One Stop Lighting (Queensland) Pty Ltd & Anor v Lifestyle Property Developments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT  

OF QUEENSLAND  No. 2121 of 1999

Brisbane

[One Stop Lighting (Queensland) Pty Ltd & Anor v Lifestyle Property Developments Pty Ltd]

BETWEEN:

ONE STOP LIGHTING (QUEENSLAND) PTY LTD
ACN 085 321 222

First Plaintiff

AND:

FIRST LIGHTING FLAGSTAFF PTY LTD
ACN 055 761 32062 878 684

Second Plaintiff

AND:

LIFESTYLE PROPERTY DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
ACN 062 878 684

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - CHESTERMAN J

Judgment delivered 24 March 1999

1             By its writ of summons issued on 8 March, 1999 the plaintiffs seek specific performance of an agreement to lease made in January 1999 in respect of premises located at Oslen Avenue in Southport.  The defendant is the developer of a retail shopping centre in which the premises are located.  The second plaintiff carries on business, principally in Victoria, as a retailer and wholesaler of electric light fittings.  The dispute concerns about 745 square metres of lettable space in the development which the first plaintiff alleges it agreed to lease from the defendant for the purpose of selling light fittings to the public.  The defendant denies that it made a binding agreement to lease.  Subject to the outcome of this action the defendant intends to lease the premises to Brightlite Nominees Pty Ltd (“Brightlite”), another retailer of light fittings and a business competitor of the plaintiffs. 

2             The premises are presently vacant.  Upon learning of the defendant’s intention to lease the premises to its rival, the plaintiffs obtained an interlocutory injunction on 5 March, 1999 restraining the defendant from proceeding with the lease to Brightlite or allowing it to go into possession.  That injunction was to expire after seven days.  Upon application to a chamber judge for an extension it was thought preferable to have the action tried urgently because the outcome of the application for the interlocutory injunction might practically have determined the action without the merits being ventilated.  The matter was sent to the civil list for trial and was heard on 15 and 17 March.  The parties require a prompt judgment and I have endeavoured to oblige them.  The need for haste must necessarily mean that my reasons will be abbreviated.

3             The agreement which the plaintiffs allege was made between the first plaintiff and the defendant.  The first plaintiff has not traded and was incorporated for the purpose of commencing retail business in Queensland.  The second plaintiff has traded successfully in Victoria for some years.  The plaintiffs rely upon, as a separate cause of action, representations allegedly made on behalf of the defendant to Messrs Berkovitch and Kupshik, representatives of both plaintiffs.  It is said, of necessity, that the plaintiffs acted to their detriment in reliance on the representations but because it was the second plaintiff, as the established company, which engaged in the conduct said to amount to detriment, it was a necessary party to the proceedings and was joined when the trial commenced.

4             The view I have come to means that the plaintiffs’ case on estoppel can…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read One Stop Lighting (Queensland) Pty Ltd & Anor v Lifestyle Pr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QSC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

One Stop Lighting (Queensland) Pty Ltd & Anor v Lifestyle Property Developments Pty Ltd was an action brought in the Supreme Court of Queensland by the plaintiffs, One Stop Lighting (Queensland) Pty Ltd and First Lighting Flagstaff Pty Ltd, seeking specific performance of an agreement to lease premises in a retail shopping centre in Southport. The defendant, Lifestyle Property Developments Pty Ltd, denied that a binding agreement to lease had been made. The plaintiffs sought an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendant from leasing the premises to another party, Brightlite Nominees Pty Ltd, pending the determination of the action. The court found that the parties had not reached a binding agreement to lease the premises, and therefore dismissed the plaintiffs' claim for specific performance. The court held that the parties had only agreed on major terms and intended to negotiate and finalize further terms in a formal lease agreement. The court also found that the plaintiffs' reliance on estoppel and the Trade Practices Act was misplaced, as the parties had not intended to be bound until a formal lease was signed. Additionally, the court held that the plaintiffs had not provided sufficient evidence of part-performance to overcome the requirement of a written memorandum of the agreement.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiffs' claim for specific performance be dismissed, and the interlocutory injunction be discharged.

