IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted AT MELBOURNE
COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION
No. 6515 of 2000
P & V INDUSTRIES PTY LTD
(ACN 005 032 600) (formerly Porto & Valente Industries Pty Ltd (ACN 005 032 600)
AND ORSPlaintiffs v ANTHONY PORTO AND ORS
(ACN 094 615 657)Defendants ---
JUDGE:
MASTER EVANS
WHERE HELD:
MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING:
29 July, 11 August, 1 and 8 September 2004; and
14 and 15 February 2005.
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
15 April 2005
CASE MAY BE CITED AS:
P & V Industries Pty Ltd v Porto
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
[2005] VSC 104
---
PRACTICE PROCEDURE – Discovery – Production – Legal professional privilege – Formulation of claim – Waiver – Express – Implied – Communications in furtherance of civil ‘fraud’ not privileged.
---
APPEARANCES:
Counsel Solicitors For the Plaintiffs Mr J. Hammond, Q.C. with
Mr D. MaselSeacombs Solicitors For the First and Seventh Defendants Mr R. Cameron on 29/7/04
Mr P. Collinson on 11/8/04, 1/9/04, 8/9/04, 14/2/05 and 15/2/05Kingdon Lawyers For the Fourth Defendant Mr T. Boston Minter Ellisoin Lawyers For the Fifth and Sixth Defendants Mr I. Waller Isakow Lawyers HIS HONOUR:
The Proceeding
1 In this proceeding the plaintiffs allege, among other things, that:-
(i)The first plaintiff, P & V Industries Pty. Ltd. (‘P & V’) is and was at all material times trustee of the Porto and Valente Unit Trust.
(ii)Each of the 2nd-10th plaintiffs (‘the unitholders’) are and were at all material times –
(a)unitholders in that trust;
(b)engaged in business as a property developer and/or as an investor in property development.
(iii)P & V provided services to and acquired benefits for those unitholders in their business.
(iv)Anthony Porto (‘Porto’) the first defendant –
(a)from about 11 September 1989, to about 30 May 1997, was employed by P & V;
(b)from about 1990 to about 30 May 1997, was employed by P & V as its Land Development Manager;
(c)from about 5 September 1990, to about 22 May 1997, was company secretary of P & V;
(d)from 2 February 1993 to about 22 May 1997, was a director of P & V;
(e)was an officer of the other plaintiffs;
(f)had duties as an employee, director and officer which included reporting to P & V all opportunities for property development which were or might be worthy of consideration for purchase and/or development by P & V or by or on behalf of the unitholders;
(g)as an employee, director and officer had duties, fiduciary duties and a duty to act in accordance with S232 (2), (4), (5) and (6) of the Corporations Law which he owed to P & V.
(v)The second defendant, Garry Lawes (‘Garry’) and the third defendant, Stephen Lawes (‘Stephen’) knew, at all material times, of the matters referred to in paragraph (i)-(iv) above.
(vi)The fourth defendant, Kennedy Guy (‘the solicitors’) –
(a)from about 1994, until about late 1998, was the firm acting as solicitors to P & V and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read P & V Industries Pty Ltd v Porto and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] VSC 104
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the communications were protected by legal professional privilege and whether any waiver of that privilege had occurred. Specifically, the court needed to consider if the privilege applied to communications made in furtherance of a civil 'fraud'. The court had to evaluate whether the privilege was waived either expressly or impliedly.
The court found that the privilege did not apply to communications made in furtherance of a civil 'fraud'. It held that there was no implied waiver of the privilege by the party seeking discovery. However, the court did find an express waiver in the form of a statement by the solicitor that the privilege was waived in relation to the documents in question. As a result, the court ordered the production of the documents, ruling that the waiver of privilege was effective and binding.