P and D Bulte Pty Ltd v Seafare Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

23/1998

PARTIES:  P & D BULTE PTY LTD
  v
  SEAFARE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  259/1997
DELIVERED:  25 March 1998
HEARING DATE/S:  17 March 1998
JUDGMENT OF:  Slicer J

CATCHWORDS:

Interpretation - Admissibility of extrinsic evidence in relation to instruments - Matters particularly relating to contract - Collateral contracts - Consistency of collateral contract with main contract.

Esanda Ltd v Burgess (1984) 2 NSWLR 139, followed.
Aust Dig Interpretation [33]

Procedure - Supreme Court procedure - Tasmania - Practice under rule of court - Summary judgment - Action on deed - Existence of counterclaim.

Rules of the Supreme Court, O15.
Wallingford v The Director, etc, of the Mutual Society and the Official Liquidator Thereof (1880) 5 App Cas 685; James Lamont & Co Ld v Hyland Ld [1950] 1 KB 585, followed.
Aust Dig Procedure [270]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicant/Plaintiff:  M J Temple-Smith
             Respondent/Defendant:                   J L Dewar
Solicitors:
             Applicant/Plaintiff:  Temple-Smith Barclay
             Respondent/Defendant:                   Piggot Wood & Baker

Judgment category classification:
Court Computer Code:  
Judgment ID Number:  23/1998
Number of pages:  7

Serial No 23/1998
File No 259/1997

P & D BULTE PTY LTD v SEAFARE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  SLICER J

25 March 1998

The plaintiff seeks summary judgment for moneys due under a deed executed by itself and the defendant.  The defendant does not deny that the money is due, but contends that there is no requirement to pay until the plaintiff performs certain obligations stated in the agreement.

The plaintiff was at all material times engaged in the business of boat repairs and the retail of marine equipment.  It had undertaken the refit of a fishing vessel owned or operated by the defendant.  Following the completion of the work, there was disputation concerning the standard of workmanship and the entitlement of the plaintiff to the sum claimed.  Following negotiations conducted by telephone, correspondence and a meeting, the plaintiff forwarded a draft deed to the defendant which contained the terms of settlement as understood by the plaintiff.  The defendant replied in the following terms:

"Thank you for your fax 11.11.96
Changes that should be made.

The item's (sic) in my letter to you on the 23 May 1998 should be included.  It was agreed that these would be repaired at your cost.

A price should be put on the repairs and if the work is not done then that amount would come off the total owed to Bulte.

The Agreement Recital

A        Agreed

BShould be deleted.  Seafare is not entering into this agreement because of any threat of legal action.

CAgreed

DAgreed

The Deed

1Agreed

2Amend - from the 31 January 1997.

a    Agreed
b    Amend
c    Agreed

3         Agreed

4         Agreed"

It would appear that an amended draft was forwarded to the defendant since the amendments proposed by the defendant have been incorporated into the executed document.  The deed was executed by the defendant and returned to the plaintiff.  At the same time, a facsimile was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read P and D Bulte Pty Ltd v Seafare Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] TASSC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

P & D Bulte Pty Ltd initiated legal proceedings against Seafare Australia Pty Ltd, seeking summary judgment for moneys due under a deed. The dispute revolves around the interpretation of the deed and whether the defendant is obligated to pay the plaintiff until certain warranty work is completed. The Supreme Court of Tasmania was tasked with determining the admissibility of extrinsic evidence and the consistency of any collateral contracts with the main contract terms.

The court examined whether the defendant could rely on a collateral contract or an implied term that payment of the moneys due under the deed was conditional upon the performance of the warranty work. The court found that the defendant had not provided sufficient evidence to establish the existence of such a collateral contract or implied term. The affidavit provided by the defendant's director did not particularise the facts necessary to support the claim of a collateral contract. Additionally, the court concluded that the terms of the deed were clear and unambiguous, and any collateral contract would have to be consistent with and not contradict the main agreement. The court also noted that the defendant's actions of making initial payments were inconsistent with the claim that payment was conditional upon the performance of the warranty work.

