Owen Haviland Pty Ltd v Willoughby City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Owen Haviland Pty Ltd v Willoughby City Council [2004] NSWLEC 265
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
Owen Haviland Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT
Willoughby City Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10102 of 2004
CORAM: Tuor C.
KEY ISSUES: Development Application :- demolition of a contributory house in a conservation area
impact on the heritage significance of a conservation area
LEGISLATION CITED: Willoughby Local Environmental Plan 1995
CASES CITED:
DATES OF HEARING: 24/05/2004
EX TEMPORE
JUDGMENT DATE :
05/25/2004
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT
Mr M Ball

RESPONDENT
Ms H Irish, Barrister
Solicitors
Mallesons Stephen Jaques



JUDGMENT:

IN THE LAND AND


ENVIRONMENT COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES

                          10102 of 2004

                          Tuor C

                          25 May 2004
OWEN HAVILAND PTY LTD
                                  Applicant
      v
WILLOUGHBY CITY COUNCIL
                                  Respondent
Extempore Judgment

      Introduction

1 This is an appeal against the refusal by Willoughby City Council (the council) of a development application (DA 2003/810) to demolish an existing house and construct a new house at 13 Horsley Avenue, Willoughby.


      The site and its context

2 The site (being lot 13 DP14241) is located on the northern side of Horsley Avenue. It has an area of 638.6m2 with a frontage of about 14.2m to Horsley Avenue and a depth of about 44.5m. There is a fall of about half a metre from the rear to the front.

3 The site is developed with an inter war bungalow (c 1928). The front of the house is double brick with a lean to addition at the rear. There is a separate fibro garage, which is accessed from a single driveway along the eastern side of the house.

4 The house is located within the Horsley Avenue Conservation Area. This conservation area includes Horsley Avenue and Summerville Crescent. Other houses in the street are single storey, built at a similar time although some have been altered and appear as later houses.


      Statutory framework

5 The site is zoned 2 (a) (Residential) under Willoughby Local Environmental Plan 1995 (LEP 1995). The proposal is permissible with consent. Under this LEP the site is identified as being within the Horsley Avenue Conservation Area. Willoughby Development Control Plan No 19-Heritage and Conservation (DCP 19) and Willoughby Development Control Plan No 16-Dwelling Houses, Dual Occupancy and Boarding Houses in Residential Zones (DCP 16) are also relevant to the application.


      Issues

6 The Statement of Issues before the Court contains 2 issues. These can be summarised as whether the demolition of the existing house and the construction of a new house has an acceptable impact on the heritage significance of the conservation area.

7 After the site visit, amended plans were prepared. The heritage experts disagreed on the impact of the demolition of the existing house but agreed that if it were allowed to be demolished the proposed dwelling in the amended plans was acceptable.

8 The following experts provided Statements of Evidence:

· For the council

          Ms J Hill, heritage architect

· For the applicant

          Mr W McPhee, heritage architect

· Court appointed experts

          Mr P…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Owen Haviland Pty Ltd v Willoughby City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWLEC 265
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Owen Haviland Pty Ltd appealed against the refusal by Willoughby City Council to approve a development application to demolish an existing house and construct a new house at 13 Horsley Avenue, Willoughby. The site is within the Horsley Avenue Conservation Area, which has a coherent character with a predominance of 1920s bungalows. The appeal was heard by Tuor C in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales.

The key legal issues were whether the demolition of the existing house and the construction of a new house had an acceptable impact on the heritage significance of the conservation area. The experts disagreed on the impact of the demolition but agreed that if it were allowed the proposed dwelling was acceptable. The Court had to determine whether the existing house was incapable of reasonable or economic use and whether the proposed new dwelling was a reasonable alternative to retention.

The Court found that the existing house was capable of reasonable or economic use and that the proposed new dwelling was not a reasonable alternative to retention. The Court accepted the evidence that replacing original buildings which contribute to the significance of the conservation area with a replica building will erode the significance of the conservation area. On this basis, the application was refused.

The final orders were that the appeal be dismissed, the development application be refused, and the exhibits be returned.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established