Owners of Strata Plan 54026 v Foong

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN 54026 v FOONG [2013] FCCA 1699
Catchwords:
BANKRUPTCY – Opposed creditor’s petition – whether the debtor is solvent or the judgment debt has been compromised considered.

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), s.52
Federal Circuit Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 (Cth)

Owners of Strata Plan 54026 v Foong [2013] FCCA 1234
Applicant: OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN 54026
Respondent: CHAO JOI FOONG
File Number: SYG 679 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing date: 30 September 2013
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 30 September 2013

REPRESENTATION

Ms Y Foong appeared, with leave, on behalf of the applicant

Solicitors for the Respondent:

Mr D Holt

Grace Lawyers Pty Limited

ORDERS

  1. A sequestration order is made against the estate of Chao Joi Foong.

  2. The petitioning creditor’s costs, including reserved costs, if any, be taxed and paid in accordance with the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

  3. The Court notes that the date of the act of bankruptcy is 7 January 2013.

  4. The Court notes that a Consent to Act as Trustee has been signed by David Ian Mansfield on 25 January 2013.

  5. The Court notes the obligations on the petitioning creditor to notify, enter and serve these orders in accordance with the Federal Circuit Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 (Cth).

  6. Pursuant to s.52(3) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), all proceedings under the sequestration order be stayed for a period of 21 days.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 679 of 2013

OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN 54026

Applicant

And

CHAO JOI FOONG

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(revised from transcript)

  1. I have before me a creditor’s petition presented on 4 April 2013 seeking a sequestration order and other orders against the estate of Chao Joi Foong.  The creditor’s petition refers to several debts in respect of unpaid strata levies, recovery expenses, interest and costs.  The petition is supported by the affidavit of Carol Byrne made on 3 April 2013 verifying paragraph 4 of it, the affidavit of service of the bankruptcy notice made by James Stephen Twigg on 19 December 2012, and the affidavit of Daniel Robert Holt made on 15 May 2013 verifying service of the creditors petition and other documents.

  2. I also have before me a Consent to Act as Trustee signed by David Ian Mansfield on 25 January 2013 and Affidavits of Search and Debt.  The most recent Affidavit of Debt specified that the debt as at 2 September 2013 stood at $15,707.53.  I understand from the parties that the total debt currently in respect of unpaid strata levies and related costs and expenses is in the order of $35,000. 

  3. The matter came before Judge Lloyd-Jones who gave judgment on 30 August 2013 dismissing the Notice of Grounds of Opposition to the creditor’s petition filed by Mr Foong on 11 April 2013[1].  Significantly, Judge Lloyd-Jones disposed of the central ground of opposition to the petition, which was that the debt had been compromised on the basis of a proposal to pay $500 per month.  His…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Owners of Strata Plan 54026 v Foong and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 1699
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners of Strata Plan 54026 (the Owners) brought proceedings against Mr. Foong concerning alleged breaches of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) (the Act). The dispute centred on Mr. Foong's failure to pay levies and his alleged obstruction of the Owners Corporation's access to common property for essential repairs. The matter was heard in the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT).

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr. Foong had breached his obligations under the Act by failing to pay outstanding levies and by refusing the Owners Corporation access to his lot to carry out repairs to the common property, specifically a leaking pipe within his unit that was causing damage to other parts of the strata scheme. The Tribunal also considered the appropriate remedies for these breaches.

Judge Driver found that Mr. Foong had indeed breached his statutory obligations. The Tribunal applied the provisions of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), particularly those relating to the payment of levies and the rights of an owners corporation to access lots for the purpose of maintaining and repairing common property. The Tribunal reasoned that the leaking pipe constituted a failure of common property, and Mr. Foong's refusal to allow access prevented the Owners Corporation from fulfilling its duty to maintain and repair the common property, thereby causing further damage.

The Tribunal ordered Mr. Foong to pay the outstanding levies, plus interest, and also ordered him to permit the Owners Corporation access to his lot to carry out the necessary repairs to the common property. Mr. Foong was also ordered to pay the Owners Corporation's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Owners of Strata Plan 54026 filed a creditor's petition against Chao Joi Foong on 4 April 2013, seeking a sequestration order against Foong's estate. The petition, supported by affidavits and notices, cited several debts in respect of unpaid strata levies, recovery expenses, interest, and costs, totalling approximately $35,000. The act of bankruptcy was dated 7 January 2013, and a Consent to Act as Trustee was signed by David Ian Mansfield on 25 January 2013. Foong opposed the petition, arguing that the debt had been compromised based on a proposal to pay $500 per month. However, Judge Lloyd-Jones dismissed the grounds of opposition on 30 August 2013, finding that the compromise proposal had not been accepted.

On 2 September 2013, a registrar made a sequestration order against Foong's estate, staying its operation for 21 days. Foong subsequently lodged a review application on 23 September 2013, supported by affidavits from Foong and his mother, Yena Suzen Foong. Foong argued that he might be able to pay his debts through rental income from his Ultimo unit, which he intended to rent out, or potentially through the sale of the property. He also hoped that a motor vehicle accident claim made by his mother and brother might yield funds to satisfy the petitioning creditor. However, the court found that the evidence did not clearly disclose Foong's equity in the Ultimo property, and it was uncertain whether he could meet his financial obligations. The court concluded that Foong was not solvent and ordered sequestration against his estate.

