Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 3) [2016] FCA 253

File number(s): NSD 937 of 2014
Judge(s): YATES J
Date of judgment: 17 March 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – security for costs – where parties have previously agreed to the amount of security to be provided – where consent orders as to security for costs have previously been made – whether “top-up” security for costs should be ordered – amount of security to be provided for future costs  
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt IVA

Federal Court Rules 2011 Sch 3

Cases cited:

Federal Treasury Enterprise (FKP) Sojuzplodoimport v Spirits International B.V. (No 2) [2012] FCA 23

Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland [2015] FCA 1010

Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 2) [2015] FCA 1485

Date of hearing: 11 February 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 96
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr C Withers and Mr R May
Solicitor for the Applicant: Squire Patton Boggs
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr DB O’Sullivan QC with Mr J O’Regan
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

NSD 937 of 2014
BETWEEN:

OZTECH PTY LTD ACN 005 907 871

Applicant

AND:

THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND

Respondent

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 MARCH 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 31 March 2016, the applicant provide security for the respondent’s costs up to the commencement of the trial on 27 June 2016 in the amount of $925,265 by way of cash deposit with the Court. 

2.If the applicant does not provide security for costs in accordance with Order 1, the proceeding be stayed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

YATES J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. The respondent applies for orders that the applicant provide further security for his costs of the proceeding.  The respondent seeks security in the amount of $1,775,000, representing:

    ·“top-up” security for costs from 16 October 2014 to 1 September 2015, in the amount of $775,000; and

    ·security for costs from 1 September 2015 to the first day of the trial on 27 June 2015, in the amount of $1 million.

  2. The applicant accepts that the respondent has an entitlement to security for costs, specifically in relation to the respondent’s future costs.  The issues that divide the parties are whether the respondent is entitled, in the circumstances of this case, to the “top-up” security he claims and whether, in any event, the overall amount of the security that the respondent seeks is appropriate.

    BACKGROUND

  3. This proceeding is a representative proceeding commenced under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). It arises out of the respondent’s role as the trustee for noteholders in respect of senior unsecured notes issued by the company now called Octaviar Investment Notes Limited (in liquidation)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Oztech Pty Ltd has commenced a representative proceeding against the Public Trustee of Queensland, arising from the trustee's role as trustee for noteholders in respect of senior unsecured notes issued by Octaviar Investment Notes Limited (in liquidation). The applicant alleges that the trustee acted too slowly to protect the interests of noteholders. The applicant has already provided security for the respondent's costs. The respondent has now applied for further security in respect of future costs. The applicant accepts that the respondent is entitled to security for future costs but disputes the amount claimed, particularly in relation to "top-up" security. The court was required to decide whether the respondent was entitled to "top-up" security and, if so, the appropriate amount of security for future costs.

The court found that "top-up" security should not be granted, except for certain tasks, because the orders for security made in February and July 2015 were the result of negotiated outcomes. Each negotiated outcome was forward-looking and the parties advanced competing arguments as to what they considered to be the respondent's likely allowable costs on a party/party taxation for the specifically identified steps in the proceeding. The court found that the respondent could not have underestimated his then likely costs for these steps to the extent represented in the present application. The court found that the respondent was not entitled to "top-up" security for work covered by the first tranche of security and the applicant was entitled to proceed on the reasonable expectation that there would be no re-visiting of the question of security in respect of work covered by the first tranche. The court found that the respondent, or at least his solicitors, must have had a fair idea of the level at which costs were running for the tasks that were intended to be covered by the second tranche of security, particularly in relation to discovery. The court found that the applicant was entitled to provide security for the respondent's costs up to the commencement of the trial on 27 June 2016 in the amount of $925,265 by way of cash deposit with the Court. If the applicant does not provide security for costs in accordance with the order, the proceeding be stayed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 31 March 2016, the applicant provide security for the respondent’s costs up to the commencement of the trial on 27 June 2016 in the amount of $925,265 by way of cash deposit with the Court.

