TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
ReOpposition by Orientis Gourmet to application by ABCDEX Pty Ltd and Burkhard Geiger for cessation of protection of International Registration 1040748 (30) (Australian designation 1504642) – LØV ORGANIC - in the name of Orientis Gourmet
Delegate: Robert Wilson
Representation: Opponent: Phillips Ormond Fitzpatrick
Applicants: Self-represented
Decision: 2020 ATMO 134
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – Reg17A.48F opposition: opposition to application for cessation of protection pursuant to reg 17A.48C – no use of trade mark during relevant period – extension of protection to cease
Background
1. Orientis Gourmet (‘the Opponent’) is the Holder of International Registration 1040748 (‘the IR’). Protection of the IR was extended to Australia; relevant details are as follows:
Australian Designation:
1504642
Filing Date:
4 May 2012
Goods:
Class 30: Tea, non-medicinal infusions, coffee
(‘the Goods’)
Trade Mark:
LØV ORGANIC
(‘the Trade Mark’)
2. Any references to sections or regulations, below, are references to sections or regulations of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) or the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth), respectively, unless otherwise indicated.
3. On 5 April 2018, ABCDEX Pty Ltd and Burkhard Geiger (‘the Applicants’) filed an application (‘the Application’) seeking cessation of protection of the Trade Mark. The Applicants alleged that the Trade Mark was not used in good faith in relation to any of the Goods during the three year period ending on 5 March 2018 (‘the Relevant Period’). The Applicants also alleged that on the day on which the application for extension of protection to Australia was filed, the Opponent had no intention in good faith:
(i)to use the Trade Mark in Australia; or
(ii)to authorise the use of the Trade Mark in Australia; or
(iii)to assign the Trade Mark to a body corporate for use by the body corporate in Australia;
in relation to the Goods and that the Opponent:
(iv)has not used the Trade Mark in good faith in Australia; or
(v)has not used the Trade Mark in Australia;
in relation to the Goods at any time before the period of one month ending on the day on which the Application was filed.
4. The Opponent filed a Notice of Opposition consisting of a Notice of Intention to Oppose filed on 29 May 2018 and a Statement of Grounds and Particulars which was filed on 22 June 2018. The Applicants filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 31 July 2018.
Evidence
5. The Opponent filed Evidence in Support of its opposition (‘EIS’) which consists of:
·Statutory Declaration made on 12 November 2018 by Marine Guillou, an employee of the firm Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick, the representative of the Opponent, with Exhibits MG-1 to MG-7 (‘the Guillou declaration’).
6. The Applicants filed Evidence in Answer (‘EIA’) which consists of:
·Declaration made on 22 January 2019 by Burkhard Geiger, the Managing Director of ABCDEX Pty Ltd,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Orientis Gourmet v ABCDEX Pty Ltd and Burkhard Geiger and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] ATMO 134
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Opponent had established use of the trade mark, or a substantially similar mark, within the relevant period to resist the application for removal. Given that an extension of protection had been granted for more than five years, the court focused its consideration on the grounds for removal under section 92(4)(b) of the relevant Act.
The court reasoned that to successfully oppose the removal application, the Opponent was required to provide clearly dated evidence demonstrating use of the trade mark in relation to the goods within the specified relevant period. The court found that the evidence provided by the Opponent, including declarations and exhibits, was insufficient. Specifically, dated documents such as vendor registration forms and invoices were outside the relevant period, and images of product packaging, while showing the trade mark, contained dates that were either outside the relevant period or too difficult to read to be of assistance. The court noted that undated examples of use carry little weight in such proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
Orientis Gourmet has opposed the removal application, asserting that it has used the trade mark in relation to its goods within the relevant period. To support its claim, Orientis Gourmet submitted a declaration by Guillou, stating that it has been selling its tea and infusions under the trade mark in Australia since at least 2013, with sales continuing since that date. The declaration also mentions that Orientis Gourmet began selling its products through Myer outlets. However, the provided documents, such as vendor registration forms and invoices, are dated outside the relevant period and do not assist in proving use during that time.
Further, Orientis Gourmet provided images of goods bearing the trade mark with Myer Limited as the importer. These images show packages of tea with the trade mark visible, although the low resolution makes it difficult to read the text on the packages. Only two of the images appear to have dates, both of which fall outside the relevant period. One date appears to be '01/2015' and the other '04/2015'. These images do not provide sufficient evidence of use within the relevant period, as required to rebut the Applicants' claim of non-use.
