Oranville Pty Ltd v Plum Property Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Oranville Pty Ltd and Anor v Plum Property Pty Ltd and Others [2022] QSC 119

PARTIES:

ORANVILLE PTY LTD ACN 081 368 069

(First Plaintiff)
AND

BRISFARM PTY LTD ACN 625 372 009

(Second Plaintiff)

v

PLUM PROPERTY PTY LTD ACN 609 806 920
(First Defendant)
AND
DANIEL MARK LEE
(Second Defendant)
AND
KYMBERLEY SAUNDERS
(Third Defendant)
AND
TYLER BEAN

(Fourth Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 10176 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

9 June 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 May 2022

JUDGE:

Brown J

ORDER:

The order of the Court is that:

1.   The parties are to confer and provide to my Associate by 4pm on 8 July 2022 a revised disclosure protocol and document management plan and proposed directions in relation to disclosure of documents, reflecting these reasons.

2.   I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES – DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS – DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS – GENERALLY – where the second to fourth defendants were former employees of the plaintiffs – where the plaintiffs claim damages for breach of contract and alternatively, equitable compensation for misuse of confidential information and other duties – where the plaintiffs apply for further disclosure pursuant to rule 223(4)(b), or alternatively, rule 371 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) – whether objective likelihood that the duty to disclose has not been complied with

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) rr 211, 223, 261A, 371

Ahga v Devine Real Estate Concord Pty Ltd & Ors [2021] NSWCA 29, cited
Central Queensland Mining Supplies Pty Ltd v Columbia Steel Casting Co Ltd [2011] QSC 183, cited
Golden Vision Gold Coast Pty Ltd & Anor v Orchid Avenue Pty Ltd & Anor [2022] QSC 49, discussed
Integrated Medical Technology Pty Ltd v Gilbert (No 2)
[2015] QSC 124, cited
Robson v REB Engineering Pty Ltd [1997] 2 Qd R 102, cited

COUNSEL:

S S Monks for the applicants
A P Collins with S A Mackie for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Jemmeson & Fisher Solicitors for the applicants
Harding Richards Lawyers for the respondents

  1. BROWN J: The first and second plaintiffs, the applicants, apply for further disclosure brought pursuant to rule 223(4)(b)(i) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (“UCPR”), or alternatively pursuant to rule 371 for a failure to comply with the duty of disclosure in rule 211. In that respect there is nothing unconventional about the application. However, the relief sought could not be described as conventional.[1]  The plaintiffs seek an order that the Court appoint an independent expert to review the first defendant’s Customer Relations Management (“CRM”) Software, computers containing emails sent by or on behalf of the second to fourth defendants from 1 April 2012, their respective mobile phones and any other electronic documents on which they stored information said to be Raine and Horne Confidential information, sent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oranville Pty Ltd v Plum Property Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Oranville Pty Ltd v Plum Property Pty Ltd, the plaintiffs sought damages for breach of contract and, in the alternative, equitable compensation for the misuse of confidential information and other duties. The plaintiffs applied for further disclosure pursuant to rule 223(4)(b) or alternatively, rule 371 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), alleging that there was an objective likelihood that the defendants had not fully complied with their duty to disclose relevant documents. The defendants, who were former employees of the plaintiffs, denied the allegations and objected to the plaintiffs' application for further disclosure.

The court had to determine whether there was an objective likelihood that the defendants had not fully complied with their duty to disclose relevant documents. The plaintiffs argued that the defendants had failed to disclose documents that were necessary to calculate the quantum of damages, such as sale contracts and commission percentages. The plaintiffs also claimed that the defendants had not disclosed documents that would show how they had used the plaintiffs' confidential information, such as sales of properties. The defendants argued that they had provided relevant documents and schedules, and that the plaintiffs' objections were based on irregularities in their evidence.

The court found that there was an objective likelihood that the defendants had not fully complied with their duty to disclose relevant documents. The court noted that the defendants had provided evidence that the fourth defendant did not hold documents for certain properties because he was not working for the plaintiffs at the time. However, the court found that the absence of disclosure of other documents, such as sale contracts and commission percentages, raised doubts about the comprehensiveness of the searches carried out and the duty of disclosure having been complied with. The court also found that the defendants had not disclosed documents that would show how they had used the plaintiffs' confidential information, such as sales of properties.

The court ordered the parties to confer and provide a revised disclosure protocol and document management plan and proposed directions in relation to disclosure of documents, reflecting these reasons. The court also noted that it would hear the parties as to costs.

In summary, the court found that there was an objective likelihood that the defendants had not fully complied with their duty to disclose relevant documents. The court ordered the parties to provide a revised disclosure protocol and document management plan and proposed directions in relation to disclosure of documents, reflecting these reasons. The court also noted that it would hear the parties as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The order of the Court is that:

