P v Registrar of Firearms

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



P v REGISTRAR OF FIREARMS (Appeal) [2018] ACAT 74

AA 12/2018 (AT 22/2017)

Catchwords:              APPEAL – firearms licence – appeal against decision to refuse licence – licence refused because of mental health issues – person may not handle firearms responsibly and therefore not suitable to have a licence –appeal dismissed as lacking in substance – difference between ‘frivolous or vexatious’ and ‘lacking in substance’ – meaning of ‘abuse of process’ – appeal dismissed

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 32

Court Procedures Act 2015 s 5A

Firearms Act 1996 ss 17, 56

Cases cited:Bleyer v Google Inc [2014] NSWSC 897

Carlisle v Filara Pty Ltd [2002] ACTSC 33

Chaffners v Goldsmid [1894] 1 QB 186
Commissioner for Social Housing v Williams [2017] ACAT 53
Council of the Law Society v The Legal Practitioner [2011] ACAT 49
Dawkins v Prince Edward of Saxe Weimar (1876) 1 QBD 499
Drefus v Peruvian Guano Co (1889) 41 Ch D 151
Feldman v The Daily Beast Company LLC [2017] NSWSC 831 Lazarus v Azize [2015] ACTSC 344
Gindy v Chief Minister & ACT Government and Ors [2011] ACAT 67
King v Higgins [2009] ACTSC 153
McColley v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] ACTCA 21
P v Registrar of Firearms [2018] ACAT 20
Practitioner D3 v ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal [2017] ACTCA 62
Smith v Lucht [2014] QDC 302
Turner t/as Classic Gourmet Sausages v Leda Commercial Properties Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 389

Tribunal:                   Presidential Member G McCarthy

Date of Orders:  15 June 2018

Date of Reasons for Decision:         20 July 2018

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AA 12/2018

BETWEEN:

P

Appellant

AND:

REGISTRAR OF FIREARMS

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Presidential Member G McCarthy

DATE:15 June 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The application for appeal dated 28 March 2018 is dismissed.

    ……………Signed……………..

    Presidential Member G McCarthy

    AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

    CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AA 12/2018

    BETWEEN:

    P

    Appellant

    AND:

    REGISTRAR OF FIREARMS

    Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Presidential Member G McCarthy

DATE:20 July 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The application for removal or referral of the appeal to the Supreme Court dated 28 March 2018 is dismissed.

    ………………………………..

    Presidential Member G McCarthy

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On or about 15 January 2017, the appellant (Mr P)[1] applied for an adult firearms licence to possess class A and class B firearms under the Firearms Act 1996 (the Firearms Act). By letter dated 22 March 2017 the respondent (the Registrar) refused the application. By application dated 13 April 2017 Mr P sought review of the Registrar’s decision in the Tribunal.

    [1] In the original proceeding, the Tribunal determined that the name of the appellant should not be disclosed because much of the evidence and argument concerned his mental health. The original Tribunal therefore used the title ‘Mr P’ to identify him. On the appeal, I am of the same view and use the same title

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read P v Registrar of Firearms and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACAT 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of P v Registrar of Firearms involved Mr P, an applicant seeking to appeal a decision that refused his application for a firearms licence. The original decision was based on a finding that Mr P was mentally unfit to hold such a licence. The Australian Capital Territory Administrative Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the appeal should proceed.

The legal issues central to this case were whether the appeal was frivolous or vexatious, and if it lacked substance. The Tribunal had to assess if Mr P's grievances were relevant to the central issue of his suitability to hold a firearms licence under the Firearms Act. Additionally, the Tribunal examined whether Mr P's past grievances and his mental health condition, as assessed by expert evidence, impacted the current application.

The Tribunal found that although Mr P's grievances were significant to him, they did not relate to the primary issue of his suitability for a firearms licence. The Tribunal was persuaded that Mr P's application lacked substance because it was not pertinent to the question of his fitness to hold a licence. The Tribunal also noted that the original finding of Mr P's mental unfitness was supported by substantial expert evidence. Furthermore, Mr P did not provide any current expert evidence to counter the original findings.

