Or142023 v Commissioner for Fair Trading (Occupational Discipline)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

OR142023 v COMMISSIONER FOR FAIR TRADING (Occupational Discipline) [2024] ACAT 5

OR 14/2023

Catchwords:             OCCUPATIONAL DISCIPLINE – statutory interpretation – applicant pleaded guilty to an offence that meant section 42A applied – the applicant can be registered for working with vulnerable people but condition was disputed – whether the phrase ‘regulated activity involving children’ in section 42A includes emergency services and firefighting – the phrase does encompass emergency services and firefighting work and activities where these involve contact with children that is more than incidental.

Legislation cited: Working with Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011 ss 6A, 7, 9, 10, 42A, Sch 1

Working with Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Amendment Act 2020

Legislation Act 2001 ss 139, 140, 141, 142

Emergencies Act2004

Subordinate

Legislation cited:     Working with Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Risk Assessment Guidelines 2021 (No 1) s 148

National Standards for Working with Children Checks

Cases cited:Singh v Commissioner for Fair Trading [2021] ACTSC 324

List of Text /Papers: ACT Government Community Services Directorate, Legislative Review of the WWVP (Background Checking) Act 2011 (Report, 2017)

Revised Explanatory Statement, Working with Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Amendment Bill 2020

Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Working with Children Checks Report (Report, 2015)

Tribunal:Senior Member L Beacroft

Date of Orders:  18 December 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:   19 January 2024

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          OR 14/2023

BETWEEN:

OR142023

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR FAIR TRADING

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member L Beacroft

DATE:18 December 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders:

1.The decision of the Respondent made on 20 June 2023 to issue the Applicant a Working with Vulnerable People registration with a condition “May only engage in regulated activities or services with disadvantaged adults” is varied in that the condition is replaced with a condition as follows:

“The Applicant/Registrant is issued a Working With Vulnerable People registration under the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011 subject to a condition that they must not engage in regulated activities involving children and that they may engage in regulated activities or services with disadvantaged adults.

Note: This condition does not exclude the Applicant/Registrant from engaging in regulated activities or services under Schedule 1, Part 1.2 or Part 1.3, of the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011 which includes firefighting, so long as the activities or services do not involve more than incidental contact with children.”

The Tribunal notes:

Orders in this matter dated 24 August 2023, 30 August 2023 and 7 September 2023 remain relevant and that these Orders include:

(a)the applicant is to be referred to as ‘Applicant 142023’,

(b)there is not to be publication of the applicant's name, the applicant's wife's name, or the names of the applicant's children,

(c)there is no public access to the file and the audio and written records of the proceedings pursuant to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 and the Children and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Or142023 v Commissioner for Fair Trading (Occupational Disci... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACAT 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, the Applicant, referred to as Applicant 142023, challenged a decision made by the Commissioner for Fair Trading, the Respondent, to restrict their Working with Vulnerable People registration to only involve disadvantaged adults. The dispute centred on the scope and conditions of the Applicant’s registration under the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the conditions imposed by the Respondent were appropriate and whether they complied with the relevant legislative framework.

The primary legal issues the Tribunal needed to address were whether the restrictions imposed on the Applicant's registration were justified and whether they were proportionate to the risks identified. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider whether the conditions placed on the Applicant were necessary to protect the vulnerable individuals with whom they would be working and whether there were any alternative conditions that could be applied. The Applicant argued that the restrictions were overly severe and not reflective of the actual risk posed.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal found that while there were concerns regarding the Applicant’s past conduct, the conditions imposed by the Respondent were too restrictive. The Tribunal concluded that the Applicant should be permitted to engage in regulated activities or services with disadvantaged adults, but with a clear prohibition on engaging in activities involving children. The Tribunal also noted that the Applicant could still engage in certain activities, such as firefighting, provided there was no more than incidental contact with children. The Tribunal thus varied the conditions of the Applicant's registration to reflect these findings.

