TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by WISELIST PTY LTD to application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by Wise Payments Limited to remove trade mark number 1999009 (classes 9, 36 and 42) - WisePay - in the name of WISELIST PTY LTD
Delegate: | Timothy Brown |
Representation: | Removal Opponent: Stephen Rebikoff, Senior Counsel, instructed by Vardon Legal Removal Applicant: Andrew Sykes of Counsel instructed by Trioli Intellectual Property |
Decision: | 2025 ATMO 143 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – application under section 92(4)(b) – opposition to removal under s 96 – use demonstrated in the relevant period for some services – Registrar’s discretion not exercised – trade mark registration partially removed from the Register. |
Background
This decision concerns an application made under s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[1] by Wise Payments Limited (‘Removal Applicant’) seeking removal of the trade mark registration detailed below from the Register of Trade Marks (‘Register’):
[1] Unless stated otherwise, each reference to a section or regulation is a reference to the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) or Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’).
Trade Mark Number: 1999009
Trade Mark: WisePay (‘Trade Mark’)
Owner: WISELIST PTY LTD (‘Removal Opponent’)
Filing Date: 28 March 2019
Goods and Services: Class 9: Computer programs for financial management; Computer programs for financial reporting; Computer programs for use in processing data relating to financial records; Computer programs relating to financial matters; Computer programs, downloadable; Computer programs, recorded; Computer software; Computer software (programs); Computer software (recorded); Computer software applications (downloadable); Computer software downloaded from the internet; Computer software for business purposes; Computer software platforms, recorded or downloadable; Computer software products; Computer software programs; Computer software programs for database management; Computer terminals for use with credit cards at point of sale; Computer terminals for use with debit cards at point of sale; Computer terminals for use with encoded cards at point of sale; Computer terminals for use with magnetic cards at point of sale; Machines for executing remote financial transactions; Electronic funds transfer machines; Apparatus for payment with magnetically encoded cards; Apparatus for payment with magnetically memory cards; Machine readable devices for cashless payment systems; Magnetic payment cards; Payment cards being magnetically encoded; Terminals for electronically processing credit card payments; Terminals for the electronic payment of charges with credit cards
Class 36: Computerised financial services; Computerised transfer of funds; Actuarial services relating to financial transactions; Conducting of financial transactions; Electronic funds transfer services; Monetary exchange; Monetary transaction services; Monetary transfer; Organisation of monetary collections; Providing information, including online, about insurance, financial and monetary affairs and real estate affairs; Collection of fees, payments or tolls (for others); Collection of payments; Electronic payment services; Financial management of reimbursement payments for others; Financial payment services; Payment of bills and accounts for others; Payment processing services; Payment transaction card services; Processing of debit card payments; Processing of payments for banks
Class 42: Electronic monitoring of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Opposition by WISELIST PTY LTD to application under section... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] ATMO 143
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the trade mark "WisePay" had been used in good faith in Australia in relation to the registered goods and services during the three-year period ending one month before the filing of the removal application. The Removal Applicant alleged non-use, placing the onus on the Removal Opponent to rebut this allegation by demonstrating use of the trade mark as a badge of origin, or by establishing circumstances that constituted an obstacle to its use.
The delegate considered evidence of use presented by WISELIST PTY LTD, including screenshots of its website and the WiseList app, which displayed the "WisePay" trade mark. The delegate found that the use of the trade mark on the WiseList website, including variations in its presentation, was sufficient to demonstrate use as a badge of origin, indicating a connection in the course of trade between the services and the owner. This use was considered in light of section 7(1) of the Act, which allows for trade mark use with additions or alterations that do not substantially affect its identity.
The delegate determined that the Removal Opponent had demonstrated use of the trade mark in relation to certain services within the relevant period. Consequently, the delegate exercised discretion not to remove the trade mark registration entirely, ordering instead that the registration be partially removed from the Register, reflecting the scope of use established.
Background
Background to the litigation
WISELIST PTY LTD, represented by Stephen Rebikoff SC, asserts that it is the owner and creator of the WiseList app, developed in 2018, which allows customers to list, compare, and order supermarket products. According to Jinjun Liu, the sole Director of the Removal Opponent, over 180,000 people have downloaded the WiseList app. Liu claims that the Trade Mark, WisePay, was developed in 2019 and has been used in relation to all registered goods and services. He provided evidence such as screenshots of the WiseList website and the WiseList app, displaying the Trade Mark. Liu also asserts that the domain name wiselist.app, which redirects to the WiseList website, was purchased by him on 21 June 2011.
