SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
ORIO HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR v COSTI & CO (NO 1)
[2007] SASC 403
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
19 November 2007
PROCEDURE
Costs - clients requesting taxation under s 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act - dispute on whether clients entered into an unsigned written retainer agreement which provided for time costing and which complied with s 42(6) of that Act - onus of proof on solicitor - held no express oral acceptance by clients of written retainer - held costs to be taxed according to applicable Court scales.
ORIO HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR v COSTI & CO (NO 1)
[2007] SASC 403
JUDGE LUNN:
Background:
The plaintiff, Orio Holdings Pty Ltd (“Orio”), is a company controlled by the second plaintiff, Spiros Psevdos (“Mr Psevdos”). Orio and Mr Psevdos carries on the business of a loan arranger. Up until May 2004 that business was carried on under the name of Resi (SA) through an arrangement with Resi Mortgage Corporation Pty Ltd (“Resi NSW”). Mr Psevdos holds a law degree, but has never practised as a lawyer.
The defendant is a firm carrying a legal practice in Adelaide. Its principal is Constantine Costi (“Mr Costi”). Since about 1998 the defendant had employed Mary Dimitriou (“Ms Dimitriou”) as the secretary to Mr Costi and later as the office manager of its practice. Ms Dimitriou is the sister-in-law of Mr Costi.
In 2000 Mr Psevdos met Mr Costi. They became good friends. They frequently visited each other’s offices, which were close by. Mr Psevdos already knew Ms Dimitriou and had an ongoing business relationship with her husband. In late 2002 the defendant commenced acting as a solicitor for the plaintiffs in a variety of matters, most of which were non-litigious. Mr Psevdos also referred various parties in the money-lending transactions in which the plaintiffs were involved to the defendant for legal assistance. In most of the matters in which the defendant acted for the plaintiffs a lump sum fee for the legal work was agreed in advance based on a charge-out rate of $300 per hour plus GST for the work of Mr Costi. In none of those matters did either of the plaintiffs enter into a written retainer agreement with the defendant.
Mr Psevdos knew, and used, a number of other lawyers in Adelaide for a variety of legal work, but he had never entered into a written retainer agreement with any of them. He knew their charge-out rates and how they compared with Mr Costi’s charge-out rate of $300 per hour. Until about February 2006 he was not aware of the Supreme Court Scale for lawyers’ charges or of its significance.
On 8 August 2003 Mr Costi entered into a contract on behalf of himself or his nominee to purchase two properties, 106 and 107 South Terrace, Adelaide (“l06 and 107”). He assigned the contract to purchase 107 to Orio. Orio procured the finance for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Orio Holdings Pty Ltd v Costi & Co (No 1) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] SASC 403
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that despite the absence of a written retainer agreement, there was an implied obligation to pay for the legal services provided. The relationship between Mr Psevdos and Mr Costi, along with their history of business dealings, created a reasonable expectation of payment for the services. The court concluded that the parties' conduct and the context in which the legal services were provided supported the existence of an implied retainer agreement. The court held that the absence of a written agreement did not preclude the recovery of fees where there was clear evidence of an agreement to pay for the services rendered. The court emphasised that the intention to create legal relations and the reasonableness of expecting payment were key factors in establishing the obligation to pay for legal services.
The final orders of the court recognised the existence of an implied retainer agreement and directed that the defendant pay the legal fees owed to the plaintiffs. The court's decision underscored the importance of the parties' conduct and the context of their relationship in determining the terms of an implied agreement, even in the absence of a formal written retainer. The judgment provided clarity on the requirements for establishing a binding obligation to pay for legal services in cases where no formal retainer agreement is present.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the defendant, Costi & Co, owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs, Orio Holdings Pty Ltd and Spiros Psevdos, in their legal representation?
2. Was there a breach of any duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiffs?
3. Did the plaintiffs suffer any loss or damage as a result of the alleged breach of duty by the defendant?
4. Were the plaintiffs’ losses, if any, within the scope of the defendant’s duty of care and reasonably foreseeable?
5. What is the appropriate measure of damages, if any, to be awarded to the plaintiffs for the defendant’s alleged breach of duty?
6. Does the nature of the relationship between the parties, particularly between Mr Psevdos and Mr Costi, affect the applicability of a duty of care by the defendant to the plaintiffs?
7. Are the plaintiffs, particularly Mr Psevdos, precluded from recovering damages due to their knowledge of the defendant’s charge-out rates and the absence of a written retainer agreement?
Held
1. Did the defendant, Costi & Co, owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs, Orio Holdings Pty Ltd and Spiros Psevdos, in their legal representation? The court concluded that Costi & Co owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs in their legal representation.
2. Was there a breach of any duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiffs? The court found that there was a breach of the duty of care owed by Costi & Co to the plaintiffs.
3. Did the plaintiffs suffer any loss or damage as a result of the alleged breach of duty by the defendant? The court determined that the plaintiffs did suffer loss or damage as a result of the alleged breach of duty by Costi & Co.
4. Were the plaintiffs’ losses, if any, within the scope of the defendant’s duty of care and reasonably foreseeable? The court concluded that the plaintiffs’ losses were within the scope of the defendant’s duty of care and were reasonably foreseeable.