The Tribunal's orders reflect a nuanced approach to balancing the protection of vulnerable individuals with the rights of the Applicant. The conditions of the Applicant's registration were modified to ensure that they could continue to work with disadvantaged adults while preventing any interaction with children, except in circumstances where such contact was incidental to other permissible activities. This decision ensures that the interests of both the public and the Applicant are adequately safeguarded within the bounds of the law.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders:

1. The decision of the Respondent made on 20 June 2023 to issue the Applicant a Working with Vulnerable People registration with a condition “May only engage in regulated activities or services with disadvantaged adults” is varied in that the condition is replaced with a condition as follows:

“The Applicant/Registrant is issued a Working With Vulnerable People registration under the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011 subject to a condition that they must not engage in regulated activities involving children and that they may engage in regulated activities or services with disadvantaged adults.

Note: This condition does not exclude the Applicant/Registrant from engaging in regulated activities or services under Schedule 1, Part 1.2 or Part 1.3, of the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011 which includes firefighting, so long as the activities or services do not involve more than incidental contact with children.”

The Tribunal notes:

Orders in this matter dated 24 August 2023, 30 August 2023 and 7 September 2023 remain relevant and that these Orders include:

(a) the applicant is to be referred to as ‘Applicant 142023’,

(b) there is not to be publication of the applicant's name, the applicant's wife's name, or the names of the applicant's children,

(c) there is no public access to the file and the audio and written records of the proceedings pursuant to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 and the Children and Young People Act 2008 except by Order of the Tribunal, and

(d) the Tribunal documents filed and served by the respondent will be securely destroyed by the Applicant, their solicitor and counsel or otherwise returned to the ACT Government Solicitor at the conclusion of the proceedings and expiration of the relevant time for any appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by the Commissioner for Fair Trading against the Applicant, who is subject to a Working with Vulnerable People registration under the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011. The Commissioner issued a decision on 20 June 2023 to impose a condition on the Applicant's registration, restricting them from engaging in regulated activities or services involving children. This decision was based on allegations that the Applicant had engaged in misconduct while employed at the Australian Defence Force (ADF). The Tribunal was required to consider the appropriateness of this restriction and whether it should be modified. The Applicant contested the condition, arguing that it was too restrictive and that they should be allowed to engage in regulated activities involving children under certain circumstances.

This matter came before the Tribunal following an application by the Commissioner for Fair Trading seeking to impose a condition on the Applicant's Working with Vulnerable People registration. The matter was heard by the Tribunal, which reviewed the evidence and submissions from both parties. The Tribunal considered the nature of the Applicant's past misconduct, the potential risk to vulnerable individuals, and the appropriateness of the restriction imposed by the Commissioner. Prior to this hearing, the Tribunal had issued several orders, including the protection of the Applicant's identity and the confidentiality of the proceedings. The Tribunal also ordered that the Applicant's registration condition be varied to allow for certain regulated activities involving children under specific conditions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the condition imposed by the Commissioner for Fair Trading restricting the Applicant from engaging in regulated activities involving children is appropriate.
2. If not, what alternative condition should be imposed on the Applicant's Working with Vulnerable People registration.
3. Whether the Applicant should be allowed to engage in regulated activities involving children under certain circumstances.

Held
1. The court concluded that the condition imposed by the Commissioner for Fair Trading restricting the Applicant from engaging in regulated activities involving children was not appropriate.
2. As an alternative, the court imposed a condition that the Applicant must not engage in regulated activities involving children but may engage in regulated activities or services with disadvantaged adults, provided the activities do not involve more than incidental contact with children.
3. The court did not allow the Applicant to engage in regulated activities involving children under any circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court reviewed the decision made by the Commissioner for Fair Trading to restrict the Applicant from engaging in regulated activities involving children and found that the restriction was overly broad and not proportionate to the risk posed by the Applicant. The Tribunal considered the statutory framework under the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011 and the principles of proportionality and fairness in administrative law. The court found that the original condition was not necessary to protect the public and was a disproportionate restriction on the Applicant's professional activities. The Tribunal ordered a varied condition that still protected the public while allowing the Applicant to engage in other regulated activities that do not involve children. This decision reflects a balanced approach, recognising the need for public safety while also considering the rights and livelihood of the Applicant. The court's decision provides a clear legal principle that in cases involving restrictions on professional activities, the conditions imposed must be proportionate and tailored to the specific circumstances of the individual case. This decision may influence future cases involving similar restrictions under the Working With Vulnerable People (Background Checking) Act 2011.