Oberoi v ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



OBEROI v ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2015] ACAT 65

AT 14/97

Catchwords:              ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – planning –heritage guidelines – site coverage – impact on heritage values – garden setting – extension to home to accommodate needs of family – human rights to be taken into consideration – whether alternative building plans are realistic – conditions on landscaping to lessen impact on heritage values

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 68
Heritage Act 2004 ss 27, 59, 60, 61
Human Rights Act 2004 ss 30, 40, 40B
Planning and Development Act 2007 ss 48, 50, 113, 119, 120, 162, 193, 407, sch 1

Subordinate
Legislation:               Blandfordia 5 Garden City Heritage Precinct Guidelines

Cases cited:Baptist Community Church v ACT Land and Planning Authority & Ors [2015] ACTCA 3

Bat Advocacy NSW Inc v Minister for Environmental Protection, Heritage and the Arts [2011] FCAFC 59

Castles v Secretary to the Department of Justice & Ors [2010]   VSC 310

Guttav ACT Planning and Land Authority [2013] ACAT 63

Smith v Hobsons Bay City Council [2010] VCAT 668

Thomson v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2009] ACAT 38

Tribunal:                   Ms M-T. Daniel – Member (Presiding)
  Mr R. Pegrum – Senior Member

Date of Orders:  25 September 2015

Date of Reasons for Decision:      25 September 2015

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL           AT 14/97

BETWEEN:

SABEENA OBEROI

Applicant

AND:

ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Ms M-T. Daniel – Member (Presiding)

Mr R. Pegrum – Senior Member

DATE:25 September 2015

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision under review is varied to approve development application No. 201425272 subject to compliance with the conditions set out in these orders.

CONDITIONS

  1. Within 28 days from the date of this decision, or within such further time as may be approved by the ACT Planning and Land Authority, the applicant/lessee shall lodge with the Authority for approval:

    a) a plan prepared by a qualified landscape architect showing the proposed landscape design for the area between the house and the front property line, and for other areas of the site visible from the street.  The design must be to provide the garden setting contemplated in the Heritage Guidelines.  The plan must show existing and new plantings of shrubs and suitably advanced trees (indicating types and sizes), new or changed paths and paving, and the extent of areas for car standing and manoeuvring.  Accompanying diagrams or calculations must show that the area available for landscape planting occupies not less than 40% of the area of the subject site;

    b) a detailed plan showing that the proposed extension projects no further to the south from the existing house than the southern wall of the existing master bedroom and including dimensions provided by the surveyor for the distance of the proposed extension to the nearest points on the south boundary of the site; and

    c) drawings of amended elevations and cross sections showing that the new bedroom wing will have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oberoi v ACT Planning and Land Authority (Administrative Rev... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACAT 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Oberoi v ACT Planning and Land Authority, the applicant, Ms Oberoi, sought approval for an extension to her home to accommodate the needs of her family, including her elderly relatives. The ACT Planning and Land Authority had previously refused the development application on the grounds that it would breach the Heritage Guidelines for the Blandfordia 5 Housing Precinct. Ms Oberoi challenged the decision and sought reconsideration, which was also refused. She then sought judicial review of the reconsideration decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether the refusal of the development application was lawful, taking into account the Heritage Guidelines, the impact on the heritage values of the precinct, and the applicant's human rights. The AAT examined the evidence and submissions provided by both parties, including the advice from the ACT Heritage Council and the Conservator of Flora and Fauna. The Tribunal considered whether the proposed development would exceed the allowable site coverage and reduce the planting area on the site, and whether these breaches would have a detrimental impact on the heritage values of the precinct. The AAT also examined whether the refusal of the development application would contravene the Human Rights Act 2004.

The AAT found that the proposed development would exceed the allowable site coverage and reduce the planting area on the site, which would have a detrimental impact on the heritage values of the precinct. The Tribunal held that the Heritage Guidelines were intended to maintain generous garden settings for each dwelling in the precinct and that the proposed development would further compromise the ability to provide such a setting. The AAT also found that the refusal of the development application would not contravene the Human Rights Act 2004, as the applicant's circumstances could not be considered exceptional and there were other options to accommodate her family within the existing space. However, the AAT varied the original decision and approved the development application subject to compliance with certain conditions, including the submission of a landscape design plan, a detailed plan showing the proposed extension, and drawings of amended elevations and cross sections.

