Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read
91 CLR 486

PACIFIC COAL COMPANY PROPRIETARY see ys WN 96 LIMITED

72 499

PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY (LIMI-

RESPONDENT. TED)

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Landlord and TenantRent-control-Coal-mine-Lease-Ren and royalty-Rate-

Amount payable-Calculation-Prices Regulation Order-Applicability-Plee ings-Demurrers-National Security Act 1939-1946, S. 5 (5)-National Security SYDNEY,

(Prices) Regulations-Prices Regulation Order No. 985-Reduction of Rents Act April 12, 13;

1931 (N.S.W.)--Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1932-1947 (N.S.W.), Aug. 20.

S. 15 (1)-Prices Regulation Act 1948 (N.S.W.), S. 2 (1).

By a lease made in 1919 the respondent leased to the appellant a coal mine for a term commencing on 1st September 1919 and ending on 1st September afferrate.

1962 at a fixed yearly rent of £819, payable quarterly, plus a royalty per ton which varied with the grade of coal mined. To the reservation of the 93.GLR.

fixed rent of £819 there was a proviso to the effect that the lessee should be 480.

at liberty to win coal to a quantity the royalty on which would be equal to affende:

that fixed rent, and that the royalty should be calculated only on coal won over and above that quantity. In an action in the Supreme Court of New 56 AC

South Wales the respondent claimed a balance of rent and royalty alleged 165.

to have accrued due in certain periods between 1st January 1932 and 31st December 1950. The appellant pleaded that the rent and royalty had, by various statutory enactments, been reduced by twenty-two and one-half per cent and that it had paid rent and royalty in full at the reduced rate. In respect of periods between 1st January 1932 and 31st December 1947 it relied on the Reduction of Rents Act 1931 (N.S.W.) and the Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1932-1947 (N.S.W.). On demurrer the pleas in respect of these periods were upheld by the Supreme Court, which decided that the royalties payable under the lease were "rent" within the meaning of the statutes. There was no appeal by the respondent against this decision.

91 CLR 487

In respect of later periods the appellant relied on Prices Regulation Order No. 985, which was made on 18th March 1943 by the Prices Commissioner in pursuance of the powers conferred upon him by the National Security (Prices) Regulations made under the National Security Act 1939-1940 (Cth.). This Order had effect under the National Security Act and regulations up to 20th September 1948. On and after that date it had effect under S. 2 (1) of the Prices Regulation Act 1948 (N.S.W.): see Brown v. Green (1951) 84 C.L.R. 285. Regulation 23 (2) of the National Security (Prices) Regulations authorized the commissioner by order to fix and declare the maximum rate at which any declared service might be supplied or carried on, and reg. 23 (2A) authorized him to fix " different maximum rates according to differences in the quality, description or volume of the service supplied or carried on ". By the Order the commissioner…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1954] HCA 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd (appellant) and Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd) (respondent) were parties to a dispute concerning rent and royalty payments owed under a coal mine lease. The respondent sued the appellant for an alleged balance of rent and royalty accrued between 1 January 1932 and 31 December 1950. The appellant contended that statutory enactments had reduced the amounts payable by 22.5%. The Supreme Court of New South Wales upheld the appellant's pleas regarding periods between 1 January 1932 and 31 December 1947, finding that royalties constituted "rent" under the relevant New South Wales legislation. However, the Supreme Court allowed demurrers to the appellant's pleas concerning later periods, which relied on a Commonwealth Prices Regulation Order. The appellant appealed this latter decision to the High Court.

The High Court was required to determine whether Prices Regulation Order No. 985, made under the National Security (Prices) Regulations, validly applied to the rent and royalties payable under the lease. Specifically, the Court needed to consider if the Order, which fixed maximum rates for mining rights based on amounts payable on 31 August 1939, was a valid exercise of the Commissioner's power, whether it applied retrospectively to a lease predating the Order, and how the "amount per ton of coal mined payable on 31 August 1939" should be calculated, particularly in light of the existing statutory deduction.

The High Court held that Prices Regulation Order No. 985 was a valid exercise of the Commissioner's power, interpreting the word "volume" in the regulations to include "quantity." The Court found that the Order applied to the rent and royalties under the lease, notwithstanding that the lease was entered into before the Order was made. Crucially, the Court determined that the "amount per ton of coal mined payable on 31 August 1939" referred to the amount reserved by the lease less the statutory deduction of 22.5% applicable at that time. Consequently, the High Court reversed the Supreme Court's decision regarding the demurrers to the pleas concerning the periods affected by the Prices Regulation Order, allowing the appellant's appeal in part.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.