Oldfield & Anor v. Gold Coast City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Oldfield & Anor v Gold Coast City Council [2008] QSC 226

PARTIES:

DEBRA OLDFIELD as representative of the Lot Owners of Western Bay CTS Body Corporate 30080
(first plaintiff)
WESTERN BAY CTS BODY CORPORATE 30080
(second plaintiff)  v
GOLD COAST CITY COUNCIL
(defendant)

FILE NO:

BS1581 of 2007

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

25 September 2008

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27-29 May and 4 June 2008

JUDGE:

Mullins J

ORDER:

The proceeding is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY - EASEMENTS – EASEMENTS GENERALLY - RIGHTS OF WAY – ABANDONMENT, SUSPENSION, EXTINGUISHMENT OR MODIFICATION – EXTINGUISHMENT – STATUTORY – where easement in gross granted in favour of local government by developer of residential estate for pedestrian access over walkway between houses and lake – where local government permitted by easement to authorise members of the public to enjoy rights conferred by easement – where rights mainly exercised by residents of the residential estate other than the owners of the servient tenements – where application made by owners of the servient tenements to extinguish easement under ss 181 (1) (b) and (d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q) – where servient tenements able to be used for residential purposes despite breaches of the easement – where owners of the servient tenements unable to show that easement impeded some reasonable user of the servient tenements – where members of the public authorised to exercise access rights are persons entitled to the benefit of the easement – where owners of the servient tenements unable to show that extinguishment would not substantially injure persons entitled to the easement

Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997, s 18
Land Titles Act
1994, s 81A, s 89
Property Law Act 1974, s 181

Averono v Mbuzi [2005] QCA 295, considered
Averono v Mbuzi [2005] QSC 6, considered
Cavacourt Pty Ltd v Durian (Holdings) Pty Ltd [1998] NSWSC 787, considered
Re Eddowes [1991] 2 Qd R 381, considered
Eucalypt Group Pty Ltd v Robin [2003] 2 Qd R 488, considered
Guth v Robinson (1977) 1 BPR 9209, considered
Kort Pty Ltd v Shaw [1983] WAR 113, considered
Ex parte Melvin [1980] Qd R 391, followed
Re Rollwell Australia Pty Ltd (1999) Q ConvR 54-521, followed
Smyth v Brisbane City Council [2007] QSC 30, considered
Wallace v Goodwin [2004] QSC 42, considered

COUNSEL:

JA Griffin QC (4 June 2008 only) and RJ Clutterbuck for the plaintiffs
DJ Campbell SC and HGS Trotter for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

PCF Law for the plaintiffs
Minter Ellison – Gold Coast for the defendant

  1. : MULLINS JCoomera Waters Estate is a residential resort style estate that has been developed in stages around a man-made lake based on the Coomera River. This proceeding concerns stage 4 of the estate which is known as Western Bay and was one of the early stages of the development. The plaintiffs seek extinguishment of registered easements numbered 705416571 (easement BJ on SP 143451) and 705772957…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oldfield & Anor v. Gold Coast City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Oldfield & Anor v. Gold Coast City Council was heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland and involved a dispute over the extinguishment of a pedestrian easement granted over land owned by the plaintiffs, Oldfield and another. The easement, which was initially created in favor of the Gold Coast City Council, allowed for public access over a walkway between residential properties and a nearby lake. The plaintiffs sought to extinguish the easement on the grounds that it was no longer necessary and that its continuation would cause them inconvenience. The defendants, including the Gold Coast City Council, argued that the easement was still necessary for public access and that its extinguishment would harm the public interest.

The central legal issues in the case were whether the easement could be extinguished under section 181(1)(b) and (d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q), which allows for the extinguishment of easements if they are no longer necessary or if their extinguishment would not substantially injure persons entitled to the benefit of the easement. The court had to consider whether the easement was indeed no longer necessary and whether its extinguishment would substantially injure those who were entitled to use it, namely, the public and the residents of the adjoining properties.

The court found that the easement was still necessary as it provided public access to the lake, a benefit that was being enjoyed by the public and the residents of the adjoining properties. The court further determined that the plaintiffs could not demonstrate that the easement impeded a reasonable use of their land, nor could they prove that the extinguishment would not substantially injure those entitled to the easement. Consequently, the court ruled that the easement could not be extinguished under the statutory provisions, and dismissed the plaintiffs' application.

Orders

Orders of the court

The proceeding is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns an easement in gross that was granted in favour of the Gold Coast City Council (the respondent) by a developer of a residential estate. This easement was established for pedestrian access over a walkway between the houses and a nearby lake. The easement allowed the Council to authorise members of the public to enjoy the rights conferred by the easement. However, the rights were predominantly exercised by the residents of the residential estate, rather than the general public. The owners of the servient tenements (the applicants) sought to extinguish the easement under sections 181(1)(b) and (d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q). They argued that the easement impeded some reasonable use of the servient tenements and that its extinguishment would not substantially injure persons entitled to the benefit of the easement. The servient tenements remained usable for residential purposes despite any breaches of the easement. The applicants could not demonstrate that the easement impeded a reasonable use of their property nor could they prove that extinguishment would not substantially injure those entitled to the easement.

The matter came before the court as an application by the applicants, the owners of the servient tenements, to extinguish an easement in gross granted to the Gold Coast City Council. The application was made under sections 181(1)(b) and (d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q). The case involved the interpretation of the easement and the determination of whether the applicants had satisfied the statutory criteria for extinguishing the easement. The court considered evidence and submissions from both parties regarding the impact of the easement on the servient tenements and the rights of the public to enjoy the easement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the easement impeded some reasonable use of the servient tenements as required by s 181(1)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q).
2. Whether the extinguishment of the easement would not substantially injure persons entitled to the benefit of the easement as required by s 181(1)(d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q).

Held
1. The court concluded that the easement did not impede some reasonable use of the servient tenements as required by s 181(1)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q). The application to extinguish the easement was dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the extinguishment of the easement would not substantially injure persons entitled to the benefit of the easement as required by s 181(1)(d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q). The application to extinguish the easement was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the easement impeded some reasonable use of the servient tenements, as required by s 181(1)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q). It was noted that the easement primarily benefited the residents of the residential estate, who were not the owners of the servient tenements. Despite some breaches of the easement, the owners of the servient tenements were still able to use their land for residential purposes. The court held that the servient tenement owners had not demonstrated that the easement impeded some reasonable use of their property, and thus, the application to extinguish the easement failed under s 181(1)(b).

Next, the court considered whether the extinguishment of the easement would substantially injure persons entitled to the benefit of the easement as required by s 181(1)(d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q). The court found that the easement allowed the local government to authorise members of the public to enjoy rights conferred by the easement. Therefore, these members of the public were persons entitled to the benefit of the easement. The servient tenement owners were unable to show that extinguishing the easement would substantially injure these persons. As a result, the application to extinguish the easement also failed under s 181(1)(d).

The court did not depart from any established authority in making its decision. The reasoning relied on the plain language of ss 181(1)(b) and (d) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Q) and the facts of the case. The ratio decidendi is that an easement will not be extinguished if the servient tenement owners cannot show that the easement impedes some reasonable use of the servient tenements or that extinguishment would substantially injure persons entitled to the benefit of the easement.