Wise Payments Limited, represented by Andrew Sykes of Counsel, contends that the Removal Opponent did not use the Trade Mark in Australia during the relevant period ending on 13 December 2022. The Removal Applicant filed for removal under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act, which states that a trade mark may be removed if it has remained registered for a continuous period of three years without being used in Australia or used in good faith in Australia in relation to the goods and/or services to which the application relates. The Removal Opponent bears the onus of proving that the Trade Mark was used in good faith or that there were circumstances that were an obstacle to its use during the relevant period.
The delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Timothy Brown, considered the evidence presented and determined that the Removal Opponent had used the Trade Mark in good faith in relation to payment services during the relevant period. However, there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark in relation to the remaining registered goods and services. The delegate did not exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain registered for the unamended goods and services. Consequently, the decision was to amend the trade mark registration to exclude the unamended goods and services, with an effective date one month from the decision date. Timothy Brown declined to award costs to either party as both had a degree of success.
This matter came before the court as an application by Wise Payments Limited for the removal of a trade mark from the Register of Trade Marks, pursuant to section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). WISELIST PTY LTD, the owner of the trade mark in question, opposed the application. The case proceeded through several procedural stages, starting with WISELIST PTY LTD filing a Notice of Intention to Oppose on 14 March 2023, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 4 April 2023. Wise Payments Limited filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 31 May 2023. Both parties submitted evidence in support of their positions, with WISELIST PTY LTD filing its evidence on 12 September 2023, Wise Payments Limited filing its evidence in answer on 5 February 2024, and WISELIST PTY LTD filing evidence in reply on 19 March 2024. Following the submission of evidence, the parties requested to be heard, and the matter was ultimately heard before Timothy Brown, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 22 April 2025. WISELIST PTY LTD was represented by Stephen Rebikoff SC, while Wise Payments Limited was represented by Andrew Sykes of Counsel.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Trade Mark was used by the Removal Opponent in relation to the Registered Goods and Services during the Relevant Period.
2. Whether the domain name and WiseList website evidence sufficiently demonstrate use of the Trade Mark by the Removal Opponent.
3. Whether the evidence of use of the Trade Mark within the WiseList app during the Relevant Period is sufficient to establish use.
4. Whether it is reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain registered for the remaining Registered Goods and Services.
Held
1. Whether the Trade Mark was used by the Removal Opponent in relation to the Registered Goods and Services during the Relevant Period.
- The court concluded that the Removal Opponent used the Trade Mark in relation to payment services in Class 36 during the Relevant Period. However, the court was not satisfied that the Removal Opponent used the Trade Mark in relation to the remainder of the Registered Goods and Services. Result: Partial use established.
2. Whether the domain name and WiseList website evidence sufficiently demonstrate use of the Trade Mark by the Removal Opponent.
- The court found that the use of the Trade Mark on the WiseList website and the domain name, which redirects to the WiseList website, sufficiently demonstrated use of the Trade Mark as a badge of origin for payment services. Result: Evidence deemed sufficient for payment services.
3. Whether the evidence of use of the Trade Mark within the WiseList app during the Relevant Period is sufficient to establish use.
- The court found that the evidence of use of the Trade Mark within the WiseList app did not sufficiently establish use during the Relevant Period because the evidence was undated. Result: Insufficient evidence for the Relevant Period.
4. Whether it is reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain registered for the remaining Registered Goods and Services.
- The court concluded that it was not reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain registered for the remaining Registered Goods and Services. Result: Discretion not exercised.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by considering whether the Trade Mark had been used by the Removal Opponent in relation to the Registered Goods and Services during the Relevant Period. The court noted that the onus was on the Removal Opponent to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark in good faith during this period. The Removal Opponent relied on limited evidence to support their claim of use, including the WiseList website, the Domain Name, and the WiseList app.
In relation to the WiseList website and the Domain Name, the court found that the screenshots provided were sufficient to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark as a badge of origin for payment services. However, the court was not satisfied that this use extended to the remaining Registered Goods and Services. The use of the Domain Name was found to be insufficient to demonstrate use of the Trade Mark, as it did not constitute use of the Trade Mark itself.
Regarding the WiseList app, the court found that the use of the Trade Mark within the app was consistent with use in relation to payment services. However, the evidence did not establish that this use occurred during the Relevant Period.
The court then considered whether it was reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain registered for the remaining Registered Goods and Services. The court found that there was insufficient evidence to support the Removal Opponent’s contention that it had been using the Trade Mark since 2021 in connection with the remaining Registered Goods and Services. The court also found that there was no persuasive evidence of a reputation in the Trade Mark, and that the Removal Applicant had a legitimate interest in the removal of the Trade Mark.
In conclusion, the court found that the Removal Opponent had established its opposition to the removal of the Trade Mark in relation to payment services, but was not satisfied that it was reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion to allow the Trade Mark to remain registered for the remaining Registered Goods and Services. The Trade Mark registration was therefore amended to reflect the services for which use had been demonstrated.