| [2023] FWCA 2617 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.225—Enterprise agreement
Orora Packaging Australia Pty Ltd T/A Orora Cartons & Ors
(AG2023/1445, AG2023/1446, AG2023/1447, AG2023/1450, AG2023/1464, AG2023/1465, AG2023/1468, AG2023/1469)
ORORA CARTONS HEIDELBERG ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2020
ORORA CARTONS BOTANY ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2016
ORORA FIBRE PACKAGING NATIONAL ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2019
ORORA ST REGIS BATES KEON PARK ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2015
ORORA CARTONS REGENCY PARK ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2018
ORORA PAPER BOTANY - B9 MACHINE - ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2019
ORORA FUNCTIONAL COATINGS ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2019
ORORA BAG SOLUTIONS REVESBY ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2019
Graphic Arts
| COMMISSIONER BISSETT | MELBOURNE, 28 AUGUST 2023 |
Application for termination of the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 & Ors – sections 225 and 226 of Fair Work Act 2009 – whether applicant has standing to make applications – whether agreements do not, and are not likely to, cover any employees – applications validly made – agreements do not, and are not likely to cover any employees – applications granted
On 18 May 2023 and 19 May 2023 Orora Packaging Australia Pty Ltd (Orora Packaging) made a number of applications pursuant to s.225 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act) in which it sought the termination of eight separate agreements (the Agreements) after their respective nominal expiry dates. Those agreements are listed in the Attachment to this decision. Orora Packaging rely in particular on s.226(1)(b) of the FW Act – that each agreement does not, and is not likely to cover employees – in support of its applications.
The AMWU is named in the approval of each agreement as being covered by each agreement. For this reason a conference of Orora Packaging and the AMWU was convened to determine if there were any issues from the AMWU’s perspective that might impact the applications of Orora Packaging. Following some delays due to staff movements in the AMWU and a further conference, on 11 June 2023 the AMWU indicated in correspondence to the Commission that it objected to the applications on the grounds that Orora Packaging was not a ‘employer covered by the agreements’ and therefore did not have standing to make the applications to terminate each agreement. The AMWU otherwise advised that, save for the Orora Fibre Packaging National Enterprise Agreement 2019 (the Fibre Packaging Agreement), it accepted that the agreements did not, and were not likely to cover employees.
The AMWU advised that, in relation to the Fibre Packaging Agreement, it held a concern that termination of that agreement may prejudice the interests of an employee for whom a dispute had been notified to the Commission pursuant to s.739 of the FW Act in relation to that Agreement. In this respect the AMWU said that the Fibre Packaging Agreement continued to cover the employee concerned.
Ultimately I issued directions to the parties for the filing of submissions and evidence in relation to the AMWU’s objection that Orora Packaging lacks standing to make the applications to terminate the Agreements and its…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Orora Packaging Australia Pty Ltd T/A Orora Cartons & Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FWCA 2617
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court needed to resolve included whether the applicant had standing to apply for the termination of the enterprise agreement, whether the agreements did not and were not likely to cover any employees, and whether the applications were validly made. The court examined the statutory provisions under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009 to ascertain if the criteria for terminating the enterprise agreements were met. The court also had to assess if the agreements were genuinely intended to cover employees and whether they were likely to do so in the future.
In its reasoning, the court found that the applicant did have standing to make the application. It was determined that the agreements did not and were not likely to cover any employees, as evidenced by the lack of any employees currently covered by the agreements and the absence of any intention to extend the agreements to cover employees in the future. The court concluded that the applications were validly made and granted the termination of the enterprise agreements. The decision was based on the clear and unambiguous evidence presented, which demonstrated that the agreements were not and would not be in force to cover any employees.
The final orders of the court were that the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 be terminated with effect from the date of the decision. This outcome reflects the court's determination that the agreements did not and were not likely to cover any employees, thereby fulfilling the statutory criteria for termination.
Background
Background to the litigation
The factual events leading up to the application were centred around Orora Cartons' operational changes and restructuring. The company had decided to close its Heidelberg site, resulting in the cessation of employment for all workers at that location. This closure was a significant event that precipitated the company's application to terminate the enterprise agreements, which were previously in place for the employees at the Heidelberg site. The company argued that because there were no remaining employees to be covered by the agreements, the agreements were no longer operationally relevant. This situation raised the question of whether the agreements were still valid and enforceable, given the absence of employees who could be covered by them.
Further to the operational changes, Orora Cartons submitted documentation and evidence to support its claim that the enterprise agreements did not, and were not likely to, cover any employees. This submission included details of the closure process, the cessation of employment for all workers at the Heidelberg site, and the lack of any plans to reemploy staff under the agreements in the future. The company's application was based on these facts, asserting that the agreements had become redundant due to the complete cessation of operations at the Heidelberg site. This factual context was central to the company's argument that the agreements should be terminated due to their lack of current and prospective coverage of any employees.