The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to summary judgment. The court determined that the defendant was conclusively bound by the terms of the deed, which required the payment of a debt already incurred. The court found that the defendant was not entitled to avoid its obligation to pay the moneys due under the deed based on a separate claim regarding the warranty work. The court also noted that the defendant's counterclaim for damages for a claimed breach of the warranty work was a separate issue that could be pursued independently of the plaintiff's claim for moneys due.

The court granted judgment in favour of the plaintiff, ordering the defendant to pay the sum of $25,734, which included the debt of $21,885, interest up to 23 May 1997 in the sum of $2,013, and further interest at the rate of $6 per day from 25 March 1998. The court emphasised that the entry of judgment in favour of the plaintiff would not affect the defendant's right to pursue its counterclaim.

Background

Background to the litigation

P & D Bulte Pty Ltd, a company engaged in boat repairs and the retail of marine equipment, completed a refit of a fishing vessel owned or operated by Seafare Australia Pty Ltd. Following the completion of the work, there was a dispute concerning the standard of workmanship and the plaintiff's entitlement to the sum claimed. After negotiations conducted by telephone, correspondence, and a meeting, the plaintiff forwarded a draft deed to the defendant containing the terms of settlement as understood by the plaintiff. The defendant replied with suggested changes, which were later incorporated into the executed deed. The deed provided for a repayment plan and outlined the warranty work to be completed by the plaintiff.

The defendant made payments totalling $20,000 but ceased further payments, claiming that the plaintiff had failed to complete the warranty work. The plaintiff, in turn, claimed that it remained willing to complete the warranty work but that the defendant had not made the vessel available for the work to be carried out. The plaintiff commenced proceedings for the recovery of the remaining debt. In its defence, the defendant claimed that payment of the moneys was conditional upon the plaintiff completing the warranty work. The defendant also claimed that there existed a collateral contract and that a term could be implied by the conduct of the parties that payment was dependent on the performance of the warranty work.

The defendant provided evidence by way of affidavit, which traversed grounds wider than those pleaded in its defence. The plaintiff contended that the defendant should be confined to its own pleading and not be permitted to advance additional matters. However, the Court held that the defendant was entitled to put material to the Court, in addition to its pleadings, showing cause why the application should not be granted. The defendant claimed that there existed a separate collateral contract, but the Court found that the evidence did not establish such a claim. The Court also concluded that there was no arguable case involving the existence of an implied term that payment of the debt was dependent on completion of the warranty work.

The Court considered the interpretation of the deed and concluded that the terms were inconsistent with an interpretation that payments should not commence until after the completion of the warranty work. The Court further held that the defendant was conclusively bound by what it stated in the deed it would undertake, namely, the payment of a debt already incurred, by means of instalments. The Court held that the plaintiff was entitled to summary judgment for the debt of $21,885 and interest calculated up to 23 May 1997 in the sum of $2,013, and thereafter at the rate of $6 per day.

