Osborne v Osborne Ice Works No. DCCIV-99-1396

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

GRAHAM ANGUS OSBORNE v OSBORNE ICE WORKS PTY LTD
[2000] SADC 134

Judge Lunn
Civil

The participants in the dispute

  1. The defendant, Osborne Ice Works Pty Ltd (“the Company”), was incorporated in 1953.  Until his death in December 1998 Mr George Osborne (“the father”) was a director of the Company and its manager.  During this time the only other director was his wife (“Mrs Osborne”), but she had no significant role in the Company’s activities.  By and large the Company was the alter ego of the father.  There are three children of the father and Mrs Osborne, being Marilyn Osborne (“Marilyn”), the plaintiff and Neville Osborne (“Neville”).  Each of the five family members held shares in the Company.  It had no other shareholders.

  2. The Company has carried on a profitable business as an investor.  Until about late 1989 the primary accounting records of the Company were prepared by the father in an apparently fairly rough and rudimentary way.  The secondary records, such as ledgers, journals, balance sheets, profit and loss accounts and the like, were prepared by a professional accountant, Mr Guthrie, and his staff, and apparently from such primary records and information as were given to them by the father.  Mr Guthrie also prepared and kept the minute book and statutory records of the Company.  Mr Guthrie died in about 1989 and ever since D G Scott & Co (“Scotts”), another firm of accountants, have done this work for the Company.  Prior to 1990 there was an account with the Hindmarsh Building Society No 92150302 (“the Hindmarsh account”) which was in the name of the father, but which either wholly or partly contained money belonging to the Company.  In his dealings with money and property the father did not necessarily strictly differentiate between what belonged to the Company and what belonged to him personally.  Many of his dealings were in cash.

History of relevant events

  1. In 1995 the plaintiff separated from his wife and they became involved in contested proceedings in the Family Court.  He then bought a house in Coffin Bay for $135,000.  To finance the purchase he borrowed $30,000 from the Hindmarsh Building Society at 17.75% per annum interest and $48,000 from the Company.  To secure this latter loan he gave the Company a second mortgage over the Coffin Bay property which on its terms required him to pay interest at 5% per annum and to repay the loan and interest by monthly instalments of $259.  However, the father did not insist on him making such monthly payments and they were not made.  There is no record of any interest payable under this mortgage being either paid or debited to the plaintiff’s running loan account in the books of the Company.  In 1986 the plaintiff paid these amounts totalling $36,815 to the Company in reduction of the mortgage principal.  In about that year the plaintiff arranged with the father for the Company to pay out the first mortgage to the Hindmarsh Building Society over the Coffin Bay…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v Osborne Ice Works No. DCCIV-99-1396 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SADC 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Osborne v Osborne Ice Works Pty Ltd was an action in the District Court of South Australia by the plaintiff, Graham Angus Osborne, against the defendant, Osborne Ice Works Pty Ltd, seeking to recover an amount of money which he claimed was an overpayment by him to the defendant of a loan repayment and interest thereon, and to have the money repaid to him. The plaintiff also sought a declaration that he was entitled to interest at 15% per annum on the overpayment and that the defendant had a duty to pay it. The defendant denied that it owed the plaintiff any money and pleaded that the plaintiff's claim was barred by limitation of actions. The primary judge, Lunn J, found that the plaintiff was entitled to a sum of $8,091, being $7,561 plus interest under the District Court Act, but no more. The plaintiff's claim for further money and for interest at 15% per annum was rejected. The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal was dismissed. The Supreme Court found that the primary judge had correctly determined that the plaintiff's cause of action arose by the end of 1989. The plaintiff was therefore required to bring his action within six years of that date. He did not do so. The primary judge had correctly found that the plaintiff could not obtain an extension of time under s 48 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) because he had not satisfied either s 48(3)(b)(i) or (ii). The primary judge had also correctly exercised his discretion under s 48(3) to refuse the plaintiff an extension of time because in all the circumstances of the case it was not just to grant it. The plaintiff's contention that the primary judge had erred in excluding evidence of settlement discussions between the parties in 1999 under s 67c of the Evidence Act 1995 (SA) was rejected. The primary judge had correctly found that the defendant had not consented to the admission of that evidence for the purpose for which it was sought to be used. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established