The matter of Orientis Gourmet v ABCDEX Pty Ltd and Burkhard Geiger came before the court following an application by ABCDEX Pty Ltd and Burkhard Geiger to remove the registered trade mark from the Australian Register of Trade Marks. This application was lodged under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The application was predicated on the allegation that Orientis Gourmet, the proprietor of the trade mark, had not used the trade mark in relation to the goods during the Relevant Period. The case represents an interlocutory application to determine the admissibility of evidence regarding use of the trade mark. Prior to this hearing, no formal proceedings had been instituted; this application was the first formal step in the judicial process. The case is not an appeal or a judicial review but rather a direct application under the provisions of the Trade Marks Act. The court must now consider whether the evidence submitted by Orientis Gourmet is sufficient to rebut the allegation of non-use and thereby oppose the application for removal of the trade mark.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the evidence provided by the Opponent sufficient to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period?
2. Can undated examples of use of the Trade Mark carry any weight in rebutting the allegation of non-use?
3. Are the documents in MG-1 dated outside of the Relevant Period and therefore not helpful to the Opponent?
4. Do the images in MG-2 show the Trade Mark on the goods with any legible dates that fall within the Relevant Period?
5. What weight, if any, should be given to the images in MG-2 given the difficulty in reading the dates on the packages?
6. Does the evidence from MG-1 and MG-2 together suffice to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period?
Held
1. The court concluded that the evidence provided by the Opponent was insufficient to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period; the result was that the application for removal was likely to be upheld.
2. The court held that undated examples of use of the Trade Mark carried little, if any, weight in rebutting the allegation of non-use; the result was that such evidence did not aid the Opponent.
3. The court found that the documents in MG-1 were dated outside of the Relevant Period and, therefore, not helpful to the Opponent; the result was that these documents did not contribute to the Opponent’s case.
4. The court determined that the images in MG-2 did not show the Trade Mark on the goods with any legible dates that fall within the Relevant Period; the result was that these images did not effectively rebut the allegation of non-use.
5. The court concluded that, given the difficulty in reading the dates on the packages in MG-2, the weight to be given to these images was minimal; the result was that they did not significantly support the Opponent's claim.
6. The court found that the evidence from MG-1 and MG-2 together did not suffice to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period; the result was that the application for removal was likely to be successful.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Orientis Gourmet v ABCDEX Pty Ltd and Burkhard Geiger, the court was tasked with determining whether the Opponent provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate the use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period. The court began by clarifying that the provisions of s 92(4) of the Act provide the grounds for removal of a registered trade mark, with s 101 giving the Registrar the discretion to consider non-use matters. Given the specifics of these provisions and the facts of this case, the court focused on the application for removal under s 92(4)(b). The court reiterated that, unless the discretion under s 101 is invoked, the Opponent must establish that it has used the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period to successfully oppose the Application.
The court then assessed the evidence provided by the Opponent. It was established that the Opponent had to provide clearly dated evidence of use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period to rebut the allegation of non-use. The court noted that undated examples of use carry little, if any, weight in such matters. The Opponent had provided a declaration from Guillou stating that the Trade Mark had been used in Australia since 2013 and that use had been ongoing. The court noted that while this declaration provided some information, it did not provide sufficient evidence of use within the Relevant Period.
The court then examined the documents in MG-1, which were declared to be copies of vendor registration forms and invoices dated 2013 and 2014. The court found that these documents were dated outside of the Relevant Period and therefore did not assist the Opponent in proving use within that period. The court further considered Exhibit MG-2, which was declared to be images of goods bearing the Trade Mark with labels showing Myer Limited as the importer. However, the images were of low resolution, making it difficult or impossible to read the writing on the packages. The court noted that while the Trade Mark was apparent on some of the packaging, there were only two images with legible dates, both of which appeared to be outside of the Relevant Period.
In assessing the weight of the images in MG-2, the court found that due to the difficulty in reading the dates on the packages, it was challenging to determine if the Trade Mark was used within the Relevant Period. The court concluded that the evidence from MG-1 and MG-2 together did not suffice to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period.
The court distinguished this case from prior authority by highlighting the importance of clearly dated evidence in non-use matters and the limited weight of undated examples of use. The court followed the principle that it is incumbent upon the Opponent to provide clearly dated evidence showing use of the Trade Mark within the Relevant Period. The ratio decidendi of this case is that undated examples of use and images with illegible dates do not sufficiently demonstrate use of a Trade Mark within the Relevant Period in opposition proceedings.