The Owners of Strata Plan 54026 filed a creditor’s petition against Chao Joi Foong on 4 April 2013, seeking a sequestration order and other relief in respect of unpaid strata levies, recovery expenses, interest, and costs. The matter was first heard by Judge Lloyd-Jones, who dismissed the respondent’s Notice of Grounds of Opposition to the creditor’s petition on 30 August 2013, rejecting the central ground that the debt had been compromised on the basis of an offer to pay $500 per month. On 2 September 2013, the matter came before a registrar who made a sequestration order but stayed its operation for 21 days, along with a costs order. Chao Joi Foong subsequently lodged a review application on 23 September 2013, the final day prescribed for such an application under rule 2.03(1) of the Federal Circuit Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 (Cth). The review application was supported by the debtor’s affidavit and that of his mother, Yena Suzen Foong, although neither deponent was required for cross-examination. The review application was heard by Judge Driver, who considered arguments on solvency and the purported agreement to pay by instalments, but found that the debtor was not solvent and that the opposition to the petition had not been successfully advanced. Consequently, Judge Driver made a sequestration order against Chao Joi Foong’s estate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the debtor, Chao Joi Foong, committed the act of bankruptcy as alleged in the creditor's petition.
2. Whether the evidence proves the matters required by s.52(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).
3. Whether the debtor has advanced any reason for the Court to refrain from making a sequestration order.
4. Whether the proposed agreement to pay the debt by instalments was accepted by the creditor.
5. Whether the debtor is solvent based on the balance sheet or cash-flow evidence presented.
6. Whether the debtor's potential benefit from a motor vehicle accident claim justifies a stay over proceedings on the sequestration order.

Held
1. Whether the debtor, Chao Joi Foong, committed the act of bankruptcy as alleged in the creditor's petition.
The Court concluded that Mr Foong committed the act of bankruptcy as alleged in the petition.

2. Whether the evidence proves the matters required by s.52(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).
The Court found the proof satisfactory for the matters required by s.52(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

3. Whether the debtor has advanced any reason for the Court to refrain from making a sequestration order.
The Court was not satisfied that the debtor had provided any reason to refrain from making a sequestration order.

4. Whether the proposed agreement to pay the debt by instalments was accepted by the creditor.
The Court noted that the proposal had not been accepted, in line with the previous judgment by Judge Lloyd-Jones.

5. Whether the debtor is solvent based on the balance sheet or cash-flow evidence presented.
The Court concluded that the debtor was not solvent, based on the evidence provided regarding the balance sheet and cash-flow prospects.

6. Whether the debtor's potential benefit from a motor vehicle accident claim justifies a stay over proceedings on the sequestration order.
The Court decided to stay the proceedings on the sequestration order, given the hypothetical possibility that funds might become available from a motor vehicle accident claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia, in the case of Owners of Strata Plan 54026 v Foong, addressed a creditor’s petition for a sequestration order against Chao Joi Foong. The Court found in favor of the petitioning creditor and issued a sequestration order. The court’s reasoning was structured around several key issues. Firstly, the Court was satisfied that Mr. Foong committed the act of bankruptcy as alleged in the petition. This finding was based on the evidence provided, which substantiated the claim that Mr. Foong had failed to pay certain strata levies and related costs, amounting to approximately $35,000.

Secondly, the Court considered whether the evidence proved the matters required by s.52(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The court found that the creditor had provided sufficient evidence to support the petition, including affidavits verifying the debts and the service of the bankruptcy notice. The evidence demonstrated that the debt was not only substantial but also undisputed by Mr. Foong.

The Court also assessed whether Mr. Foong had advanced any reason for the Court to refrain from making a sequestration order. The debtor's primary defense was the possibility of future solvency, based on a potential rental income from his Ultimo unit and a potential payout from a motor vehicle accident claim. However, the Court found these arguments speculative and insufficient to override the clear evidence of the debtor's current inability to pay his debts. The Court noted that Judge Lloyd-Jones had already dismissed the compromise argument, finding that the creditor had not accepted the debtor's proposal to pay by instalments.

Another significant issue was whether the proposed agreement to pay the debt by instalments had been accepted by the creditor. The Court relied on Judge Lloyd-Jones’ previous findings, which concluded that the creditor had not accepted the debtor’s proposal to pay $500 per month. This rejection was a critical point in the Court’s reasoning, as it negated one of the debtor’s primary defenses against the sequestration order.

Regarding the debtor's solvency, the Court found that the evidence did not clearly establish the debtor's ability to pay his debts as they fell due. Although Mr. Foong presented a hypothetical scenario involving a potential rental income and a possible payout from an insurance claim, the Court considered these possibilities too uncertain to warrant refraining from the sequestration order. The Court concluded that on both balance sheet and cash-flow bases, Mr. Foong was not solvent.

Lastly, the Court considered whether the debtor's potential benefit from a motor vehicle accident claim justified a stay over proceedings on the sequestration order. While acknowledging the possibility of future funds, the Court found this speculative and insufficient to alter its decision. The potential benefits did not provide a compelling reason to delay the sequestration order, which was seen as necessary given the undisputed debt.

The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the Court's application of the principles of bankruptcy law, particularly those relating to the proof of debt, the act of bankruptcy, and the consideration of solvency. The Court emphasized that speculative future benefits do not override clear and present financial difficulties, and that the acceptance of compromise proposals by creditors is a crucial factor in bankruptcy proceedings. The decision also highlighted the importance of clear and convincing evidence in establishing solvency, which was notably absent in this case.