Opals Australia P/L v Opal Australiana P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

196 qv

JUDGMENT No. ........ ........ .. I ........ ....
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
)
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY ) NO. NG 348 of 1993

)

GENERAL DIVISION )
BETWEEN : OPALS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Applicant

AND :  OPAL AUSTRALIANA PTY LIMITED

Respondent

24 March 1994 S

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

LOCKHART J.

This is a motion by the applicant for an order that its

costs be ordered and taxed on an indemnity basis from 30 June

1993, that date being selected because it was the date on which

the solicitors for the applicant wrote a letter of offer to the respondents' solicitors. In substance, the letter stated that if the respondents would consent to the relief sought by the applicant in its application which initiatedthe proceeding, then the applicant would pay its own costs and not expect the respondents to pay its costs.

proceeded to trial. The applicant succeeded at the trial in its in a moment), was not accepted by the respondents and the matter
claim for injunctive relief and the court only granted in~unctions and an order for costs (order No 4 which was made on 3 September 1993), namely, that the first respondent pay the costs of the applicant of the proceeding including any reserved costs.
The motlon that has subsequently been filed by the applicant seeks an order for indemnity costs, as I have mentioned earlier. The basis of the motion is that the letter of offer was made on
30 June last and it is said that the ludgment of the court on 3
September substantially confirmed the orders sought in the initiating application and that in those circumstances there ought to be an order for indemnity costs. The first respondent, who is the only relevant respondent for present purposes because it is the only respondent against whom an order for costs was made on 3 September 1993, opposes the motion on a number of grounds.
First, it is said by counsel for the first respondent that
the relief obtained by the applicant was not all the relief
sought in the initiating application. Indeed, it was argued that
there was a substantial difference between the relief sought and the relief granted. Secondly, it was argued by counsel for the respondent that the offer of 30 June 1993 was made at a stage when the case was still in the course of preparation and that a considerable amount of further evidence later emerged including the oral evidence at the trial.
Third, it was argued that this is not a case where the first respondent behaved so unreasonably as to warrant an order for indemnity costs being made against it. Finally, it was argued on behalf of the first respondent that this court has no jurisdictional power now to make an order of the kind sought in the motion.

In the letter the applicant said that should its offer not be accepted it intended to tender the letter to the court with respect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Opals Australia P/L v Opal Australiana P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] FCA 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Opals Australia P/L and Opal Australiana P/L were involved in a legal dispute regarding injunctive relief and costs. The Federal Court of Australia considered a motion filed by Opals Australia P/L seeking an order for its costs to be taxed on an indemnity basis from 30 June 1993. Opals Australia P/L had written a letter of offer to Opal Australiana P/L's solicitors, stating that if Opal Australiana P/L agreed to the relief sought in the initiating application, Opals Australia P/L would pay its own costs and not expect Opal Australiana P/L to pay its costs. The court needed to determine whether the relief obtained by Opals Australia P/L was substantially the same as that sought in the initiating application and whether Opal Australiana P/L behaved unreasonably in not accepting the offer.

The court found that the relief granted by the court was not substantially the same as that sought in the initiating application. The court had only granted injunctive relief and did not award damages or an account of profits, which were not minor issues in the proceeding. Additionally, the court found that Opal Australiana P/L did not behave unreasonably in not accepting the offer, as the case was still in the course of preparation and much remained to be done to prepare the case for trial. The court also expressed doubt about whether the letter of offer could be properly characterised as an offer in the sense used in cases dealing with indemnity costs orders.

Based on these findings, the court dismissed the motion and ordered Opals Australia P/L to pay the costs of Opal Australiana P/L of the motion. The court found that the circumstances did not warrant an order for indemnity costs and that the ordinary rule that applies in applications for indemnity costs should be followed, which is that costs should be paid and taxed on a party and party basis unless the circumstances of the case warrant departure from that course.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established