Background

Background to the litigation

One Stop Lighting (Queensland) Pty Ltd, along with its principal, First Lighting Flagstaff Pty Ltd, initiated legal proceedings against Lifestyle Property Developments Pty Ltd to enforce a claimed agreement to lease premises located at Oslen Avenue in Southport. The plaintiffs sought specific performance of an alleged agreement to lease made in January 1999 for approximately 745 square meters of lettable space in a retail shopping center being developed by the defendant. The plaintiffs intended to use the premises for selling light fittings to the public. The defendant denied the existence of a binding lease agreement and planned to lease the space to Brightlite Nominees Pty Ltd, a competitor. The plaintiffs obtained an interlocutory injunction preventing the defendant from proceeding with the lease to Brightlite or allowing Brightlite to take possession, which was later extended to allow for an urgent trial. The trial was held on 15 and 17 March 1999.

The plaintiffs filed a writ of summons on 8 March 1999 to seek specific performance of the alleged lease agreement. An interlocutory injunction was granted on 5 March 1999, restraining the defendant from proceeding with the lease to Brightlite or allowing it to take possession. The injunction was initially set to expire after seven days but was extended upon application. The matter was subsequently sent to the civil list for an urgent trial due to the potential determination of the case without ventilating the merits through the interlocutory application. The trial took place over two days, on 15 and 17 March 1999.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the parties made a concluded agreement for the lease of the premises.
2. Whether the conduct of the parties after the alleged agreement supports the existence of a binding contract.
3. Whether the plaintiffs can enforce the claimed agreement to lease despite the absence of a written contract.
4. Whether the acts of part-performance by the plaintiffs can establish the existence of an oral agreement.

Held
1. Whether the parties made a concluded agreement for the lease of the premises. The court concluded that the parties did not make a concluded agreement for the lease of the premises as the parties did not intend to be bound until a formal lease was executed.
2. Whether the conduct of the parties after the alleged agreement supports the existence of a binding contract. The court concluded that the conduct of the parties after the alleged agreement does not support the existence of a binding contract, as the parties intended to be bound only upon the execution of a formal lease.
3. Whether the plaintiffs can enforce the claimed agreement to lease despite the absence of a written contract. The court concluded that the plaintiffs cannot enforce the claimed agreement to lease despite the absence of a written contract, as there was no binding contract in place.
4. Whether the acts of part-performance by the plaintiffs can establish the existence of an oral agreement. The court concluded that the acts of part-performance by the plaintiffs cannot establish the existence of an oral agreement, as the acts did not unequivocally point to the existence of a contract of the type alleged by the plaintiffs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the communications and conduct between the parties to determine if they had reached a concluded agreement for the lease of the premises. The court found that the parties had not reached a final agreement on 29 January, as the defendant's response to the "Intent to Lease" document suggested equivocation or hesitation rather than unconditional acceptance. The court also noted that the subsequent conduct of the parties, including the exchange of a draft lease and the defendant's insistence on a director's guarantee, indicated that the parties did not intend to be bound until a formal lease was executed. The court relied on Masters v. Cameron to conclude that the case fell into the third category, where the intention of the parties is not to make a concluded bargain unless and until they execute a formal contract.

The court rejected the plaintiffs' argument that the conduct of the parties after the alleged agreement supported the existence of a binding contract, as the parties had clearly indicated that they would not be bound until a lease was signed. The court also dismissed the plaintiffs' estoppel claim, as they could not rely on a representation that there was a binding agreement when they knew that the defendant was not bound until a lease was signed.

Regarding the enforceability of the claimed agreement despite the absence of a written contract, the court concluded that the plaintiffs could not enforce the agreement, as there was no binding contract in place. The court found that the documents provided by the parties did not contain all the terms of a concluded contract, and therefore, did not satisfy the requirement of a sufficient memorandum under the Property Law Act 1974.

Lastly, the court found that the acts of part-performance by the plaintiffs did not establish the existence of an oral agreement, as the acts did not unequivocally point to the existence of a contract of the type alleged by the plaintiffs. The court relied on the principles established in Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v. Maher and ANZ Banking Group Ltd v. Widin to conclude that the acts of part-performance were not consistent with the existence of a contract between the parties.