Overland Corner Station Pty Ltd & Anor v Gould

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

OVERLAND CORNER STATION PTY LTD & ANOR v GOULD

[2010] SASC 61

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

23 March 2010

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - TREES AND VEGETATION - NATIVE VEGETATION

The first appellant cleared native vegetation from four separate areas of a property and was convicted for four contraventions of s 26(1) of the Native Vegetation Act 1991 (SA) (NVA) - the second appellant was a director of the first defendant - the second defendant was convicted under s 39 of the NVA for each of the four clearances.

Whether the clearances were for the purpose of maintaining existing fences or for the construction of new fences as contemplated by reg 5(1)(s) of the Native Vegetation Regulations 2003 (SA) (the Regulations) - whether the Magistrate erred in ruling that the onus was on the defendants to prove that the clearance was in accordance with reg 5(1)(s) of the Regulations - discussion of the principles relating to the application of s 56(2) of the Summary Procedure Act 1921 (SA) to s 26(1) of the NVA - whether the Magistrate erred in finding that fences on the first appellant's property did not constitute "existing fences" for the purposes of reg 5(1)(s) - whether the remaining conditions in reg 5(1) were established.

Held:  Magistrate did not err - appeals against conviction dismissed.

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE  - OTHER MATTERS

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - DISCRETION TO RECORD CONVICTION - RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS

A single fine of $60,000 was imposed on the first defendant - a single fine of $20,000 was imposed on the second defendant - the first defendant had one prior conviction for a contravention of s 26(1) of the NVA - several features of the first defendant's offending were aggravating.

Whether the Magistrate erred by failing to give sufficient reasons - whether the Magistrate should have found good reason not to record convictions for the offences of the second defendant.

Held:  Magistrate did not err - appeals against sentence dismissed.

Native Vegetation Act 1991 (SA) s 26, s 36; Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 16, s 18A; Native Title Regulations 2003 (SA) reg 5; Summary Procedure Act 1921 (SA) s 56; Native Title Management Act 1985 (SA) s 19; Native Vegetation (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act 2002 (SA) s 20, referred to.
Lloyd-Groocock v Police [2008] SASC 313; Hemming v Lukin (1996) 67 SASR 248; R v Waugh (2005) 93 SASR 274; R v Symonds [1999] SASC 217, applied.
Chugg v Pacific Dunlop (1990) 1710 CLR 249; R v Edwards (1975) 1 QB 27; Daire v O'Malley (1986) 41 SASR 583; Rowbottom v Nicolitsi (1986) 41 SASR 576; Dowling v Bowie (1952) 86 CLR 136; Robin v Police (2002) 81 SASR 253; McCarron v Akpata (2001) 216 LSJS 153; Dal Piva v Maynard (2000) LGERA 165; Piva v Brinkworth

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Overland Corner Station Pty Ltd & Anor v Gould and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Overland Corner Station Pty Ltd and one of its directors, Gould, appealed against their convictions for contravening the Native Vegetation Act 1991 (SA) by clearing native vegetation. The vegetation was cleared from four separate areas on the Overland Corner Station property, a 4,400 hectare property. The appellants argued that the clearances were either for the purpose of maintaining existing fences or for the construction of new fences, as permitted by regulation 5(1)(s) of the Native Vegetation Regulations 2003 (SA). The Magistrate ruled that the onus was on the appellants to prove the clearances were in accordance with the regulation, and found that there were no existing fences to be maintained in the areas where the clearances occurred. The court was required to determine whether the Magistrate erred in placing the onus of proof on the appellants and in finding that the fences on the property did not constitute "existing fences" for the purposes of the regulation. The court also needed to assess whether the remaining conditions in regulation 5(1) were established.