2. If the applicant does not provide security for costs in accordance with Order 1, the proceeding be stayed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant accepts that the respondent has an entitlement to security for costs, specifically in relation to the respondent’s future costs. The issues that divide the parties are whether the respondent is entitled, in the circumstances of this case, to the “top-up” security he claims and whether, in any event, the overall amount of the security that the respondent seeks is appropriate.BACKGROUND This proceeding is a representative proceeding commenced under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). It arises out of the respondent’s role as the trustee for noteholders in respect of senior unsecured notes issued by the company now called Octaviar Investment Notes Limited (in liquidation) (OIN). A company now called Octaviar Limited (receivers and managers appointed) (in liquidation) (OL) was a guarantor of OIN’s obligations under the notes. The applicant alleges that, following a sharp drop in OL’s share price in January 2008, and OL’s sale of a business (the Stella Group) which was completed on 29 February 2008, the respondent acted too slowly to protect the interests of noteholders, in particular by failing to apply to wind-up OIN and OL, and to take other steps, by 29 February 2008. The alleged consequence is that the respondent breached his statutory, contractual and general law duties to noteholders. The applicant is funded by International Litigation Partners No. 9 Pte. Ltd. (ILP), a litigation funder (described in a company search as an “other investment holding [company]”) incorporated in Singapore. There is no evidence that it has assets in Australia. ILP was incorporated on 4 September 2014, just before the commencement of this proceeding. It has issued one ordinary share to Robustus Pte. Ltd., another company incorporated in Singapore. The applicant has already provided security for the respondent’s costs. The evidence reveals that this security was provided following periods of extensive negotiation between the parties. On 27 November 2014, the Court made an order that, by 11 December 2014, the parties confer with a view to agreeing on the amount payable by the applicant for security for costs. On 19 December 2014, in the absence of agreement having then been reached, the respondent filed an interlocutory application seeking an order for security for costs in the amount of $2,491,629. However, agreement was eventually reached and, on 16 February 2015, at the request of the parties, the Court made an order by consent that, within 28 days, the applicant provide security for the respondent’s costs up to the close of pleadings, in the amount of $200,000. The evidence in the present application shows that, in coming to this agreement, the parties also agreed that, should the respondent make further application for security, then: ·to the extent that the amount already paid as security exceeded the amount that might be recoverable as party/party costs on a taxation by the respondent, the applicant may seek to have that amount taken into account with respect to any future security payable; and·to the extent that the amount already paid as security was less than the amount that might be recoverable as party/party costs on a taxation by the respondent, the respondent may seek to have the shortfall in security taken into account with respect to any future security payable.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant provided the following example to illustrate this particular problem. Mr Sharry has deposed that a fee earner at Partner level has spent 262.9 hours undertaking discovery. Mr Garrett has allowed 910 hours of Partner time in his report, but has not identified the tasks to which the 910 hours have been allocated. It is not clear, therefore, whether Mr Garrett has allowed 262.9 hours of Partner time for discovery or whether he has made reductions from Partner time for that task. The same problem applies in respect of each of the phases of work for which the respondent is seeking “top-up” security. The applicant’s evidence In an affidavit sworn on 28 January 2016, the applicant’s solicitor, Amanda Kim Banton, has taken issue with Mr Sharry’s identification of the work that he says was new and different work which, at the time of providing his assumptions, he did not foresee. Ms Banton says that a number of these tasks were included in the assumptions and information provided to Mr Garrett and considered by Mr Garrett in his earlier reports, that were used by the respondent in coming to an agreement on the earlier orders for the provision of security. Ms Banton has analysed the schedule in Mr Sharry’s affidavit (to which I have referred) and another document prepared by Mr Sharry which provides further explanation of the variances on which the respondent relies for its “top-up” security. In paragraphs 66 to 124 of her affidavit, Ms Banton has undertaken a critique of the work performed for the respondent and of the fees charged for this work. Ms Banton has expressed the opinion that if I came to the view that such further security should be provided, then the amount of $70,413.57 would be reasonable as “top-up” security. I will not seek to summarise all the criticisms and comments made by Ms Banton. It is nevertheless convenient that I refer to some matters that feature in the applicant’s submissions: ·The respondent incurred costs of $111,465.80 in respect of the “initial scoping” of the applicant’s claim (the statement of claim was 31 pages in length) and attending a directions hearing on 27 November 2014 by video link, which lasted for three minutes.