P & D Bulte Pty Ltd v Seafare Australia Pty Ltd originated as a proceeding in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, file number 259/1997, where the plaintiff sought summary judgment against the defendant for monies owed under a deed executed between the parties. The matter came before Slicer J on 17 March 1998, with judgment delivered on 25 March 1998. The plaintiff, a boat repair and marine equipment retailer, had completed refitting a fishing vessel for the defendant. Following disputes over the standard of workmanship and the debt owed, the parties executed a deed of settlement on 10 February 1997. The deed stipulated that the defendant would repay the debt in monthly instalments, with interest, and required the plaintiff to perform certain warranty work, contingent upon the vessel being delivered to the plaintiff’s premises. The defendant made partial payments before ceasing, asserting that further payments were contingent upon the plaintiff completing the warranty work. The plaintiff, denying any such condition, applied for summary judgment on 7 August 1997. During the summary judgment hearing, the defendant sought to introduce evidence of a collateral contract and implied terms suggesting that payment was conditional on completing the warranty work. The plaintiff argued that the defendant should be limited to the pleadings, and the court considered whether the evidence presented constituted a sufficient defence. The court ultimately found that the defendant had not established an arguable case for a collateral contract or implied term that would preclude the plaintiff from obtaining summary judgment. The central issue revolved around the interpretation of the deed, with the court concluding that the obligation to pay the debt was independent of the warranty work. The court granted the plaintiff's application for summary judgment, finding that the defendant was bound by the terms of the deed to pay the debt as agreed, without requiring performance of the warranty work as a precondition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the deed requires performance of the warranty work as a pre-condition to the payment of moneys.
2. Whether a collateral contract existed which made payment conditional on the performance of the warranty work.
3. Whether an implied term can be read into the deed to make payment of the debt dependent on completion of the warranty work.
4. Whether there exists an arguable defence to the plaintiff's claim for summary judgment.
5. Whether the defendant is entitled to amend its defence and counterclaim in light of the evidence presented.

Held
1. Whether the deed requires performance of the warranty work as a pre-condition to the payment of moneys.
The court concluded that the deed does not require performance of the warranty work as a pre-condition to the payment of moneys; the payment of moneys was independent of the warranty work.

2. Whether a collateral contract existed which made payment conditional on the performance of the warranty work.
The court concluded that the defendant failed to establish an arguable case for the existence of a collateral contract that made payment conditional on the performance of the warranty work.

3. Whether an implied term can be read into the deed to make payment of the debt dependent on completion of the warranty work.
The court concluded that there was no arguable case for the existence of an implied term that made payment of the debt dependent on completion of the warranty work.

4. Whether there exists an arguable defence to the plaintiff's claim for summary judgment.
The court concluded that there was no arguable defence to the plaintiff's claim for summary judgment, and that the plaintiff was entitled to judgment.

5. Whether the defendant is entitled to amend its defence and counterclaim in light of the evidence presented.
The court concluded that the defendant was entitled to amend its defence and counterclaim in light of the evidence presented, as the Rules of Court permit such amendments.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the deed required the performance of warranty work as a pre-condition to the payment of moneys, the Court examined the terms of the deed. The deed provided for the payment of a quantified debt in instalments, with a fixed timeframe for repayment. Clause 5 of the deed, which referred to the warranty work, was independent of the payment provisions and did not operate as a pre-condition to the payment of moneys. The Court found that the terms of the deed did not support the defendant's contention that payment of moneys was dependent on the completion of the warranty work.

The Court also considered whether a collateral contract existed which made payment conditional on the performance of the warranty work. The Court found that the evidence presented did not establish the existence of a collateral contract. The defendant had made payments under the deed, which ran counter to the contention that payment of moneys was not required until the performance of the warranty work.

The Court also examined whether an implied term could be read into the deed to make payment of the debt dependent on the completion of the warranty work. The Court found that the terms of the deed were inconsistent with such an implied term and that there was no arguable case involving the existence of an implied term.

The Court further considered whether there existed an arguable defence to the plaintiff's claim for summary judgment. The Court found that the defendant had not established an arguable defence to the claim for moneys due under the deed. The defendant's counterclaim for compensation for a claimed breach of the warranty work was a separate issue and entitlement from the right of the plaintiff to enforce its claim for moneys due.

Finally, the Court considered whether the defendant was entitled to amend its defence and counterclaim in light of the evidence presented. The Court found that the defendant was entitled to seek leave to amend its defence and counterclaim, but that it was not entitled to rely on evidence beyond its pleadings and the terms of the deed.

In conclusion, the Court found that the plaintiff was entitled to summary judgment for the debt of $21,885, plus interest. The Court entered judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $25,734.