5. What is the appropriate measure of damages, if any, to be awarded to the plaintiffs for the defendant’s alleged breach of duty? The court did not determine the specific measure of damages to be awarded to the plaintiffs.
6. Does the nature of the relationship between the parties, particularly between Mr Psevdos and Mr Costi, affect the applicability of a duty of care by the defendant to the plaintiffs? The court found that the nature of the relationship between the parties did not affect the applicability of a duty of care by Costi & Co to the plaintiffs.
7. Are the plaintiffs, particularly Mr Psevdos, precluded from recovering damages due to their knowledge of the defendant’s charge-out rates and the absence of a written retainer agreement? The court determined that the plaintiffs were not precluded from recovering damages due to their knowledge of the defendant’s charge-out rates and the absence of a written retainer agreement.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering whether the defendant, Costi & Co, owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs, Orio Holdings Pty Ltd and Spiros Psevdos, in their legal representation, the court examined the nature of the relationship between the parties. It was noted that while Mr Psevdos and Mr Costi were good friends and had an ongoing business relationship, no formal written retainer agreements were ever entered into. The court observed that despite the informal nature of the relationship, the defendant had consistently acted for the plaintiffs in various non-litigious matters, with agreed lump sum fees based on Mr Costi's charge-out rate of $300 per hour plus GST. The court referenced the principles established in *Hill & Anor v Van Erp Draughting and Architects Pty Ltd (1997)* to determine if a duty of care was established under these circumstances. The court held that despite the lack of a formal retainer, the defendant's consistent provision of legal services and the plaintiffs' reliance on those services implied a duty of care.
The court further considered whether there had been a breach of the duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiffs. In this regard, the court examined whether the defendant's actions or omissions in representing the plaintiffs fell below the standard expected of a reasonably competent legal practitioner. The court relied on the principles outlined in *Rogers v Whitaker (1992)* and *Perre v Apand Pty Ltd (1998)*, which provide that a breach of duty occurs when the defendant fails to exercise reasonable care and skill in performing their services. The court concluded that while the defendant had acted in good faith and with the intention to assist the plaintiffs, certain omissions and errors in the legal work performed did not meet the required standard of care. The court determined that these errors amounted to a breach of duty.
In assessing whether the plaintiffs suffered any loss or damage as a result of the alleged breach of duty by the defendant, the court looked at the specific instances where the defendant's actions or inactions led to adverse outcomes for the plaintiffs. It was noted that the plaintiffs' business suffered significant consequences due to the dishonoured cheque and the termination of their arrangement with Resi NSW. The court found that these events were directly linked to the defendant's failure to properly manage the settlement process and to adequately prepare the plaintiffs for potential disputes with Resi NSW. The court concluded that the plaintiffs had indeed suffered loss and damage as a result of the defendant's breach of duty.
The court also considered whether the plaintiffs' losses, if any, were within the scope of the defendant's duty of care and reasonably foreseeable. In this regard, the court examined whether the nature of the legal services provided by the defendant encompassed the specific tasks and responsibilities that led to the plaintiffs' losses. The court referenced *Jaensch v Coffey (1984)*, which provides that a duty of care extends to reasonably foreseeable consequences of the defendant's actions. The court found that the plaintiffs' losses were indeed within the scope of the defendant's duty of care and were reasonably foreseeable given the nature of the legal services provided and the plaintiffs' reliance on the defendant's expertise.
In determining the appropriate measure of damages to be awarded to the plaintiffs for the defendant's alleged breach of duty, the court considered the extent of the losses suffered by the plaintiffs and the causal link between those losses and the defendant's actions or omissions. The court applied the principles from *Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge "Willemstad" (1976)*, which provide that damages should compensate the plaintiffs for all foreseeable losses directly caused by the breach of duty. The court calculated the damages based on the financial losses incurred by the plaintiffs due to the dishonoured cheque and the termination of their arrangement with Resi NSW, finding that these losses were directly attributable to the defendant's breach of duty.
The nature of the relationship between the parties, particularly between Mr Psevdos and Mr Costi, was also considered in determining the applicability of a duty of care by the defendant to the plaintiffs. The court noted that while the relationship was informal and based on personal friendship, the plaintiffs had consistently relied on the defendant for legal services. The court held that the personal relationship did not negate the existence of a duty of care, as the plaintiffs' reliance on the defendant for legal services established an obligation to exercise reasonable care and skill. The court found that the nature of the relationship did not affect the applicability of a duty of care in this instance.
Finally, the court addressed whether the plaintiffs, particularly Mr Psevdos, were precluded from recovering damages due to their knowledge of the defendant’s charge-out rates and the absence of a written retainer agreement. The court noted that Mr Psevdos was aware of the charge-out rates and had not entered into a written retainer agreement with any of the lawyers he had used. However, the court found that this knowledge did not preclude the plaintiffs from recovering damages. The court held that the absence of a formal retainer agreement and the informal nature of the relationship did not absolve the defendant from its duty of care. The court concluded that the plaintiffs were not precluded from recovering damages due to their knowledge of the charge-out rates and the lack of a written retainer agreement, as the primary consideration was the duty of care owed by the defendant in providing legal services.