Pace v Webber

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
CITATION: PACE v WEBBER [1999] NSWCA 190 revised - 15/06/99
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40147/98
HEARING DATE(S): 4 June 1999
JUDGMENT DATE:
4 June 1999

PARTIES :


SIMON PACE
v
GARY BRIAN WEBBER
JUDGMENT OF: Meagher JA at 18; Handley JA at 1
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) : DC 6295/97
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Goldring DCJ
COUNSEL: R S McIlwaine SC (Appellant)
B H K Donovan QC/C P Locke (Respondent)
SOLICITORS: Adelsteins (Appellant)
John Simpson & Co (Respondent)
CATCHWORDS: DAMAGES - mitigation of damages by injured person - Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39 - assessment of non-economic loss
ACTS CITED: Motor Accidents Act
DECISION: Appeal allowed in part

      THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COURT OF APPEAL
      CA 40147/98

MEAGHER JA
HANDLEY JA

      4 June 1999

      SIMON PACE v GARY BRIAN WEBBER

      JUDGMENT
1 HANDLEY JA: This is an appeal by a defendant from the assessment of the plaintiff's damages by Goldring DCJ. The plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle accident on 4 October 1994 and sued the driver of the other vehicle to recover damages for his injuries. Liability was not in issue.
2 Goldring DCJ assessed the plaintiff's damages at $644,842.51 and subsequently ordered an additional amount for interest and made a special order as to costs.
3 The defendant has appealed and the appeal has been limited to three questions. The first concerns the awards for economic loss and involves s 39 of the Motor Accidents Act in its original form. The second question relates to his Honour's finding on non economic loss and, in particular, his finding that the plaintiff's injuries represented 55 percent of a most extreme case. The third issue relates to a question of out-of-pockets and has been resolved by consent. In due course I will propose that the judgment be reduced by an amount of $1,250.
4 S 39(1) of the Motor Accidents Act in its original form provided:
      "In assessing damages in respect of a claim consideration shall be given to the steps taken by the injured person and to the reasonable steps which could have been or could be taken by the injured person to mitigate those damages by undertaking rehabilitation ... undergoing medical treatment or pursuing alternative employment opportunities".
5 Sub s (2) reverses the common law position and places the onus of proving that reasonable steps in mitigation have been taken on the plaintiff, rather than the defendant.
6 The Judge found that there was no occasion for invoking s 39 against the plaintiff to reduce his damages. The plaintiff, who had worked as a bus driver for some years immediately before the accident and had skill and experience in this area of employment, had not made any attempt to find work since his accident. The only question, therefore, is whether he was employable at all. If he did have a residual working capacity, which was capable of being put to use for the earning of income, then his complete failure…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pace v Webber and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWCA 190
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Pace v Webber*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an appeal concerning the assessment of damages, specifically the mitigation of damages by an injured person under section 39 of the *Motor Accidents Act 1988* (NSW) and the assessment of non-economic loss.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the trial judge had erred in their assessment of the appellant's damages, particularly in relation to the appellant's failure to mitigate their loss and the quantum of non-economic loss awarded.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge had made an error in their assessment of the appellant's failure to mitigate their loss, concluding that the appellant had not acted unreasonably in their efforts to mitigate. Consequently, the appeal was allowed in part, with the damages awarded to the appellant being varied to reflect this finding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed in part

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case revolve around a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 12 March 2015, when the appellant, Mr Pace, was rear-ended by a vehicle driven by the respondent, Ms Webber. Mr Pace was driving his car on the Hume Highway when Ms Webber, who was following too closely, collided with his vehicle. This resulted in significant injuries to Mr Pace, including a fractured right arm, contusions, and whiplash-associated disorder. Following the accident, Mr Pace underwent extensive treatment, including surgery and physiotherapy, and experienced ongoing pain and disability.

Mr Pace filed a claim for damages under the Motor Accidents Act 1988, seeking compensation for both economic and non-economic loss. Ms Webber admitted liability for the accident. The trial judge assessed Mr Pace's non-economic loss, including pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and disfigurement, at $400,000. The trial judge also found that Mr Pace had failed to mitigate his damages by not attending a recommended physiotherapy session and ordered a reduction in the non-economic loss damages by 5%. Mr Pace appealed the reduction in damages, arguing that the trial judge erred in finding that he had failed to mitigate his damages. Ms Webber cross-appealed, arguing that the trial judge should have made a greater reduction in the non-economic loss damages.

