OCCUPANT RT391 v GRANTOR RT391 (No. 2) (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

OCCUPANT RT391 v GRANTOR RT391 (No. 2) (Residential Tenancies) [2020] ACAT 59

RT 391/2020

Catchwords:               RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – whether agreement is an occupancy agreement or a residential tenancy agreement – examination of terms of the agreement – lessor is a community housing provider – lessor does not provide care to residents – agreement is a residential tenancy agreement – notice to vacate invalid

Legislation cited:        Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 6A, 6E, 71C

Cases cited:Georgiadis v Canberra Institute of Technology [2020] ACAT 38

Noble v Centacare [2003] ACTSC 37
Wiser v Havelock Housing Association Incorporated [2014] ACTSC 138
Young Women’s Christian Association of Canberra v Carne [2017] ACAT 15

Tribunal:  Senior Member H Robinson

Date of Orders:  22 June 2020

Date of Reasons for Decision:         10 August 2020

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL           RT 391/2020

BETWEEN:

OCCUPANT RT391

Applicant

AND:

GRANTOR RT391

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:     Senior Member H Robinson

DATE:22 June 2020

ORDER

The Tribunal being satisfied that the relationship between the applicant and the respondent is one of tenant and lessor, the Tribunal orders that:

  1. The respondent is restrained from terminating the residential tenancy agreement other than in accordance with the Residential Tenancy Act 1997 provisions relating to residential tenancies.

……………Signed………..

Senior Member H Robinson

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 22 June 2020 the Tribunal heard arguments in relation to the preliminary question of whether the arrangement in this matter constituted an occupancy agreement or a residential tenancy agreement.  I gave my reasons orally. What follows is an edited copy of those reasons.

Background

  1. A brief background to this matter is set out in the decision of Senior Member Katavic in Occupant RT391 v Grantor RT391 [2020] ACAT 43 at paragraphs [4] to [9] (the previous decision )

  2. In summary, the applicant and the respondent are parties to a so-called ‘occupancy agreement’. Pursuant to that agreement, the respondent served upon the applicant a Notice to Vacate (NTV) dated 11 May 2020. The applicant seeks, amongst other things, an order preventing the respondent from evicting him.

  3. In the previous decision matter, Senior Member Katavic stayed the eviction pending a final hearing. At the time of that decision the parties proceeded on the basis that the relationship between the parties was one of occupant and grantor. The applicant now contends that the arrangement constitutes a residential tenancy agreement. If the applicant is correct, the NTV would be invalid as it is inconsistent with the permissible grounds for termination of a residential tenancy agreement set out in schedule 1 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (RT Act).

  4. The issue of characterisation is fundamental to the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in this matter, to the powers it may exercise and to the lawfulness of the eviction process implemented by the respondent. It is therefore appropriate that I determine it on a preliminary basis without considering the other issues before the Tribunal.

Agreed facts

  1. The parties have agreed on a set of facts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read OCCUPANT RT391 v GRANTOR RT391 (No. 2) (Residential Tenancie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACAT 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Tribunal concerns an application by an occupant of a house leased by the respondent from the ACT Government, to have a Notice to Vacate issued by the respondent declared invalid. The applicant claims that the agreement between the parties amounts to a residential tenancy agreement and that the Notice to Vacate is therefore invalid. The Tribunal must determine whether the agreement between the applicant and the respondent is an occupancy agreement or a residential tenancy agreement. This determination is fundamental to the Tribunal's jurisdiction, the powers it may exercise, and the lawfulness of the eviction process implemented by the respondent.

The primary issue is whether the agreement between the parties is an occupancy agreement or a residential tenancy agreement. The applicant argues that the agreement is a residential tenancy agreement and, as such, the Notice to Vacate is invalid because it does not comply with the permissible grounds for termination of a residential tenancy agreement set out in the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. The respondent contends that the agreement is an occupancy agreement, and the Notice to Vacate is therefore valid. The Tribunal must examine the terms of the agreement and the nature of the relationship between the parties to determine whether it is a residential tenancy agreement or an occupancy agreement.

