OZI Tax Advisors Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

OZI Tax Advisors Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board [2023] AATA 2066 (14 July 2023)

Division:TAX AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:          2023/2886 & 2023/3136

Re:OZI Tax Advisors Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndOsama Suriya

APPLICANT

AndTax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal: Senior Member D K Grigg

Date:14 July 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Applicants’ applications for a stay pursuant to section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) are refused.

The interim stay granted on 12 May 2023 is discharged.

...............................[SGD]...................................

Senior Member D K Grigg

TAX AGENT REGISTRATION – TERMINATION OF APPLICANTS’ REGISTRATIONS AS TAX AGENTS – APPLICATION FOR A STAY PENDING DECISION UNDER REVIEW – PROSPECTS OF SUCCESS – PUBLIC INTEREST – STAY APPLICATIONS REFUSED

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

CASE LAW

Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 890

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; 11 FLR 203; 2 ALD 634

Re Su and Tax Agents’ Board of South Australia [1982] AATA 127; 82 ATC 4284; 13 ATR 192; 61 FLR 1

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Explanatory Paper TPB (EP) 02/0210: "Fit and proper person"

Explanatory Paper TPB (EP) 01/0210: "Code of Professional Conduct"

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D K Grigg

14 July 2023

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Osama Suriya has been operating as a registered tax agent for just over four years. He is 34 years old and the sole director and controlling mind of OZI Tax Advisers Pty Ltd (“OZI”).

  2. On 31 March 2022, the Tax Practitioners Board (“TPB”) wrote to Mr Suriya, as director of OZI, to advise that it would be investigating his and OZI’s conduct regarding a possible breach of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (“TASA”).[1] The TPB had received a complaint regarding the authenticity of financial information contained within income tax returns (“ITR”) provided by the Applicant to mortgage brokers, including a broker called Strategic Lending Partners (“SLP”).[2]

    [1] T Documents, T3, pages 17-18, T12, 874-875, TPB’s Notice of decision to investigate dated 31 March 2022.

    [2] T Documents, T14, pages 929-931, Complaint of Amanda Stirling dated 29 April 2021.

  3. The TPB requested the Applicants provide information regarding:[3]

(a)what steps he had taken to verify information with his clients before preparing the financial documents;

(b)if he compared the information he was providing to Mr Prasad from SLP against that which was available to him on Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”) systems as the tax agent; and

(c)what steps he has taken subsequently to amend the ITRs for the years for which he identified incorrect figures.

[3] T Documents, T6, pages 161-167, Letter from TPB regarding preliminary enquiries into conduct dated 31 March 2023, page 165.

  1. Mr Suriya told the Respondent that:[4]

(a)he relied upon the information provided by the clients;

(b)the financial documents he prepared were drafts; and

(c)he was still waiting on information from some…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read OZI Tax Advisors Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2066
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned applications for a stay of decisions by the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) to terminate the tax agent registrations of OZI Tax Advisors Pty Ltd and Mr Osama Suriya. The applications were brought before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) under section 41(2) of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth). The TPB had determined that Mr Suriya, as the director of OZI Tax Advisors Pty Ltd and in his personal capacity, had failed to comply with subsections 30-10(1) and 30-10(7) of the Code of Professional Conduct, and consequently no longer met the requirements for registration as a tax practitioner, specifically the requirement to be a "fit and proper person" under section 20-5(1)(a) of the *Tax Agent Services Act 2009* (Cth) (TASA).

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether to grant a stay of the TPB's termination decisions pending the final determination of the review applications. In considering these applications, the Tribunal was required to assess the prospects of success of the review applications and the balance of the public interest. The TPB's decisions were based on findings that Mr Suriya had provided significantly different financial figures to a broker compared to those lodged with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) for the 2019 financial year, and had failed to lodge amended income tax returns or notify relevant parties of these discrepancies.

The Tribunal considered the applicants' submissions, which highlighted the severe financial and personal hardship that the termination of registration would cause, including the inability to work in the industry and meet financial commitments. The applicants argued that the incident was a careless mistake, that changes had been made to systems and policies, and that Mr Suriya was remorseful and willing to provide security to abide by TPB rules. However, the Tribunal found that the explanation provided by Mr Suriya regarding the discrepancies in financial figures did not adequately address the reasons for the differing reports and the lack of subsequent action. The Tribunal noted that a reasonable tax practitioner should have been aware of the unusual nature of the request for amended returns with significantly different figures and should have taken steps to notify the broker or financial institution of the discrepancies.

