carry a maximum of 184 passengers. Its upper deck was able to carry a maximum of 123 passengers. However, its overall maximum passenger capacity at any time was 270 persons. On 2 December 2006, the ship was staffed by a crew of 10. The crew comprised a manager (Mr Nicholls), a master or skipper, two senior crew members, five other crew members and one crew on duty person. The ship was controlled by its master. The crew wore identifiable uniforms. There were no special security arrangements. On 2 December 2006, the ship left the mainland carrying 111 passengers. All but four of those passengers belonged to one of two separate groups. The first group, comprising the appellant, his fellow employees and their families, consisted of 48 adults and 43 children. The second group, from a business known as Malouf Marine (“the Malouf group”), comprised around 20 adults. There was no designated separation of these groups on the ship. The arrangement was for the passengers of the ship to travel to McLaren’s Landing where they would enjoy various water sports and lunch. Lunch comprised seafood or a meat selection, together with vegetables and other items. Alcohol was available both on board the ship, and at McLaren’s Landing, through pre-ordered alcoholic drinks packages. The package for the appellant’s group included basic drinks only, not including spirits or premium drinks, from midday to 4.00 pm. The Malouf group also ordered a basic beverage package but it included basic spirits, again from 12 noon to 4.00 pm. The appellant’s group arrived at the mainland wharf by courtesy bus. They accessed the ship by a platform located at the stern, travelling through a gate onto an open cockpit area aft of the lower deck. They then climbed up a short flight of stairs into the lower deck cabin. At the top of those stairs passengers could either enter the main cabin area of the lower deck or proceed to access the upper deck using another set of stairs. The Malouf group boarded the ship at around this time. That group immediately travelled to the upper deck, where they remained for the trip to McLaren’s Landing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The steps that had been taken by the respondent rendered the premises as safe as reasonable care could make them. There were no further steps the respondent could reasonably be expected to take in all the circumstances. There was no suggestion the respondent sought to delegate responsibility for the taking of reasonable care in respect of foreseeable risk of injury to an entrant.Conclusion The trial judge made no material factual error. There was also no error of law. The trial judge correctly concluded the appellant’s claim must be dismissed.Orders I would order:1.The appeal be dismissed.2.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on a standard basis. FLANAGAN J: I agree with the orders proposed by Boddice J and with the reasons given by his Honour.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.