The court found that the Magistrate did not err in placing the onus of proof on the appellants. The court held that the appellants had the burden of proving that the clearances were in accordance with the regulation. The court also found that the Magistrate did not err in concluding that there were no existing fences to be maintained in the areas where the clearances occurred. The court held that the evidence showed that any pre-existing fences were in such a state of disrepair that they could not be described as “existing fences” for the purposes of regulation 5(1)(s). The court found that there was no evidence of any fence “in the course of construction” in any of the areas where the clearances took place, except in the area marked 2A. However, the court noted that the clearance of Area 2A had been completed by 3 October 2006 and construction of the fence in that area had not commenced before “early 2007”, making it improbable that a fence was “in the course of construction” at the time that the native vegetation was cleared from the area. The court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the convictions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The second defendant was also convicted of four contraventions arising from the same clearance activities. These convictions resulted from the application of s 39 of the NVA.[1] The Magistrate imposed a fine of $20,000 on the second defendant.[1] Section 39 of the NVA provides:Where a body corporate is guilty of an offence against this Act, each member of the governing body, and the manager, of the body corporate are guilty of an offence and liable to the same penalty as is prescribed for the principal offence.Background Circumstances Overland Corner Station is a property comprising approximately 4,400 hectares.. Some sections of the property have been substantially cleared but there are remaining stands of native vegetation. The prosecution concerned native vegetation growing on two strips of land on the Station. The strips were well separated from each other but both ran in a roughly north-south direction. At the trial these two strips were referred to as Areas One and Two respectively. The Magistrate did not make a specific finding as to the dimensions of either strip. However, the evidence indicates that Area One, before the first defendant’s clearance of the native vegetation, was some 1,650 metres long. The evidence concerning the width of the strip varied but Mr Storry (an employee in the Department of Water, Land and Biodiversity Conservation (the Department)), whose evidence the Magistrate regarded as reliable, calculated using aerial imagery, an average width of 50 metres. Other evidence suggested that the width of the strip comprising Area One was, at least in some places, less than 50 metres. The evidence indicated that Area Two was some 1,415 metres long. Again, the evidence as to its width varied. Mr Storry calculated an average width of 25 metres, but he acknowledged that in some places the strip had no vegetation at all, and that in other places the width of the vegetation was less than 25 metres. The Magistrate found that the first clearance of vegetation took place at some time between 21 January 2006 and 3 October 2006. At this time a portion of Area Two was completely cleared. This portion was referred to at trial as Area 2A. The Magistrate did not make findings as to the dimensions of Area 2A. However, Mr Storry’s evidence indicated that it was approximately 570 metres long and involved an area of 0.9 of a hectare. The clearance of Area 2A left a strip to its south which was some 750 metres long (referred to at trial as Area 2B) and a strip to its north which was some 85 metres long (referred to at trial as Area 2C). In other words, the cleared portion (Area 2A) was closer to the northern end of the strip than it was to the southern end. On the Magistrate’s findings, the second area to be cleared was a portion of Area One (referred to at trial as Area 1A). The clearance of Area 1A occurred at some time after 3 October 2006 and before 2 April 2007, and involved the complete clearance of 2.7 hectares of native vegetation. Area 1A was approximately 550 metres long. The remaining portion of Area A south of Area 1A (referred to at trial as Area 1B) was approximately 800 metres long, and the remaining area to the north (referred to as Area 1C) was approximately 300 metres long. As with Area 2A, Area 1A was closer to the northern end of Area A than to the southern end.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 38 of NVA provides for the vicarious liability of an employer or principal in the following terms:For the purposes of this Act, an act or omission of an employee or agent will be taken to be the act or omission of the employer or principal unless it is proved that the act or omission did not occur in the course of the employment or agency.A defendant has a defence to a charge of an offence if the defendant can prove that the alleged offence was not committed intentionally and did not result from any failure on the part of the defendant to take reasonable care. Section 40 is in the following terms:It is a defence to a charge of an offence against this Act if the defendant proves that the alleged offence was not committed intentionally and did not result from any failure on the part of the defendant to take reasonable care to avoid the commission of the offence.The Magistrate’s Decision At the trial, the defendants did not dispute that the first defendant had, without the consent of the Native Vegetation Council, caused or permitted the clearance of native vegetation from Areas One and Two. They contended, however, that the clearances were carried out in circumstances to which reg 5(1)(s) applied, and so were in accordance with Part 5 of the NVA. In a preliminary ruling on 26 August 2009, the Magistrate rejected the defendants’ submission that the prosecution had the onus of proving that the clearances which it alleged were not in accordance with Part 5 of the NVA. The trial then proceeded with each of the prosecution and the defendants adducing both oral and documentary evidence. At the conclusion of the trial, the Magistrate found that the first defendant had cleared native vegetation from each of the Areas 1A, 2A, 1B and 1C, and 2B and 2C at the times alleged. The Magistrate accepted that it was reasonably possible that there were pre-existing fences in each of those Areas. He also accepted that it was reasonably possible that the first defendant had made a decision to repair or replace existing fencing in those Areas in order to permit stock to be re-introduced on to the property. However, he went on to find, on the basis of the evidence of the second defendant and of the defendants’ witness Mr Schutz, that any pre-existing fences in those areas were in such a state of disrepair that they could not be described as “existing fences” for the purposes of reg 5(1)(s). Accordingly, the Magistrate found that there were no “existing fences” to be maintained in any of the areas where the clearances occurred. That meant that in order for the defendants to bring themselves within reg 5(1)(s) they had to establish that the clearance of the vegetation was for the purpose of providing a strip of cleared land on either side or both sides of a fence “in the course of construction” to provide access for the purpose of establishing the fence. The Magistrate considered that there was no evidence of any fence “in the course of construction” in any of the areas where the clearances took place, except in the Area marked 2A. In relation to Area 2A, the Magistrate considered that, as its clearance had been completed by 3 October 2006 and construction of the fence in that Area had not commenced before “early 2007”, it was improbable that a fence was “in the course of construction” at the time that the native vegetation was cleared from the area.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.