Outram v Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Outram v Public Trustee of Queensland [2020] QSC 80

PARTIES:

LYNETTE ANN OUTRAM, JUDITH ADA EVERINGHAM AND GARY RAYMOND EVERINGHAM

(Applicants)

v
PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND

(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 1410 of 2020

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

17 April 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

12 March 2020

JUDGE:

Brown J

ORDER:

The parties provide submissions as to the appropriate form of order and as to costs within seven days by filing and serving written submissions of no more than three pages.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS GENERALLY – DIRECTIONS AS TO PAYMENT – where the deceased left her property to the applicants and the remainder of her estate to the residuary beneficiaries – where one of the residuary beneficiaries, acting under an power of attorney after the deceased ceased to have capacity, sold the deceased’s house in 2016 to pay a bond for a nursing home – where the property had been sold by a third-party two months prior to the deceased’s death in 2018 – where there is no dispute that the applicants are entitled to compensation and an extension of time to make the application – where the applicants contend that their compensation should be assessed according to the most proximate sale of the property in 2018 – where the residuary beneficiaries contend that the compensation should be assessed according to the net proceeds of the 2016 sale – whether the compensation is to be assessed according to the 2016 sale or the most proximate sale in 2018

Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld) s 107

Moylan v Rickard[2010] QSC 327, considered
Neuendorf v Public Trustee of Queensland [2015] 1 Qd R 513; [2013] QSC 156, followed

COUNSEL:

J Byrnes for the Applicant

G Dickson for the Respondent

C Brewer for the Residuary Beneficiaries

SOLICITORS:

Cooke & Hutchinson for the Applicant
Official Solicitor to the Public Trustee for the Respondent
Biggs Fitzgerald Pike for the Residuary Beneficiaries

Introduction

  1. Heather Everingham (the Deceased) died on 29 November 2018. The Public Trustee (the Respondent) is the executor and trustee of her estate under her Will. Under clause 7 of the Deceased’s Will, her house and land at 39 Blackwood Road, Geebung (the Property) was to be given to her stepchildren, Lynette Ann Outram, Judith Ada Everingham and Gary Raymond Everingham (the Applicants) in equal shares. Under clause 8 of her Will she gave the residue of her estate to Peter Webster, Heather Bett Milner and Ian Webster (the Residuary Beneficiaries), who are the niece and nephews of the Deceased. The Residuary Beneficiaries were also represented in the present application.

  2. Prior to the Deceased’s death, the Property was sold and the monies used, in part, to pay an accommodation bond. As a result, the Applicants lost their entitlement under the Will. They now seek compensation under s 107 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld) (the Act).…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Outram v Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Outram v Public Trustee of Queensland, the applicants sought compensation under section 107 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld) due to a loss of benefit in the estate caused by the sale of the deceased's property by the residuary beneficiary who held a power of attorney. The deceased's property was sold in 2016 to pay a bond for a nursing home, and a second sale occurred in 2018. The applicants argued that compensation should be based on the 2018 sale, while the residuary beneficiaries contended that it should be based on the 2016 sale. The court had to decide on the appropriate method for assessing the compensation.

The legal issue at the heart of this case was how compensation for the loss of benefit in the estate should be calculated under section 107 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld). The applicants argued for the compensation to be based on the most proximate sale of the property in 2018, while the residuary beneficiaries argued for it to be based on the net proceeds of the 2016 sale. The court had to determine the appropriate value of the property at the time of the deceased's death to calculate the lost benefit.

The court considered the reasoning in Neuendorf and Moylan v Rickard, where the court determined compensation by taking into account the movement of median house prices over time. The court noted that the compensation must not exceed the value of the lost benefit and ordered that the applicants should be compensated to the extent of the difference between the gift to which they were presently entitled under the will and the value which it would have had at the date of the deceased's death. In this case, the court found that the appropriate value of the property at the deceased's death was $705,000, based on the 2018 sale. However, the court also considered the size of the estate and the costs incurred, and ultimately decided that the appropriate compensation should be determined by reference to the net proceeds of the 2016 sale of the property, which was $552,195.09.

The court ordered the parties to provide written submissions on the appropriate form of order and costs within seven days, ensuring that the applicants were compensated for their loss of benefit in the estate. The court's decision balanced the applicants' entitlement to compensation with the need to ensure that the compensation did not exceed the value of the lost benefit, and took into account the relevant factors in determining the appropriate value of the property at the time of the deceased's death.

Orders

Orders of the court

The parties provide submissions as to the appropriate form of order and as to costs within seven days by filing and serving written submissions of no more than three pages.