1. The parties are to confer and provide to my Associate by 4pm on 8 July 2022 a revised disclosure protocol and document management plan and proposed directions in relation to disclosure of documents, reflecting these reasons.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Of the remaining 136 documents:-(a)67 are emails between the defendants and the individuals behind the plaintiffs, Mr Craig Collette and Mr Frank Ham. These emails deal with various administrative matters; many concern the small shareholdings in the first plaintiff that were given to Mr Lee in 2013/14 (Statement of Claim paragraph 4(e)) and to Mr Bean in 2014/15 (Statement of Claim paragraph 6(c)).(b)8 are trust account payment receipts.(c)8 are sale contracts (out of the 206 properties sold and listed in Schedule A).(d)6 are payslips and PAYG statements.(e)4 are solicitors’ correspondence in 2018 and 2019.(f)4 are Oranville Pty Ltd dividend statements.(g)4 are text messages between Kym Saunders and people in Raine & Horne’s office following her resignation.Evidence of objective likelihood The plaintiffs contend that there is an objective likelihood that full disclosure has not been made because:(a)there is a failure to disclose documents going to quantum, that are necessarily in the possession, power or control of the defendants, and not the plaintiffs. Only 8 out of 206 sale contracts relating to the properties in relation to which confidential information was alleged to have been used have been disclosed. The commission percentage in the Form 6s cannot be therefore calculated against a known sale price. However, the defendants submit that a table has now been provided setting out the commissions earnt;(b)nothing has been disclosed about earnings from the 27 rent roll properties in Schedule B of the SOC. The defendants again refer to a schedule now having been provided;(c)no documents are said to have been disclosed in relation to 19 properties out of the 233 that are identified in Schedules A and B to the SOC.[12] I note an objection has been made to the relevant paragraph. I do not uphold the objection made. The paragraph and the basis for the statement made is sufficient for Ms Jemmeson to say as a matter of fact whether disclosure has been made of the documents in relation to the properties;(d)there are no documents said to go to what use they made of the plaintiffs’ confidential information that they took and/or used, notwithstanding there is evidence the properties were sold[13];[12]CFI 13 at [11] and the list at exhibit LJ-9 (exhibits page 44).[13]CFI 13 at [12]-[13]. Ms Jemmeson gives examples of where she contends disclosure was incomplete. There are a number of irregularities in her evidence which are properly the subject of complaint. I have determined that I will not allow most objections but have taken them into account in considering the weight of the evidence. Ms Jemmeson deposes that based on her review, the defendants have failed to disclose a single document, screenshot, print-out or other material from their CRM database. I reject the objection to the first sentence of paragraph [12]. She has set out the basis for her belief, namely her review of the documents. She is familiar with what is in such databases from her previous career as a real estate agent. I reject the objection to the second sentence. The relevance of the CRM database is obvious in the context of this case. The statements as to the CRM database do not need to be pleaded but support the objective likelihood of documents not having been disclosed. The objection to the third sentence is upheld. The objection to the fourth sentence is rejected. The basis of the belief is sufficiently established.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, the defendants have provided evidence in relation to the fourth defendant instructing Mr Richards that he does not hold documents for the properties which are referred to in LJ-9 because the fourth defendant was not working for the first defendant at the time, but another agency. The Form 6s were subsequently provided after the defendants’ solicitors sought them from the fourth defendants’ former agency. The absence of disclosure of those documents is explained and does not suggest an objective likelihood of the full disclosure not having been made.Conclusions In the present case the contention of the plaintiffs is that documents that are directly relevant to the use of the confidential information and the extent of the use have not been disclosed, bearing in mind documents are directly relevant not only on the basis they prove but can also disprove the allegations in issue. It is now accepted that the second and fourth defendants emailed information to themselves of clients and properties while in the employ of the first plaintiff, although that was initially denied. There is evidence that the second defendant established the first defendant prior to resigning from the first plaintiff, and soon after some information was emailed to his personal email. There is evidence which supports allegations that the second and third defendants may have diverted some clients away from the plaintiffs to the first defendant. While the defendants’ solicitors have indicated that there is nothing improper about emailing the alleged confidential information to be used to work at home, the correspondence does not state it was not used by the defendants after their resignation from the first plaintiff and subsequent employment by the first defendant. The evidence supports the fact that there is an objective likelihood proper disclosure has not been made in relation to all of the properties identified in Schedules A and B of the SOC, as identified by Ms Jemmeson, bearing in mind the defendants have identified at least one property was not in fact sold by them. There is also an absence of any disclosure in relation to how the defendants were initially retainer by the owners of the properties in Schedules A and B, save for a couple of emails. While the defendants refer to the time that has passed since the confidential information was emailed, there is evidence they have actively dealt with the properties in question. The defendants do not identify any searches carried out of databases to support the fact that reasonable investigations have been made to identify relevant documents, which may have otherwise explained the absence of documents being disclosed where I have found that there is an objective likelihood may exist. There was an absence of disclosure as to the sales of the properties with only 8 out of 206 sale contracts disclosed, and as to the documents with respect to Schedule B of the SOC. The defendants have sought to address those matters through the provision of schedules. The absence of that disclosure originally however raises doubt as to the comprehensiveness of the searches carried out and the duty of disclosure having been complied with when disclosure was made. There is also an absence of any disclosure in relation to how the defendants were initially retained by the owners of the properties in Schedule A and B of the SOC, or their initial contact with those clients, save for a couple of emails. It is highly likely contact was made with clients prior to their signing the Form 6s and that there were texts or emails exchanged in that regard. The fact that the properties were owned by the clients in the schedule emailed by the second and fourth defendants, and the proximity of a number of those sales and the first defendant being retained to manage a number of the properties in Schedule B supports an objective likelihood that the disclosure that has been made by the defendants is incomplete.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.