Oscar Dart v Triathlon Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Case number: NST-E23-156958

Case Title: Oscar Dart v Triathlon Australia

Determination

National Sports Tribunal

General Division

sitting in the following composition:

Panel Member        Ms Elisa Holmes

in the arbitration between

Oscar Dart  (Applicant)

Represented by Mr Warwick Dalziel, authorised representative

And

Triathlon Australia     (Respondent)

Represented by Mr Tim Harradine, CEO

PARTIES AND NST JURISDICTION

  1. The Applicant, Oscar Dart, is a professional triathlete who nominated for selection for the upcoming World Championship Series event in Hamburg (Hamburg Event). He was not selected.

  2. Triathlon Australia Limited is the governing body (or National Sporting Organisation, as such bodies are often called) for triathlon in Australia.

  3. Jake Birtwhistle and Callum McCluskey were identified as potentially interested parties. They were notified of the appeal but did not take any part in it.

  4. Selection for the Hamburg Event was governed by the World Triathlon Championship Series (WTCS) Selection Policy (Selection Policy). The Selection Policy provides under the heading of “Appeals”, at clause 11, that “[a]n Eligible Athlete [which description includes Mr Dart], who is not selected, may appeal that decision, under the Triathlon Australia (Fast Track) Appeals Policy, dated 2022” (Fast Track Appeals Policy).

  5. The Fast Track Appeals Policy provides for “Non-Selected Athletes” (as defined in that Policy so as to include Mr Dart) to apply for a “Selection Appeal” (again, as defined in that Policy) by the General Division of the NST (clause 5.2). Clause 5 of the Fast Track Appeals Policy sets out the process for instigating such appeals. No objection has been taken by either party in respect of the process.

  6. The NST’s jurisdiction to hear and determine this appeal is contained in section 23 of the National Sports Tribunal Act 2019 (Cth). No objection was taken by either party to the NST’s jurisdiction.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE NST

  1. Mr Dart was informed of his non-selection for the Hamburg Event on 13 June 2023 at 3:12 pm by way of letter from Daniel Mangano, Olympic Program Campaign Lead of Triathlon Australia (Non-Selection Letter).

  2. The “reasons” provided in the Non-Selection Letter were limited to the following paragraph:

    “Unfortunately, in this instance, your nomination did not meet the automatic selection criteria. You were also assessed under the discretionary selection criteria; consideration was given to relevant matters set out in Clause 4.3.1 of The Policy, and discretion was not exercised. Consequently, you have not been selected for this event.”

  3. Three athletes received automatic nomination under the Selection Policy and two other athletes received discretionary nomination.

  4. Mr Dart appealed against his non-selection by way of application to the NST dated 13 June 2023. The grounds for his appeal were summarised as follows:

    “I was not selected yesterday in the Hamburg WTS event despite meeting the automatic selection criteria of being in the top 60 on WT rankings and inside the top 4 ranked Australian athletes. 

    Triathlon Australia decide to discretionarily exclude me from the team when there is no basis for this decision.  The performance standards…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oscar Dart v Triathlon Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NST NST-E23-156958
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Oscar Dart, a professional triathlete, challenged his non-selection for the World Championship Series event in Hamburg, governed by the World Triathlon Championship Series (WTCS) Selection Policy. Dart was not selected despite meeting the automatic selection criteria of being in the top 60 on the WT rankings and being among the top 4 ranked Australian athletes. He appealed against this decision under the Fast Track Appeals Policy, asserting that the selection process was improperly applied and that he was not given a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the Selection Policy. Triathlon Australia, the governing body for triathlon in Australia, defended its decision, explaining that Dart did not meet the performance standards outlined in the policy and that its discretion was exercised properly.

The National Sports Tribunal (NST) reviewed Dart's appeal, focusing on whether the Selection Policy was properly applied by Triathlon Australia and if Dart was afforded a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the policy. The Tribunal examined the reasons provided by Triathlon Australia for Dart's non-selection, which included his failure to meet the performance standards, a decline in his performance at World Cup Level events, and an increase in his World Triathlon Ranking due to points obtained at Continental Cups. Triathlon Australia emphasized that it considered athlete performance at 2022 and 2023 WTCS and World Cups in line with the policy, and that Dart's results were less strong compared to the two athletes selected. Dart argued that he was a rapidly improving athlete who had met the first requirement for automatic selection and had been denied sufficient opportunity to race in WTCS events.

The Tribunal found that Triathlon Australia did not improperly apply the Selection Policy and that Dart was not afforded a reasonable opportunity to satisfy the policy. The Tribunal concluded that Dart's non-selection was based on his failure to meet the performance standards, a decline in his performance at relevant events, and the selection committee's exercise of its absolute discretion in line with the policy's objective to nominate athletes who have the ability to medal or play a team role in winning a medal at the events listed in the policy. The Tribunal determined that Dart's argument regarding the absence of reasons for his non-selection was not sufficient to establish that the Selection Policy was not properly applied.

The Tribunal dismissed Dart's appeal, affirming that Triathlon Australia's decision to not select Dart for the Hamburg Event was consistent with the WTCS Selection Policy and the Fast Track Appeals Policy. The Tribunal's decision highlights the importance of providing reasons for selection decisions in professional sport and the broad discretion afforded to selection committees under the policy.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established