Owners of Strata Plan 13529 v Fowler

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN 13529 -v- FOWLER [2013] WADC 5

CORAM:   DEANE DCJ

HEARD:   10-13 APRIL 2012

DELIVERED          :   18 JANUARY 2013

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3224 of 2010

BETWEEN:   OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN 13529

Plaintiff

AND

BRENT FOWLER
Defendant

Catchwords:

Lease of a residential unit - Lease expired - Defendant sent a copy of the new lease - Fire at unit before new lease signed and returned - Whether defendant holding over pursuant to lease - Whether defendant a sole tenant - Proof of damage to property and claim for loss of opportunity to rent unit - Whether this is an apportionable claim for purposes of Pt 1F of the Civil Liability Act 2002 - Whether either or both of two of the clauses in lease oust proportionate liability provisions of the Act pursuant to s 4A of the Act if it is an apportionable claim

Legislation:

Civil Liability Act 2002
Supreme Court Act 1935

Result:

Judgment for plaintiff in sum claimed plus interest

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr M N Blandford

Defendant:     In person

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Corser & Corser as agent for Mason Black Lawyers

Defendant:     Not applicable

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Aquagenics Pty Ltd v Break O'Day Council (No 2) [2009] TASSC 89

Bofinger v Kingsway Group Ltd (2009) 239 CLR 269

Coghlan v SH Lock (Australia) Ltd (1987) 8 NSWLR 88

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Witherow [2006] VSCA 45

Darlington Futures Limited v Delco Australia Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 500

Dartberg Pty Ltd v Wealthcare Financial Planning Pty Ltd (2007) 164 FCR 450

Draper v Crofts (1846) 153 ER 807

F & D Normoyle Pty Ltd v Transfield Pty Ltd (2005) 63 NSWLR 502

Godfrey Spowers (Victoria) Pty Ltd v Lincolne Scott Australia Pty Ltd (2008) 21 VR 84

Kheirs Financial Services Pty Ltd v Aussie Home Loans Pty Ltd [2010] VCSA 355

Reinhold v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation (No 2) [2008] NSWSC 187

Tancred v Christy (1843) 152 ER 1219

DEANE DCJ: 

The pleadings, background and issues

  1. The defendant's application for an adjournment of this trial was opposed by the plaintiff and was heard and dismissed on 10 April 2012.  The defendant initially had legal representation but some months prior to trial that had ceased for financial reasons and so the defendant, Mr Fowler, represented himself at the trial.

  2. The plaintiff is a strata company created under s 32(1) of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) in respect of a group of three residential units located at 121 Stock Road in Attadale, although location is sometimes referred to as the suburb of Bicton (the plaintiff's premises). For ease of reference in these reasons the location will be referred to as Attadale. It is alleged that at all material times the defendant Mr Fowler was tenant and/or occupant of Unit 1 of the plaintiff's premises. Although it might be said there is an issue as to whether the defendant was the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Owners of Strata Plan 13529 v Fowler and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WADC 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Owners of Strata Plan 13529 commenced proceedings against Fowler for the return of keys to a unit and for payment of outstanding levies. The dispute concerned a residential unit which was leased to Fowler. The lease expired, and the owners of the strata plan sent a copy of a new lease to Fowler. Before the new lease was signed and returned, there was a fire at the unit. Fowler argued that she was not holding over pursuant to the lease and was a sole tenant. The owners of the strata plan sought to recover damages for the loss of the opportunity to rent the unit as a result of the fire. They also sought to recover the amount of damage caused by the fire. The defendants argued that the claim for damages for the loss of the opportunity to rent the unit was not an apportionable claim and therefore the owners of the strata plan were not entitled to recover damages under s 4A of the Civil Liability Act 2002.

The court was required to determine whether the claim for damages for the loss of the opportunity to rent the unit was an apportionable claim for the purposes of Pt 1F of the Civil Liability Act 2002. The court was also required to determine whether either or both of two of the clauses in the lease agreement ousted the proportionate liability provisions of the Act pursuant to s 4A of the Act if the claim was an apportionable claim. The court found that the claim was an apportionable claim because it arose from a failure to take reasonable care, which was also the basis of the claim in negligence. The court also found that the clauses in the lease did not oust the proportionate liability provisions of the Act.

The court held that the claim for damages for the loss of the opportunity to rent the unit was an apportionable claim. The court held that the claim arose from a failure to take reasonable care, which was also the basis of the claim in negligence. The court held that the clauses in the lease did not oust the proportionate liability provisions of the Act. The court held that the defendants were liable for damages for the loss of the opportunity to rent the unit and the damage caused by the fire.

The court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs the amount of damages for the loss of the opportunity to rent the unit and the damage caused by the fire. The court also ordered the defendants to return the keys to the unit and pay the outstanding levies. The court held that the defendants were liable for the damages and costs of the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Reinhold v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation (No 2) [2008] NSWSC 187 the plaintiff, Mr Reinhold purchased a lottery ticket for a $2,000 lottery draw. The ticket was printed but unfortunately was incomplete and therefore invalid. A second ticket was issued and that was valid. Mr Reinhold left the newsagency with the second valid ticket. After his departure however the second valid ticket rather than the first and invalid ticket was cancelled in error. This left Mr Reinhold in possession of an invalid ticket by reason of the fact that it had been mistakenly cancelled. As luck would have it this second ticket, which unknown to Mr Reinhold had been cancelled in error, was the winning ticket in the lottery but by virtue of having been incorrectly invalidated Mr Reinhold was unable to collect his winnings. He subsequently took proceedings against the New South Wales Lotteries Corporation and the newsagency from whom he had purchased the ticket in both contract and negligence. One issue which arose was whether the claim in contract was an apportionable claim and if it was whether liability would then be shared between the Lotteries Corporation and the newsagency. Counsel for Mr Reinhold argued that it was not an apportionable claim because it did not arise from a failure to take reasonable care. As an aside it may be that this argument was advanced to enhance Mr Reinhold's prospects of recovering damages against the Lottery Corporation as distinct from a single newsagency which may not have been as financially secure. In [26] of the judgment of Barrett J his Honour noted that there would have been a breach of the relevant contractual term had the Lotteries Corporation or the newsagency intentionally and knowingly cancelled the second ticket without Mr Reinhold's consent. However on the findings made there was a breach of the contractual term because of actions entailing want of care rather than intention to breach or knowingly breach. There was no positive or conscious intention that the second ticket which Mr Reinhold took when he left the shop should actually be cancelled. Its cancellation was essentially the product of the conduct of both the Lotteries Corporation and the newsagency which involved a breach by each of them of a duty of care in negligence. His Honour went on to observe that the breaches of contract to which the cancellation of the second ticket, being the valid ticket, gave rise were of the same character as the negligence because each had a central element a failure to take reasonable care. In [27] his Honour said that each of those relevant claims determined by the court in accordance with the findings made, was a claim in an action for damages 'arising from' the failure to take reasonable care which was also at the centre of the tortious claim in negligence. That applied equally to the claim in contract, which in his Honour's view was sufficient to bring the contract claim as well as the tort claim within the relevant section of the legislation being an action for damages (whether in contract, tort or otherwise) arising from a failure to take reasonable care'). It therefore did not matter that the claim in contract was not framed in terms of a failure to take reasonable care because in the end there was evidence of that, despite the case pleaded. In the end the Lotteries Corporation was held 90% responsible for Mr Reinhold's loss and the newsagency was responsible for the remaining 10%.