DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Orr v The Public Trustee of Queensland [2019] QDC 248
PARTIES:
KATIE LOUISE ORR
(Applicant)
v
THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND
(Respondent)
FILE NO:
D25/19
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT
District Court
MaroochydoreDELIVERED ON:
6 December 2019
DELIVERED AT:
Maroochydore
HEARING DATE:
Decided without oral hearing
JUDGE:
Cash QC DCJ
ORDERS:
Order as per draft.
CATCHWORDS:
SUCCESSION – FAMILY PROVISION – REQUIREMENT FOR ADEQUATE AND PROPER MAINTENANCE - WHETHER APPLICANT WAS LEFT WITH INSUFFICIENT PROVISION – claim by testator’s children – compromise or agreement by the parties.
District Court Act 1967 (Qld), s 68(1)(x)
Succession Act 1981(Qld), s 41
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), rr 371, 430, 489, 490, 498Bartlett v Coomber [2008] NSWCA 100
Singer v Berghouse (1994) 181 CLR 201
Vigolo v Bostin (2005) 221 CLR 191
Watts v The Public Trustee of Queensland [2010] QSC 410, [15]SOLICITORS:
Cartwrights Lawyers for the applicant
Official Solicitor for the Public Trustee for the respondent
John Andrew Orr, the deceased, passed away on 30 May 2018. He was 71 years old. The deceased had married in 1972. There were two children of the marriage, Daniel and the applicant, Katie. The marriage ended in 1982. The applicant was six years old and her brother Daniel was eight. She saw the deceased only once after that when the applicant was ten years old. In 1985 the deceased married for a second time. The deceased’s second wife had two daughters, Deborah and Susan. His second wife passed away in 2014 and her daughter Susan passed away in 2015. When the deceased died he left an estate valued at about $430,000. By far the most significant asset was an unencumbered house at Sandstone Point valued at $385,000. By his last will the deceased appointed the Public Trustee as executor. He left the entire estate to his step-daughter, Deborah.
In February 2019 the applicant made a claim for provision out of the estate. In May 2019 the applicant’s brother Daniel gave notice that he too claimed provision out of the estate. In late October the interested parties compromised the claims. Subsequently the respondent applied for final orders and proposed the application be dealt with without an oral hearing.[1] None of the exceptions in r 489 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 apply. I must therefore determine the matter without an oral hearing and, as I propose to make an order, give written reasons for my decision.[2]
[1] The respondent did not comply with r 490 but as noted later in the reasons I propose to excuse this noncompliance.
[2] R 498.
Evidence
The affidavit material reveals that the applicant, her brother Daniel, and the deceased’s step-daughter Deborah, did not know each other. There was little contact between the deceased, the applicant and Daniel after his separation from their mother in 1982. The applicant deposes that she would have been happy to have contact with her father but he made no effort and showed no…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Orr v The Public Trustee of Queensland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] QDC 248
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the financial circumstances of the applicant and her brother, the size and nature of the estate, and the relationships between the deceased and the interested parties. It found that neither the applicant nor her brother had a substantial relationship with the deceased, who did not maintain or support them before his death. However, both were in need of maintenance and support. The court also considered the compromise agreement, which provided that the applicant and her brother would each receive $50,000, and the balance of the estate would go to Deborah. The court determined that the agreement was a significant factor, particularly given the modest size of the estate and the potential for litigation to consume a substantial portion of it. The court concluded that there was a proper basis for the compromise, and it should be afforded considerable weight.
Given the agreement of the parties and the modest nature of the estate, the court decided to proceed without an oral hearing and make an order in the terms of the draft agreement. The court also excused the procedural non-compliances in the application process to avoid unnecessarily inflating the costs of the proceedings. The final orders were made in accordance with the draft agreement, with the applicant and her brother each receiving $50,000, and the balance of the estate going to Deborah. The applicant's costs were fixed at $20,000, and the respondent's costs were to be paid on the indemnity basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
Order as per draft.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The matter is not inappropriate for disposition on the papers. The proposal for a decision without oral hearing should be accepted. Again, an important consideration is that this will avoid the expenditure of additional legal costs from what is a relatively modest estate.Consideration The present application falls within the jurisdiction of the District Court as it concerns a claim for less than $750,000.[5] In determining an application for family provision pursuant to s 41 of the Act, the cases provide that a two stage process is employed. First, the court must determine a jurisdictional question of whether the applicant has been left without adequate provision for his or her proper maintenance and support. Secondly, if so, the court will then determine what provision ought to be made in the circumstances.[6] In so doing the Court is asked to exercise its discretion. The agreement of the parties is a matter of significance and should be afforded considerable weight, but it is not determinative.[7][5] District Court Act 1967, s 68(1)(x).[6] J K de Groot and B W Nickel (2007) Family Provision in Australia, Third Edition, Butterworths, Australia at [2.3]; Singer v Berghouse (1994) 181 CLR 201; Vigolo v Bostin (2005) 221 CLR 191.[7] Bartlett v Coomber [2008] NSWCA 100 at [57]-[58], [72], [90]-[91]. The question of whether the applicant and Daniel have been left without adequate provision is to be answered having regard to the their financial position, the size and nature of the estate, the totality of the relationship between the applicant and the deceased and the relationship between the deceased and other persons who have legitimate claims upon the estate.[8] If they have a legitimate claim on the estate, the second question is what amount they should properly receive. This requires consideration of what provision a “wise and just testator” would have made. [8] Singer v Berghouse (1994) 181 CLR 201 at 209-210. Neither the applicant or Daniel enjoyed any substantial relationship with the deceased, He did not maintain or support either of them before his death. But it is clear that both the applicant and Daniel are in need of maintenance and support. The only other person with an interest in the estate has agreed to compromise the claims. This is a significant factor that ought to be afforded considerable weight,[9] especially where estate is not large and litigation would likely consume a substantial portion of it. In the present matter the evidence establishes that there is a proper basis for the compromise agreed by the parties.[9] Watts v The Public Trustee of Queensland [2010] QSC 410, [15]. For these reasons I will make an order in the terms of the draft.