SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Appeal from a Master: Application)
ORIO HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR v COSTI & CO (NO 3)
[2009] SASC 359
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Vanstone
25 November 2009
PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - REMUNERATION - COSTS AGREEMENTS - OTHER MATTERS
Application for review of a provisional costs order made by a Master - written retainer agreement between solicitor and clients remained unsigned - whether Master erred in finding that there was no oral acceptance by clients of that written retainer agreement - whether Master erred in finding there was no acceptance by conduct of the written retainer agreement.
Held: open for Master to find that there was no oral acceptance of the terms of the written retainer agreement - conduct relied on by solicitor to show acceptance of terms of written retainer agreement ambivalent - application dismissed.
Orio Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor v Costi & Co (2008) 257 LSJS 185; Empirnall Holdings Pty Ltd v Machan Paull Partners Pty Ltd (1988) 14 NSWLR 523, considered.
ORIO HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR v COSTI & CO (NO 3)
[2009] SASC 359Civil
VANSTONE J: By order made 12 August 2008 I referred back to a Master a review of a costs order made by him so that he might make further findings on specific matters of evidence.
The history of the matter is set out in the accompanying reasons I then gave: Orio Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor v Costi & Co [2008] SASC 218; (2008) 257 LSJS 185. The Master has now made the further findings of fact requested of him. The matter has returned to me along with a new Notice of Appeal. I consider that the new notice is both otiose and incompetent, first, as no orders disposing of the original matter were ever made, and second, because an appeal lies against orders rather than findings, and the only order made by the Master in conjunction with the further findings was to refer the matter back to me. I propose to dispose of both originating processes.
A number of the original complaints of the appellant’s solicitor were dealt with by me in my earlier reasons. The delivery of those reasons, as well as the additional findings made recently by the Master, have narrowed and clarified the issues.
Mr Hoile, for the solicitor, now presses two grounds of review. First he argues that the Master’s conclusion that there was no express oral agreement to the terms of the written retainer agreement produced by the solicitor was against the weight of the evidence. Then he argues that, in any event, the Master applied an incorrect legal test in considering the question whether there was acceptance of the written retainer by conduct and that this led to error in rejecting the solicitor’s contention that there was acceptance by conduct.
The Master found that a draft written retainer agreement was generated by the solicitor on 22 April 2004. The solicitor’s evidence before…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Orio Holdings Pty Ltd v Costi & Co (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] SASC 359
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues addressed were whether the Master erred in determining that there was no oral acceptance and no acceptance by conduct of the written retainer agreement. The court examined the evidence presented regarding the oral agreement and the conduct of the parties. The solicitor argued that there was an oral acceptance and acceptance by conduct, relying on specific actions and communications that implied acceptance of the terms. However, the Master found the evidence insufficient to establish acceptance. The court upheld the Master's findings, acknowledging the difficulty in determining the exact events and communications regarding the retainer agreement due to conflicting testimonies from both the client and the solicitor.
The court's reasoning was that the Master was within his discretion to find no oral acceptance, given the ambivalent conduct and conflicting evidence presented. The solicitor's argument about estoppel was dismissed as it did not provide a clear advantage to his case. The Master's decision was supported as it aligned with the burden of proof resting on the solicitor, and the Master's conclusion that the solicitor did not meet this burden was deemed reasonable. The appeal was dismissed, and the provisional costs order was confirmed as a judgment of the Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The solicitors contended that the clients had orally accepted the terms of the written retainer agreement, but this was denied by the clients. The Master had found that there was no oral acceptance of the terms of the written retainer agreement. The solicitors also argued that the clients had accepted the terms of the written retainer agreement by conduct, but the Master found that the conduct relied on by the solicitors to show acceptance of the terms of the written retainer agreement was ambivalent. The solicitors further argued that the clients were estopped from denying acceptance of the terms, but the court did not consider this argument further, finding it added nothing to the principal arguments.
The Master had reservations about the reliability of both the clients and the solicitors on the important factual issues in this matter, and found it difficult to make affirmative findings about what was done and said in respect of the retainer agreement. The Master rejected the clients’ denial of being present on 23 April but did not wholly accept the solicitor’s version of what occurred at that time. The onus of proof remained on the solicitor and the Master found that he was not persuaded that the terms of the written agreement were accepted. The court found that on the evidence, this position was open to the Master. The application for review was dismissed, and orders were made revoking a previous order, confirming the costs order made by the Master as a judgment of the Court, and striking out the Notice of appeal.
Orio Holdings Pty Ltd v Costi & Co (No 3) is an appeal against a provisional costs order made by a Master of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal arose from a written retainer agreement between the client, Orio Holdings, and the solicitor, Costi & Co, which remained unsigned. The central issue before the court was whether the Master erred in finding that there was no oral acceptance by the clients of the terms of the written retainer agreement and whether the Master erred in finding there was no acceptance by conduct of the written retainer agreement. The matter initially came before the Master as an application for review of the provisional costs order. The Master had concluded that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the clients had orally accepted the terms of the retainer agreement or had accepted them by conduct. The solicitor argued that the clients were estopped from denying acceptance of the terms of the retainer agreement, but this argument was not pursued further in the appeal. The appeal was dismissed, with the court confirming the costs order as entered by the Master. The appeal was subsequently struck out.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Orio Holdings Pty Ltd v Costi & Co (No 3), the Court of Appeal was tasked with reviewing a provisional costs order made by a Master. This case primarily concerned whether the Master had erred in finding that there was no oral acceptance by the clients of a written retainer agreement and whether the Master erred in finding that there was no acceptance by conduct of the written retainer agreement. The Court found it open to the Master to conclude that there was no oral acceptance of the terms of the written retainer agreement and that the conduct relied upon by the solicitor to demonstrate acceptance of the agreement's terms was ambivalent.
The Court began by addressing the issue of oral acceptance. The solicitor argued that the clients had orally accepted the terms of the written retainer agreement. However, the Court found that the Master's findings on this matter were open to him based on the evidence presented. The Court held that because of the Master's reservations about the reliability of both parties, it was appropriate for him to conclude that the terms of the written agreement were not accepted orally. This decision was based on the principle that the onus of proof lay with the solicitor to demonstrate acceptance of the terms of the written agreement, a burden he had not discharged to the satisfaction of the Master.
Turning to the issue of acceptance by conduct, the Court noted that the solicitor had attempted to demonstrate acceptance through certain actions of the clients. However, the Court held that the conduct relied upon was ambivalent and did not clearly establish acceptance of the terms of the written retainer agreement. The Court emphasized that for acceptance by conduct to be effective, the conduct must be clear and unequivocal. In this case, the conduct was not sufficiently clear to support a finding of acceptance, and thus, the Master's conclusion was upheld.
Finally, the Court briefly addressed the argument of estoppel put forward by the solicitor. The Court noted that the solicitor did not articulate how the estoppel argument could succeed if his primary arguments did not. The Court found that the estoppel argument did not add anything to the case and declined to address it further. The Court's decision not to engage with the estoppel argument further reinforces the principle that the onus of proof in matters of contract acceptance remains with the party asserting it.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that it is open to the Master to conclude that there was no oral acceptance of the terms of the written retainer agreement and that conduct relied upon to demonstrate acceptance must be clear and unequivocal. The Court did not depart from prior authority but rather applied established principles of contract law, including the onus of proof and the requirement for clear and unequivocal conduct in demonstrating acceptance of contract terms. The Court's decision reinforces the importance of clear evidence in establishing the terms of a contract, whether through oral agreement or conduct.