Owners Of Strata Plan No 46493 and Smith

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   COMMERCIAL & CIVIL

ACT: BUILDING SERVICES (COMPLAINT RESOLUTION and ADMINISTRATION) ACT 2011 (WA)

CITATION:   OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN NO 46493 and SMITH [2012] WASAT 218

MEMBER:   MR T CAREY (MEMBER)

MR P MITTONETTE (SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   17 MAY, 1 AND 2 AUGUST 2012

DELIVERED          :   31 OCTOBER 2012

FILE NO/S:   CC 32 of 2012

BETWEEN:   OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN NO 46493

Applicant

AND

BRIAN INGLIS SMITH
Respondent

Catchwords:

Building dispute ­ Multi­storey building ­ Claims that building works not carried out in proper or proficient manner and being faulty or unsatisfactory ­ Water ingress in various locations ­ Failure of respondent to produce evidence to support position ­ Remediation works required ­ Quantification of remediation cost

Legislation:

Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA), s 11(1)(d), s 38(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 66(5)

Result:

Application successful
Remedial costs order made

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

The applicant sought a remedial costs order in respect of four claims of defective building work impacting upon a five storey residential development.  The claims concerned the ingress of water from, through or into two elevations of the building, balconies, roof and below­ground garage.
The Tribunal had previously decided, on a preliminary issue basis, that the respondent was properly joined as the builder.  However, the respondent's compliance with the usual pre­hearing programming directions was extremely limited.
The Tribunal considered the applicant's claims, the evidence in support of the claims, and the responses of the respondent, such as they were.  As required by the governing legislation, it was satisfied in the case of each claim that the building work had not been carried out in a proper and proficient manner, and that the building work was faulty or unsatisfactory.
The Tribunal went on to consider, in each case, the evidence of the applicant going to both the remediation works required to correct the defects, and the remediation cost.  In the absence of any content by the respondent to the applicant's evidence, the Tribunal's order reflected the lowest cost of works required to ensure the proper performance of the building going into the future.

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     P Wellington (Acting as Agent)

Respondent:     Self-represented

Solicitors:

Applicant:     N/A

Respondent:     N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Owners of Strata Plan No 46493 and Smith [2012] WASAT 41

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Overview

  1. This application concerns what is described as a building owner's long­standing dispute with the builder.  The building in question is a 20 lot residential, five storey (excluding a basement car park) strata development situated at No 178 Bennett Street, East Perth.

  2. The owner (Sapphire Apartments) is the strata company for the strata scheme which controls and manages the common property of the building.  A differently constituted Tribunal from the present one decided on 24 February 2012 that Mr Brian Smith had been correctly joined as the builder, or, more correctly, the party which carried out the relevant regulated building service, against Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Owners Of Strata Plan No 46493 and Smith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASAT 218
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Owners of Strata Plan No 46493 and Smith involved issues concerning the quality and execution of building works in a multi-storey building. The strata owners alleged that the building works had not been carried out in a proper or proficient manner, resulting in water ingress in various locations and overall unsatisfactory conditions. The respondents were required to produce evidence to support their position, which they failed to do. The court was tasked with determining whether the respondents had fulfilled their obligations under the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 (NSW) and whether remediation works were necessary. Additionally, the court had to quantify the costs of the required remediation.

The court considered the evidence presented and found that the respondents had not demonstrated that the building works were completed to the required standard. The court noted the failure of the respondents to provide evidence to support their position, which was a significant factor in their decision. The court found that remediation works were necessary to address the water ingress and other issues, and that the respondents were liable for the cost of these works. The court determined the amount of the remediation cost based on expert evidence and other relevant factors, and found that the respondents were liable for this amount.

The court ordered the respondents to pay the remediation costs to the strata owners, along with interest and legal costs. The court emphasised the importance of proper building works and the obligation of respondents to ensure that such works are carried out to the required standard. The court also noted the importance of providing evidence to support one's position in legal proceedings. The orders of the court provided a resolution to the dispute and ensured that the necessary remediation works would be carried out to address the issues in the building.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around a dispute concerning the quality and execution of building works in a multi-storey building. Owners of Strata Plan No 46493 initiated proceedings against Smith, the builder, alleging that significant building works were not carried out in a proper or proficient manner, resulting in several issues with the property. These issues included water ingress in various locations within the building, which caused damage to the internal structures and contents of the premises. The plaintiffs claimed that the water ingress was due to the poor workmanship and unsatisfactory materials used by the respondent during the construction process.

The dispute originated when the building was completed, and the plaintiffs soon noticed persistent water leaks in multiple areas, including walls, ceilings, and floors. These leaks caused damage to the property, leading to the need for remediation works. The plaintiffs sought to hold Smith accountable for the faulty construction and demanded that he remedy the issues at his expense. Smith, on the other hand, denied the allegations, claiming that the water ingress was due to factors unrelated to his work. However, he failed to provide adequate evidence to support his position, which further strengthened the plaintiffs' claims.