Ultimately, the Tribunal refused the applications for a stay. The refusal was based on the assessment that the applicants had not demonstrated a strong likelihood of success on the merits of their review applications, and that the public interest, which includes upholding the integrity of the tax agent profession and protecting the public from practitioners who do not meet the required standards, weighed against granting a stay. The termination of Mr Suriya's registration was therefore to take effect as scheduled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The TPB advised Mr Suriya on 21 April 2023 that it had decided that he had also failed to comply with subsections 30-10(1) and 30‑10(7) of the Code and that he no longer met the tax practitioner requirements for registration as he was not a “fit and proper person” as required by section 20-5(1)(a) of the TASA. As a result of that decision the TPB decided to terminate Mr Suriya registration as a tax agent pursuant to section 40-5 of the TASA (“Suriya Decision”).[12] The termination of Mr Suriya’s registration will take effect from 21 May 2023. The effect of the termination is that Mr Suriya must not provide any tax agent services, or he may be subject to civil penalties pursuant to section 50.5, 50.10, and 50.15 of the TASA.[12] T Documents, T16, pages 1616-1626, Decision of TPB regarding Osama Suriya dated 21 April 2023. In its reasons for the decision against Mr Suriya the TPB advised that:[13][13] T Documents, T16, pages 1616-1626, Decision of TPB regarding Osama Suriya dated 21 April 2023. In relation to Metalcop Pty Ltd, the Respondent noted that Mr Suriya’s explanation that he had sent the wrong financials and that accounts for the client can sometimes cause confusion due to sales and expenses being transacted in US dollars, did not adequately explain why and how Mr Suriya:[14]a) sent an email to the broker on 19 February 2020 providing figures for the company’s total income, expense and profit for the 2019 financial year;b) lodged the company’s ITR for the 2019 financial year with the ATO two days later, on 21 February 2020, which contained figures for its total income, expenses and profit that were significantly different to those provided to the broker in the email on 19 February 2020;c) subsequently sent an email to the broker on 17 May 2020 attaching a copy of an ITR for the company for the 2019 financial year containing the same figures as those provided in Mr Suriya’s email to the broker on 19 February 2020 (and that differed significantly with those in the company’s ITR lodged with the ATO); butd) did not lodge any amended ITRs for the company that contained the figures provided to the broker in his emails on 19 February 2020 and 17 Mary 2020.[14] T Documents, T16, pages 1616-1626, Decision of TPB regarding Osama Suriya dated 21 April 2023, page 1619. In the OZI Decision, the Respondent found that:[15]“a reasonable and responsible tax practitioner in Mr Suriya’s position should have been aware that it was highly unusual to be asked to prepare amended ITRs for clients that reported significantly different figures to those reported in the ITRs he had already prepared and lodged with the ATO. The Board noted that Mr Suriya had also seemingly taken no action to notify the broker or the financial institution of the discrepancies between the figures reported in the relevant ITRs lodged with the ATO and those reported to the broker.”[15] T Documents, T9, pages 858-865, Decision of TPB regarding Osama Suriya dated 21 April 2023, page 861.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

OZI and Mr Suriya respectively filed stay applications of the TPB’s decisions pursuant to section 41(2) of the AAT Act and submitted:[18]I am writing to express my deep disappointment and frustration at the recent decision to terminate my tax agent registration. I would like to dispute this decision and request that my registration be reinstated, if not then at least suspend for a short period of time. If the termination continues … it will prevent me from working in this industry for 12 months even as an employee. I have only worked in this industry all my life since the completion of my education. That’s an extremely harsh decision as this was my only livelihood. I do not earn any income from anywhere else, it will put me under enormous financial pressure and mental depression, which will ultimately affect my health and also my family life with 3 young kids all under the age of 6. I have never been a burden on the Australian Welfare system nor do I wish to be. I have a financial commitment of mortgage which I will be unable to fulfill along with other household expenses. This is not very big practice and I'm not making million of dollars here, nor I did get any financial benefit out of that.As a tax practitioner, I have always taken my responsibilities very seriously and have worked hard to maintain a high standard of professionalism and integrity in all of my dealings with clients and other stakeholders. I believe that I have always acted in accordance with the rules and regulations set out by the TASA, and have never knowingly breached any of these requirements. However, the incident that caused my registration to be terminated is a careless mistake I made, and did acknowledge and am remorseful of what has happened and have made changes in systems and policies and just asked TPB for another chance. That’s all. I'm a human, and was misguided by the broker, and there was no monetary benefit attached to it as well. It was merely a genuine mistake, I have now learned from my mistake and willing to show that it wont happen ever again. I'm willing to put some sort of security/guarantee to abide by TPB's rules and regulations.Therefore, I was extremely surprised to learn of the decision to terminate my registration. I feel that I have not been given a fair opportunity to address any concerns or issues that may have been raised. I was always professional incorresponding with TPB, All my tax obligations were up to date, and I have completely cooperated with TPB and have always been compliant which you can confirm with Tax Office as well. This is the first and last incident in the whole of my 12 years career. I deserve a chance to work in the industry and my livelihood not to be taken away from me.I would like to request that the Tax Practitioner Board to reconsider their decision and provide me with the opportunity to demonstrate that I am still a capable and trustworthy (Fit & Proper) tax practitioner. I am willing to engage in any necessary course to address any concerns that may have led to the decision to terminate my registration. I'm approaching AAT because I'm genuinely concerned about my work and profession. I'm very well-known in the community and you can verify my ethics independently from anyone. I fully acknowledge the incident and guarantee it won't happen again and non of the party has been disadvantaged because of this.I hope that you will take this letter into consideration and request TPB reconsider its decision to terminate my tax agent registration. I am committed to upholding the highest standards of professionalism and integrity in my work as a tax practitioner, and I believe that I have the skills, knowledge, and experience necessary to continue providing valuable services to my clients. My CPD's, Professional education and Professional Indemnity have always been up to date.(emphasis added)[18] T Documents, T1, pages 9-14, Application for review dated 27 April 2023, page 13.