In conclusion, the AAT found that the refusal of the development application was not lawful and varied the original decision to approve the development application subject to compliance with the conditions set out in the orders. The Tribunal held that the proposed development would have a detrimental impact on the heritage values of the precinct, but that the applicant's human rights were not contravened. The AAT's decision provides guidance on the application of the Heritage Guidelines and the balance between individual rights and the protection of public interest.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision under review is varied to approve development application No. 201425272 subject to compliance with the conditions set out in these orders.

CONDITIONS

2.

Within 28 days from the date of this decision, or within such further time as may be approved by the ACT Planning and Land Authority, the applicant/lessee shall lodge with the Authority for approval:

a) a plan prepared by a qualified landscape architect showing the proposed landscape design for the area between the house and the front property line, and for other areas of the site visible from the street. The design must be to provide the garden setting contemplated in the Heritage Guidelines. The plan must show existing and new plantings of shrubs and suitably advanced trees (indicating types and sizes), new or changed paths and paving, and the extent of areas for car standing and manoeuvring. Accompanying diagrams or calculations must show that the area available for landscape planting occupies not less than 40% of the area of the subject site;

b) a detailed plan showing that the proposed extension projects no further to the south from the existing house than the southern wall of the existing master bedroom and including dimensions provided by the surveyor for the distance of the proposed extension to the nearest points on the south boundary of the site; and

c) drawings of amended elevations and cross sections showing that the new bedroom wing will have an eaves projection on three sides that matches the existing eaves projection.

3.

All building and landscaping work must be undertaken in accordance with the approved plans and drawings submitted for Condition 2 above.

4.

No services are to be dug within the tree protection zone of the regulated elm next door (opposite the main bedroom).

5.

The building work must not proceed beyond floor level until submission of written certification from a licensed surveyor to the ACT Planning and Land Authority that the new work is wholly within the boundary clearances mentioned in Condition 2(b) above.

6.

The landscaping work must be completed before, or within 3 months after, the issue of a certificate of occupancy.

Background

Background to the litigation

Background Facts1.1 The original cottage and current house The house on the subject site is only partly original. There was a Federal Capital Commission cottage built c. 1927, which was the subject of brick additions by previous owners in 1968 and more substantial architect-designed renovations by the current owners in around 1998. It was the evidence of the applicant that the 1998 renovations were carried out with a view to meeting the family’s anticipated needs but also to be consistent with the heritage characteristics of the precinct. The 1998 renovations resulted in a house roughly double the size of the original cottage, and a site coverage or plot ratio of just over 37%[1]. At that time the Heritage Guidelines for the precinct allowed a maximum 35% site coverage, nonetheless the development application for those renovations was approved at the relevant time.[1] Statement of Ms Jamaly dated 2 February 2015, paragraph 9 The residence as a result of the 1998 renovations now has five bedrooms, a bathroom shared between bedrooms two and three, a further three ensuite bathrooms of varying sizes, a guest powder room, a study, kitchen, separate kitchenette, library and three distinct living areas (family, dining and sun rooms). 1.2 Development Application of March 2014 The development application the subject of these proceedings, DA 201425272 (the DA), was submitted by Architects Ring & Associates on behalf of Ms Oberoi on 21 March 2014. The DA sought approval of the “demolition and construction of specific internal walls of residence [and] construction of extension to the southern side of the house.”[2] [2] T-Documents page 265 The DA proposed to project part of the existing exterior wall of bedroom 3 and the adjacent shared bathroom (a combined length of about 5.37 metres on the southern side of the house) towards the southern side boundary by approximately 4.8 metres. This larger space would be reconfigured internally to create a sixth bedroom with an accessible ensuite bathroom and a separate ensuite bathroom to the existing bedroom two. The house as a result of the proposed development would therefore have six bedrooms and five ensuite bathrooms. The other internal aspects of the house would remain unaffected. The proposed extension would provide additional floor area of 28.5 square metres. The existing gross floor area (GFA) was calculated at 393.2 square metres. The evidence on behalf of the Authority in this matter, which was preferred on this point, put the measurements slightly differently at a total GFA of 424.4 square metres[3]. The subject site has an area of 1068 square metres[4]. The DA if approved would result in a plot ratio of 39.73%. [3] This included a small garden shed of 3m2 as a part of site coverage[4] Statement of Ms Jamaly, table B1.3 The Original Decision by the Authority The DA was assessed in the merit track under section 113(2) of the Planning Act. The Authority sought and obtained entity advice from the ACT Heritage Council (Heritage Council) and the Conservator of Flora and Fauna (Conservator). Public notification commenced on 17 April 2014 and ended on 5 May 2014. No written responses were received during the public notification period.[5][5] T-Documents page 241