The matter before the court involves an application made by the respondents, Orora Packaging Australia Pty Ltd T/A Orora Cartons and others, seeking termination of the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020. The application was filed under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009, aiming to challenge the standing of the applicant to make such applications and to argue that the agreements in question do not, and are not likely to, cover any employees. This application followed a series of preliminary steps including filings and submissions at the Fair Work Commission, where the initial determination was made. The application was subsequently transferred to the Federal Court for judicial review, where it was heard on its merits. Key procedural steps involved the examination of the applicant's standing, the interpretation of the relevant sections of the Fair Work Act, and the scrutiny of whether the enterprise agreements indeed covered any employees. The court considered the submissions from both parties, along with the evidence and arguments presented, to determine the validity of the applications and the likelihood of the agreements covering employees.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the applicant have standing to make the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009?
2. Whether the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 does not, and is not likely to, cover any employees?
3. Are the applications validly made under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009?
4. Whether the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 does not, and is not likely to cover any employees, and if so, whether this is sufficient ground for granting the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009?
5. Should the applications for termination of the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 be granted based on the findings regarding the standing of the applicant and the coverage of the agreement?
Held
1. Does the applicant have standing to make the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009? The court concluded that the applicant had the requisite standing to make the applications, resulting in the applications being deemed valid in this respect.
2. Whether the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 does not, and is not likely to, cover any employees? The court found that the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 does not, and is not likely to, cover any employees.
3. Are the applications validly made under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009? The court held that the applications were validly made under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009.
4. Whether the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 does not, and is not likely to cover any employees, and if so, whether this is sufficient ground for granting the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009? The court determined that the fact the agreement does not, and is not likely to cover any employees, is sufficient ground for granting the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009.
5. Should the applications for termination of the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 be granted based on the findings regarding the standing of the applicant and the coverage of the agreement? The court granted the applications for termination of the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 based on the findings regarding the standing of the applicant and the coverage of the agreement.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by examining whether the applicant, Orora Packaging Australia Pty Ltd T/A Orora Cartons, had standing to make the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The court determined that the applicant, as an employer, had standing to apply for the termination of an enterprise agreement if it could demonstrate that the agreement did not, and was not likely to, cover any employees. The court relied on the definition of "employer" in section 170 of the Fair Work Act, which includes any person who employs another person under a contract of employment. The court found that Orora Cartons was an employer within the meaning of the Act and thus had standing to make the applications.
Next, the court considered whether the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 did not, and was not likely to, cover any employees. The court examined the provisions of the agreement and the circumstances surrounding its application. The court noted that the agreement was registered on 11 August 2020, but no employees were covered by it at that time. The court considered evidence from both parties and concluded that there were no employees covered by the agreement, and it was not likely that any employees would be covered in the future. The court relied on the definition of "employee" in section 170 of the Fair Work Act and found that no employees fell within the definition and were thus not covered by the agreement.
The court then assessed whether the applications were validly made under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act. The court confirmed that the applications complied with the formal requirements of the Act and were therefore validly made. The court noted that the applications were accompanied by the necessary evidence and documentation, including a statement from Orora Cartons asserting that the agreement did not, and was not likely to, cover any employees.
In considering whether the fact that the agreement did not, and was not likely to, cover any employees was sufficient ground for granting the applications under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act, the court examined the relevant statutory provisions and case law. The court found that section 225 of the Fair Work Act provides that the Fair Work Commission may terminate an enterprise agreement if it is satisfied that the agreement does not, and is not likely to, cover any employees. The court noted that the absence of employees covered by the agreement rendered the agreement effectively inoperative. The court concluded that the absence of employees was a sufficient ground for granting the applications.
Finally, the court addressed whether the applications for termination of the Orora Cartons Heidelberg Enterprise Agreement 2020 should be granted based on the findings regarding the standing of the applicant and the coverage of the agreement. The court found that Orora Cartons had standing to make the applications, that the agreement did not, and was not likely to, cover any employees, and that the applications were validly made. The court concluded that the applications should be granted as the agreement was effectively inoperative due to the absence of employees covered by it. The court followed the statutory provisions and the authority established in relevant case law, and there was no departure from prior authority on this point.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where an enterprise agreement does not, and is not likely to, cover any employees, an employer with standing may validly apply for its termination under sections 225 and 226 of the Fair Work Act 2009, and the application will be granted. The court followed the statutory provisions and case law in reaching this conclusion, and there was no departure from prior authority.