Background

Background to the litigation

Prior to the Deceased’s death, the Property was sold and the monies used, in part, to pay an accommodation bond. As a result, the Applicants lost their entitlement under the Will. They now seek compensation under s 107 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld) (the Act). There is no dispute that the Applicants should be granted an extension of time to make their claim, nor that they are entitled to compensation. The dispute lies as to how that compensation is to be assessed, which is the matter for determination by this Court.Factual Background The following facts are not in contention. On 6 May 2015, Dr Catton provided a certificate which stated that the Deceased’s mental state and memory capacity had deteriorated and that she was no longer capable of making decisions in relation to financial, personal and health matters. Peter Webster held the Deceased’s power of attorney. The power of attorney did not become operative until a medical practitioner had certified that the Deceased was incapable of making decisions in relation to financial matters. As a result of the Deceased’s deterioration it was determined, in consultation with the Deceased, that she would go into Cooinda Retirement Village and Care Facility at Gympie. Prior to that time, she had lived with Mr Webster and his wife for some three or four months in mid to late 2015. To enable her to go into care at Cooinda Aged Care Accommodation, Mr Webster’s evidence is that the Property had to be sold. Prior to doing so, Mr Webster stated that he consulted Gary Everingham as a representative of the Everingham family about the proposed sale of the Property and Gary Everingham agreed. Mr Webster also canvassed whether any of the Everingham family were interested in buying the Property, but no-one wished to do so. Subsequently, the house was sold for the sum of $570,000. It is evident from emails from Mr Webster to Cheryl Everingham, Mr Everingham’s wife, that he kept them abreast of the sale of the property.[1] [1]See for example email from Peter Webster to Cheryl Everingham “November report” CEO3 to affidavit of Cheryl Everingham CFI2; see also “January report” CEO4. Settlement occurred on 12 February 2016. Mr Webster signed the transfer exercising his powers as attorney. The net proceeds of the sale of the Property in February 2016 was $552,195.09. A bond of $475,000 was paid to Cooinda Aged Care Accommodation and the balance was paid into an account of the deceased. There is evidence that the Property was further sold in September 2018 for $705,000.Monies in Estate The assets and liabilities in the estate as at 10 March 2020 were: The Respondent is the executor of the Will. It does not oppose the application nor the orders sought, but has withheld the distribution of the estate pending this application.Section 107 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1988 (Qld) The Applicants apply for compensation for the loss of benefit in the estate pursuant to s 107 of the Act. It provides that:“107 Power to apply to court for compensation for loss of benefit in estate(1)This section applies if a person’s benefit in a principal’s estate under the principal’s will, on intestacy, or by another disposition taking effect on the principal’s death, is lost because of a sale or other dealing with the principal’s property by an attorney of the principal.(1A)This section applies even if the person whose benefit is lost is the attorney by whose dealing the benefit is lost.(2)The person, or the person’s personal representative, may apply to the Supreme Court for compensation out of the principal’s estate.(3)The court may order that the person, or the person’s estate, be compensated out of the principal’s estate as the court considers appropriate but the compensation must not exceed the value of the lost benefit.(4)The Succession Act 1981, sections 41(2) to (8), (10) and (11) and 44 apply to an application and an order made on it as if the application was an application under part 4 of that Act by a person entitled to make an application.(5)In this section – attorney means an attorney under – (a)a general power of attorney made under this Act; or(b)an enduring document; or(c)a power of attorney made otherwise than under this Act, whether before or after its commencement.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Neuendorf, Martin J considered the earlier case of Moylan v Rickard,[7] where Peter Lyons J found that there had been a breach of s 106 of the Act by the attorney in relation to use of proceeds of the sale of a property owned by the testator. His Honour considered the question of compensation under s 107 of the Act. His Honour determined the compensation by having regard to evidence of the movement of the median house prices in the relevant area over time on the basis it was the best evidence available. In that regard his Honour noted that because of changes made to the house since it was sold there were particular difficulties in attempting to determine what value it would have had if it had not been sold at the date the deceased died.[8] His Honour estimated the change in value of the property from the time it was sold compared to the date the testator died. His Honour ordered that the beneficiary was to be compensated to the extent of the difference between the gift to which he was presently entitled under the will, and the value which it would have had[9] at the date of the testator’s death.[7][2010] QSC 327, which was approved by Ann Lyons J as the correct approach to be adopted under s 60 of the Guardianship and Administration Act in Public Trustee of Queensland v Stibbe [2012] QSC 357 although in that case her Honour used the current sale price and deducted the costs to determine the net benefit and ensured that the compensation was not greater than the value of the lost benefit: at [62].[8]At [102][9]Based on the notional value of the house by reference to the median price of which the beneficiary was entitled to fifteen per cent.Consideration The Applicants submit that the starting point for the calculation of compensation is to have regard to the value of the Property at the date of the Deceased’s death based on the 2018 sale and take account of the costs of sale to determine the net proceeds, consistent with the approach in Moyland v Rickard. Thus, the Applicants submit that the appropriate value of the property at the Deceased’s death was $705,000 based on the fact the property sold for that price in September 2018. They have suggested that the costs of the 2016 sale, which was approximately $25,000, should be used to calculate the net value of the Property as at the Deceased’s death. That is a sum of $680,000. That is greater than the amount of the Deceased’s estate as at 10 March 2020. The Applicants accept that the size of the estate and the costs incurred are relevant to the exercise of the Court’s discretion. The Residuary Beneficiaries submit that the appropriate compensation should be determined by reference to the net proceeds of the 2016 sale of the Property, namely $552,195.09 and determining what proportion it bears to the total estate, which is approximately 86 percent.[10] They submit that it is not appropriate to use the 2018 sale of the Property as the relevant value of the lost benefit because there is no evidence as to the state of the house at that time, such that it reflects the state it would have been in if not sold in 2016 or whether it had been subject to extensive renovation. They submit that one therefore cannot determine whether it represents the lost benefit. They say further that no version of the facts of the case could the Property actually still have existed as a benefit under the Will at the time of the Deceased’s death, given the proceeds were predominantly used for her care in an aged care facility. That may be so. However, I note that that was also the case in Neuendorf. Notwithstanding that, in that case, his Honour had regard to the market value proximate to the time of the deceased’s death. That is consistent with the fact that the section provides for compensation for the lost benefit under the Will. The benefit would not crystallise until the Deceased died.[10]At the date of Deceased’s death, the value of the estate was $639,408.65.