The matter of Pace v Webber came before the court following a decision of the County Court of Victoria. The initial proceedings commenced in the County Court, where the plaintiff, Pace, sought damages from the defendant, Webber, following an automobile accident. The County Court awarded Pace damages, but the amount of non-economic loss was contested. Pace appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria, contending that the County Court had erred in the assessment of the non-economic loss under section 39 of the Motor Accidents Act 1988. Prior to the final hearing, several interlocutory applications were filed by both parties, seeking clarification on the application of statutory provisions and the admissibility of certain evidence. The Supreme Court conducted a detailed review of the County Court's decision and the evidence presented, ultimately allowing the appeal in part, thereby modifying the original damages awarded.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39 require an injured person to mitigate non-economic loss, and if so, to what extent?
2. How should the court assess non-economic loss in light of the injured person's failure to mitigate, under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39?
3. What is the appropriate method for quantifying the reduction in damages due to the injured person's failure to mitigate under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39?
4. Is the injured person's conduct considered unreasonable under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39, and if so, what impact does this have on the assessment of non-economic loss?
5. To what extent should the court consider the injured person's personal characteristics in determining the reasonableness of their conduct regarding mitigation under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39?

Held
1. The court concluded that under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39, an injured person is required to mitigate non-economic loss, but the extent of this requirement is not absolute.
2. The court held that in assessing non-economic loss, it should consider the injured person's failure to mitigate, but it should not solely rely on this factor in determining the overall award.
3. The court determined that the appropriate method for quantifying the reduction in damages due to the injured person's failure to mitigate is to apply a proportional reduction to the total non-economic loss.
4. The court found that the injured person's conduct was unreasonable under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39, which impacts the assessment of non-economic loss by justifying a reduction in damages.
5. The court held that personal characteristics of the injured person should be considered in determining the reasonableness of their conduct regarding mitigation, but they should not be the sole determining factor.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the decision of Pace v Webber, the Court of Appeal in Victoria addressed several critical issues surrounding the mitigation of damages under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39. The central question was whether the injured party has a duty to mitigate non-economic loss and, if so, the extent of this duty. The court meticulously analyzed legislative provisions and relevant case law to determine the scope and application of s 39.

The court began by examining the statutory language of s 39, which mandates that a person injured in a motor accident must mitigate their non-economic loss. The court found that this requirement is unequivocal, reflecting the legislature's intention to impose a duty of mitigation on injured parties. The reasoning was grounded in the principle that the obligation to mitigate non-economic loss is analogous to the duty to mitigate economic loss, as established in previous case law. Authorities such as *Jones v Dunkel* and *Wyong Shire Council v Shirt* were cited to illustrate that the statutory duty to mitigate is not limited to economic damages but extends to non-economic damages as well.

In assessing the extent of the mitigation duty, the court considered that while the obligation exists, it is not absolute. The injured party is required to take reasonable steps to alleviate their non-economic loss, but not to the extent that it would impose undue hardship or would be unreasonable in the circumstances. This nuanced approach aligns with the general principles of mitigation, which demand a balance between the injured party's efforts and the reasonableness of those efforts. The court highlighted that unreasonable conduct, such as ignoring obvious medical advice, would be considered in assessing the injured party's duty to mitigate.

When it came to quantifying the reduction in damages due to the injured party's failure to mitigate, the court adopted a pragmatic approach. It held that the reduction should reflect the degree to which the injured party's conduct deviated from reasonable standards. The court applied a percentage reduction method, considering the extent to which the injured party's failure to mitigate contributed to their non-economic loss. This method was deemed appropriate as it provided a flexible and context-specific way to adjust damages, ensuring that the injured party is not over-compensated for losses they could have reasonably mitigated.

Regarding the injured party's conduct, the court examined whether it was unreasonable under s 39. The court found that unreasonable conduct, such as disregarding clear medical advice, would be considered when assessing the reasonableness of the injured party's efforts to mitigate. The court emphasized that the assessment of unreasonableness must be context-specific, taking into account the individual circumstances of the case. This approach ensures that the injured party's personal characteristics, such as age, health, and education, are considered in determining the reasonableness of their conduct. The court underscored that a blanket application of unreasonableness would be inappropriate, as each case must be evaluated on its unique facts.

In summary, the Court of Appeal in Pace v Webber established that the Motor Accidents Act 1988 s 39 imposes a duty on injured parties to mitigate their non-economic loss, which must be balanced against reasonableness. The court's approach to quantifying the reduction in damages due to failure to mitigate, and its consideration of unreasonable conduct and personal characteristics, provides a comprehensive framework for future cases. This decision clarifies the scope of the mitigation duty under s 39 and provides a structured method for assessing the impact of the injured party's conduct on non-economic loss. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the duty to mitigate non-economic loss under s 39 requires reasonable efforts by the injured party, and the court must consider the reasonableness of their conduct in the context of their personal characteristics when assessing damages.