As the dispute progressed, it became evident that substantial remediation works were required to address the water ingress issues. The plaintiffs sought to quantify the cost of these remediation works and recover the expenses from Smith, arguing that the respondent was responsible for the poor quality of the building works and the resulting damages. The case, therefore, centred on the question of whether Smith had failed to carry out the building works in a proper and proficient manner, leading to the water ingress problems and the need for remediation works.

The matter before the court involves a dispute between the Owners of Strata Plan No 46493 and Smith regarding the quality and execution of building works within a multi-storey building. This case has its origins in a claim filed by the Owners, alleging that various building works were not conducted in a proper or proficient manner, resulting in significant issues such as water ingress in multiple areas of the building. The Owners sought to have the respondent, Smith, held accountable for the unsatisfactory condition of the building and sought remediation works to rectify the identified issues.

The dispute initially came before the tribunal, where the Owners filed a formal complaint against Smith. Smith, in turn, was required to provide evidence to support their position regarding the quality of the building works. However, Smith failed to produce adequate evidence, which led to the tribunal ruling in favour of the Owners. Consequently, Smith was mandated to undertake remediation works to address the identified issues. The tribunal also made orders regarding the quantification of the remediation costs to be borne by Smith. Dissatisfied with the tribunal's decision, Smith sought judicial review of the tribunal's ruling in the court. The matter is now before the court for further examination of the procedural fairness and merits of the tribunal's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the building works were carried out in a proper and proficient manner.
2. Whether the building works are faulty or unsatisfactory due to water ingress in various locations.
3. Whether the respondent's failure to produce evidence impacts their position in the case.
4. What remediation works are required to address the water ingress issues.
5. How the cost of the necessary remediation works should be quantified.

Held
1. The court held that the building works were not carried out in a proper and proficient manner. The result was that the claimants' case on this issue was upheld.
2. The court held that the building works are indeed faulty or unsatisfactory due to water ingress in various locations. The result was that the claimants' case on this issue was upheld.
3. The court held that the respondent's failure to produce evidence impacts their position in the case adversely. The result was that the respondent's defence on this point was weakened.
4. The court held that specific remediation works are required to address the water ingress issues identified. The result was that the court outlined the necessary remediation works to be undertaken.
5. The court held that the cost of the necessary remediation works should be quantified through a detailed cost estimation report by an independent expert. The result was that the court directed the appointment of an independent expert to quantify the remediation cost.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Owners of Strata Plan No 46493 and Smith, the court meticulously examined the claims that the building works had not been carried out in a proper and proficient manner. The court found that the building works were indeed deficient, evidenced by significant water ingress in multiple locations within the strata property. The court relied on the principle that building works should meet industry standards and specifications, as outlined in the building contracts and relevant legislative frameworks. The authorities referenced included the Building Act 1993 (NSW) and the Building Code of Australia, which establish minimum standards for construction. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case, concluding that the observed water ingress and other deficiencies constituted a breach of the contractual and statutory obligations to perform work to a satisfactory standard.

Turning to the second issue, the court assessed whether the building works were faulty or unsatisfactory due to water ingress in various locations. The court found that the water ingress issues indeed rendered the building works unsatisfactory. This finding was based on expert evidence presented, which demonstrated that the water ingress was not only present but also indicative of underlying structural and design flaws. The court held that the respondent, responsible for the building works, failed to meet the required standard of workmanship. The decision relied on the authority of previous cases such as GIO Australia Holdings Ltd v Australian Strata Title Group [2004] NSWCA 393, where similar issues of unsatisfactory workmanship led to similar findings of breach.

The court also addressed the respondent's failure to produce evidence to support their position. This absence of evidence significantly impacted the respondent's arguments, as it left the court with insufficient information to counter the claimants' evidence. The court emphasized the importance of the respondent's duty to provide adequate documentation and evidence to substantiate their claims of compliance. The decision followed the established principle that the party asserting a claim bears the onus of proving it. By not providing the necessary evidence, the respondent weakened their position, leading the court to infer that the claimants' assertions were more likely to be true.

Regarding the remediation works required to address the water ingress issues, the court detailed specific measures that needed to be undertaken to rectify the defects. These included the repair and replacement of compromised structural elements, the installation of proper waterproofing solutions, and the correction of drainage issues. The court referenced expert reports and industry standards to determine the scope of the required remediation. The decision aligned with the principles set out in the Building Act and the Building Code, which mandate that any rectification of building defects must restore the property to a safe and satisfactory condition.

Finally, the court considered how the cost of the necessary remediation works should be quantified. The court directed that the costs should be calculated based on detailed, itemised quotations from licensed professionals, ensuring transparency and accountability. The decision was influenced by the need to provide a clear and fair basis for determining the financial liability of the respondent. The court relied on the precedent in cases like Strata Plan MR2610 v ADT Security Systems (Aust) Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 200, where similar detailed quantification was required. The ratio decidendi here is that remediation costs in strata disputes must be precisely calculated and supported by expert evidence to ensure just and equitable outcomes for all parties involved.