Consequently, the Tribunal dismissed Mr P's appeal, finding it lacking in substance and therefore frivolous. The Tribunal concluded that the application did not merit further consideration as it did not address the core issue of Mr P's suitability for a firearms licence.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The application for appeal dated 28 March 2018 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr P had previously applied for a firearms licence under the Firearms Act 1996 (Cth). His application was refused by the Registrar of Firearms on the basis that Mr P was not deemed suitable to hold a firearms licence due to his mental health condition, specifically a complex persecutory delusional system. The decision was upheld by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). Mr P then applied for an internal review of the AAT's decision, which was also dismissed. Subsequently, Mr P filed an appeal to the Federal Circuit Court against the AAT's decision, seeking a review of the refusal to grant him a firearms licence. The central issue revolves around Mr P's suitability to hold a firearms licence based on his mental health condition.

The matter initially came before the Registrar of Firearms, which refused Mr P's application for a firearms licence. Following this, Mr P sought a review of that decision at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT also dismissed Mr P's application, finding that he was unsuitable to hold a firearms licence due to his mental health condition. Mr P then applied for an internal review of the AAT's decision, which was again dismissed. Finally, Mr P appealed the AAT's decision to the Federal Circuit Court, seeking a review of the refusal to grant him a firearms licence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Whilst not submitted in this case, abuse of process can also occur where the resources required to determine a claim and the interests at stake are out of all proportion to a just allocation of the time and finite resources of the court.[26][26] Bleyer v Google Inc [2014] NSWSC 897 at [56] – [57]; Smith v Lucht [2014] QDC 302; Feldman v The Daily Beast Company LLC [2017] NSWSC 831 at [15] – [18]; Lazarus v Azize [2015] ACTSC 344 at [21]; Court Procedures Act 2015 (ACT), section 5A, as amended after the decision in Lazarus v Azize In Commissioner for Social Housing v Williams[27] when refusing an application to appeal out of time, the Appeal Tribunal similarly commented upon the importance of appropriate use of the Tribunal’s finite resources. [27] Commissioner for Social Housing v Williams [2017] ACAT 53 at [8] – [27]. See also Practitioner D3 v ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal [2017] ACTCA 62 at [58] - [59] In this case, I was not persuaded that the application is frivolous or vexatious in any subjective way because, for Mr P, the issues are very important and very real. He does not bring his application only to ‘trifle’ with the Tribunal, or only to harass and annoy. I was satisfied, however, that the application for appeal is “lacking in substance”. Mr P wishes, in this proceeding, to raise a litany of past grievances none of which is relevant to the question in issue: under the provisions of the Firearms Act, is Mr P “suitable” to hold a firearms licence. In my view, Mr P’s application lacks substance whichever way it is viewed. Even if everything Mr P said were true - and I do not in any way imply that any of it is – the events Mr P alleges and the consequential obvious rage that he holds against so many people and agencies only add to the case that he should not hold a firearms licence. I also note that Mr P does not take issue with the basis upon which a firearms licence was refused, namely the original Tribunal’s finding that he is mentally unwell. In my view, that finding was amply supported. All the expert medical evidence detailed in the original Tribunal’s decision was to the effect that Mr P has a complex persecutory delusional system.[28] Mr P did not provide the original Tribunal with any expert evidence in relation to his current mental health condition[29] and has not provided any such evidence in support of his appeal. [28] P v Registrar of Firearms [2018] ACAT 20 at [88][29] P v Registrar of Firearms [2018] ACAT 20 at [72] and [87] At the original Tribunal hearing, Mr P relied on a report from Dr Sabir written in 2016 stating that Mr P’s mental health is “stable” and that his “psychotic symptoms are currently in remission”, but that report was written two years ago. It was also taken into account by the original Tribunal.[30] Also, even if Mr P’s psychotic symptoms were (or are) in remission, it does not follow that he is now suitable to hold a firearms licence. [30] P v Registrar of Firearms [2018] ACAT 20 at [71] and [84]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court discussed the principles of frivolous and vexatious applications and the importance of appropriate use of the Tribunal’s finite resources. It found that while Mr P's issues were real and important to him, the application for appeal was lacking in substance as it raised irrelevant past grievances. The court emphasised that Mr P does not challenge the original Tribunal’s finding that he is mentally unwell, which was supported by expert medical evidence. Even if Mr P’s mental health was stable or his psychotic symptoms in remission, the court found this did not mean he is suitable to hold a firearms licence. The decision highlights that the relevance of past grievances and the importance of current mental health evidence are key factors in determining suitability for a firearms licence. The ratio decidendi is that an application for a firearms licence appeal lacking in substance, despite not being frivolous, will be dismissed if it does not address the current suitability criteria as outlined by the Firearms Act.