In determining the nature of the agreement, the Tribunal considered the terms of the agreement and the nature of the relationship between the parties. The Tribunal found that the agreement gives the applicant a right to occupy the premises as defined, and the parties agree that this right amounts to an exclusive possession of the bedroom and shared use of the common living areas. The Tribunal also noted that all the residents require a very high level of personal care and support, including all aspects of daily activity and living, which are coordinated by a disability care provider contracted directly by the applicant and the other residents and funded by the NDIS. The Tribunal held that the respondent does not supply any services to the applicant or other residents other than acting as lessor of the property and does not get involved in operational matters within the house. The Tribunal concluded that the relationship between the applicant and the respondent is one of tenant and lessor, and the agreement is a residential tenancy agreement.

The Tribunal orders that the respondent is restrained from terminating the residential tenancy agreement other than in accordance with the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 provisions relating to residential tenancies. The Tribunal's decision highlights the importance of determining the nature of the agreement between the parties in residential tenancy disputes and the need to examine the terms of the agreement and the nature of the relationship between the parties to make an informed decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal being satisfied that the relationship between the applicant and the respondent is one of tenant and lessor, the Tribunal orders that:

1.

The respondent is restrained from terminating the residential tenancy agreement other than in accordance with the Residential Tenancy Act 1997 provisions relating to residential tenancies.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

A brief background to this matter is set out in the decision of Senior Member Katavic in Occupant RT391 v Grantor RT391 [2020] ACAT 43 at paragraphs [4] to [9] (the previous decision ) In summary, the applicant and the respondent are parties to a so-called ‘occupancy agreement’. Pursuant to that agreement, the respondent served upon the applicant a Notice to Vacate (NTV) dated 11 May 2020. The applicant seeks, amongst other things, an order preventing the respondent from evicting him. In the previous decision matter, Senior Member Katavic stayed the eviction pending a final hearing. At the time of that decision the parties proceeded on the basis that the relationship between the parties was one of occupant and grantor. The applicant now contends that the arrangement constitutes a residential tenancy agreement. If the applicant is correct, the NTV would be invalid as it is inconsistent with the permissible grounds for termination of a residential tenancy agreement set out in schedule 1 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (RT Act). The issue of characterisation is fundamental to the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in this matter, to the powers it may exercise and to the lawfulness of the eviction process implemented by the respondent. It is therefore appropriate that I determine it on a preliminary basis without considering the other issues before the Tribunal. The parties have agreed on a set of facts that relate to the nature of the agreement between the parties. They are:(a)the applicant is a severely disabled individual who requires full-time care and support;(b)at present the applicant and another individual are co-residents in a suburban house that the respondent leases from the ACT Government under a services agreement;(c)the applicant has a dedicated bedroom in that house. The applicant has resided in the house for some nine years and his co-resident for thirty; (d)the house was previously managed by the ACT Government, who oversaw it as a disability group house, providing both accommodation and services to the residents, but it was transferred to the respondent organisation following the introduction of the NDIS;(e)there is a written agreement between the parties entitled, ‘Occupancy agreement’. It was signed by the applicant’s guardians and the respondent on 20 March 2017;(f)the agreement gives the applicant a right to occupy the premises as defined;(g)the parties agree that this right amounts to an exclusive possession of the bedroom and shared use of the common living areas; (h)all the residents are severely disabled, and all require a very high level of personal care and support, including all aspects of daily activity and living, including meal planning and preparation, bathing, cleaning and assistance with stimulation and outings. All these services are coordinated by a disability care provider (care provider) contracted directly by the applicant and the other residents and funded by the NDIS;(i)a representative of the care provider stays at the residence at all times, and they sleep in the spare bedroom; (j)the respondent does not supply any services to the applicant or other residents other than acting as lessor of the property;(k)the respondent does not generally get involved in operational matters within the house;(l)the applicant and the residents pay for utilities, including gas, electricity and water;(m)the respondent does not enter the house other than in accordance with the notice provisions set out in the agreement or to conduct urgent repairs; and (n)the keys are held by the resident’s guardians and by the service providers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established