·The respondent incurred costs of $714,654.20 in preparing its defence (the defence is 79 pages in length). This is said to have involved 718.8 hours of Partner time (the equivalent of 102 days at seven hours per day) as well as 189.1 hours of Senior Associate time (the equivalent of 27 days at seven hours per day) on the same tasks, and Counsel’s fees of $201,681, as well as the time of other professional staff (at Special Counsel, Lawyer and Graduate Lawyer rates). The respondent claims security for part of these costs ($476,436.14).·The respondent incurred costs of $107,542.20 in respect of its first security for costs application (see [5]-[7] above).·The respondent incurred costs of $86,293.19 for a directions hearing on 25 May 2015. The directions hearing lasted for approximately 30 minutes.·The respondent incurred costs of $133,748.20 in respect of a so-called “common fund” application which was foreshadowed by the applicant, but not proceeded with. The applicant says that such an application, had it been successfully made, really had nothing to do with the respondent in any event because it would have concerned the question of how the cost of the funding provided by ILP was to be shared among group members.·The respondent incurred costs of $518,893.85 in respect of the giving of discovery. This work included reviewing approximately 32,000 hardcopy and electronic records held by the respondent. The giving of discovery is said to have involved 1,361.6 hours of work (the equivalent of 194 days at seven hours per day). This included 262.9 hours of Partner time (the equivalent of more than 37 days at seven hours per day); 330 hours of Senior Associate time (the equivalent of more than 47 days at seven hours per day); 117.9 hours of Lawyer time (the equivalent of approximately 17 days at seven hours per day); and 125.3 of Graduate Lawyer time (the equivalent of approximately 18 days at seven hours per day.·The respondent incurred costs of $38,597.80 in respect of its second security for costs application (see [9]-[12] above).·The respondent incurred costs of $46,327.10 for a directions hearing on 29 July 2015. The directions hearing lasted for approximately 20 minutes.·The respondent incurred costs of $267,285.98 in respect of two interlocutory applications the subject of the reasons given in Oztech Pty Ltd v Public Trustee of Queensland [2015] FCA 1010. Apart from Counsels’ fees of $149,785, the two applications, which were heard on the one day, were said to have involved 131.6 hours of Partner time (the equivalent of 18.8 days at seven hours per day) and 93.5 hours of Senior Associate time (the equivalent of 13.4 days at seven hours per day).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant submits that if, contrary to its submission, the Court is persuaded that “top-up” security should be given, the amount claimed by the respondent is manifestly excessive. In that connection, the applicant refers to the amounts I have noted at [29] above, and says that costs, in these amounts, and in the amounts claimed for other work, would not be allowable on a party/party taxation. Consideration I am not persuaded that “top-up” security should be granted other than for certain tasks to which I refer below. The orders for security for costs made in February and July 2015 were the result of negotiated outcomes. Each negotiated outcome was forward-looking, in the sense that the orders for security made in February 2015 were for costs up to the close of pleadings and the orders made in July 2015 were for costs from the close of the pleadings to the case management conference listed for 1 September 2015. On each occasion, the parties advanced competing arguments as to what they considered to be the respondent’s likely allowable costs on a party/party taxation for the specifically identified steps in the proceeding. In a letter dated 13 February 2015, the respondent’s solicitors identified what they regarded to be the relevant steps to be taken up to the close of pleadings, and summarised the parties’ competing positions on the costs for each step. Those steps were identified as: Defence; Particulars (which includes the Reply); Amended Statement of Claim and Defence; and Security for Costs. In a letter dated 10 July 2015, the respondent’s solicitors identified what they regarded to be the relevant steps to be taken from the close of pleadings up to the case management hearing appointed for 1 September 2015 and, once again, summarised the parties’ competing positions on the costs of each step. Those steps were identified as: Notice to Group Members; Opt Out Notice Application; Security for Costs; Discovery; Case Management Conference; Correspondence; Telephone attendances; and Care and Consideration. I do not understand how, at the time of these negotiations, the respondent could have underestimated his then likely costs for these steps to the extent represented in the present application. Apart from the experience and expertise of his solicitors, he was assisted in formulating his position by Mr Garrett’s reports. He also had the competing views advanced by the applicant’s solicitors, who were assisted by Ms Higinbotham’s reports. Moreover, at the time that negotiations were in progress for the second tranche of security, the respondent must have known that his actual costs for work referable to the first tranche of security were well in excess of the considered view that had been taken in February 2015. At that time, the respondent did not seek “top-up” security for work covered by the first tranche. In the circumstances, the applicant was entitled to proceed on the reasonable expectation that there would be no re-visiting of the question of security in respect of work covered by the first tranche. Furthermore, at that time, the respondent, or at least his solicitors, must have had a fair idea of the level at which costs were running for the tasks that were intended to be covered by the second tranche of security, particularly in relation to discovery.