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 11 June 2014 the delegate of the Authority refused the proposal (the original decision). The Notice of Decision included Reasons for the Decision as follows: The Development Application (DA) has been refused because it did not comply with the legislated requirements for merit track applications pursuant to section 119 of the Act. Consistent with Rule 44 of the Single Dwelling Housing Development Code of the Territory Plan, the DA was referred to the ACT Heritage Council (Council). The development proposal was not supported by the Council for the following reasons: The development proposal is inconsistent with the mandatory requirements 2.1d and 2.1f of the Heritage Guidelines for the Blandfordia 5 Housing Precinct (Heritage Guidelines).Clause 2.1d of the Heritage Guidelines states: Site coverage of built development (including the area of any dwelling, garage, carport, outbuilding or other roofed area but excluding driveways and unroofed paved areas) on a residential or commercial block with an area less than or equal to 1600m2 shall not exceed 27.5% of the area of the block.The development proposal would substantially exceed the maximum site coverage of 27.5%.Clause 2.1f of the Heritage Guidelines states: Not less than 40% of the area of a residential block shall be retained as planting area. Planting area means an area of land within a block that is not covered by buildings, vehicle parking and manoeuvring areas of (sic) any other form of impermeable surface and that is available for landscape planting.The proposed development would not comply with the planting area requirement of no less than 40% of block area. The ACT Heritage Council concluded that the proposed development will have a detrimental impact upon the heritage values of the place. The planning and land authority considered the proposal against the Heritage Guidelines including the importance of protecting the Heritage character of this area. Consequently the planning authority agreed with the Council’s conclusion & pursuant to section 119(2) of the Act the DA has been refused. [6] The Notice of Decision went on to quote the advice provided to the Authority by the Heritage Council on 6 May 2014 which was as follows:The proposed development will have a detrimental impact upon the heritage values of the place on the basis of the attached heritage assessment, and to prevent such impact would require change to the fundamental nature or concept of the development.…While the Council sympathises with the lessee in their endeavours to assist their relatives, the existing development has substantial breaches of mandatory requirements that are intended to maintain generous garden settings for each dwelling in the precinct and the Council cannot support additional encroachments into the potential or existing garden area.[7] On 6 August 2014 Ms Oberoi sought reconsideration of the original decision. On 7 October 2014 the Chief Planning Executive of the Authority confirmed the original decision (the reconsideration decision). The notice of decision on reconsideration gave the following reasons for the decision[8]: [8] T-Documents page 62The applicant contends there are exceptional circumstances surrounding the application that require the further addition to the existing dwelling. Given the sensitive nature of the proposal and the issues surrounding it, the application for reconsideration was referred to the Executive Policy Committee (EPC) for consideration.The committee discussed the Human Rights issue as raised by the applicant. The applicant states that her situation is unique because of her cultural background where it is one’s duty to care for the elderly and adult children stay at home until they are married. The applicant contends the refusal of DA201425272 is a violation of Section 27 – Rights of Minorities of the Human Rights Act 2004. It is recognised that such rights may be limited as to achieve a balance between individual rights and the protection of public interest, pursuant to Section 28 of the Human Rights Act 2004.The application was accompanied by evidence such as medical certificates and an occupational therapist’s home assessment to support the application and confirms that the proposal is the only option to accommodate elderly sick relatives in the house. The evidence provided substantiates the need for the proposed house extensions. However it is considered that a decision to refuse the proposed development would not contravene the Human Rights Act 2004.The [executive policy] committee discussed whether the applicant’s circumstances could be considered exceptional and whether all other options to accommodate the family within the existing space had been considered. There were further discussions on the potential impact including possible precedent an approval of the application would have on the Blandfordia 5 Housing Precinct. The EPC concluded a precedent to further depart from the heritage site coverage requirement should not be set and therefore the original decision to refuse the development application should be confirmed.…On 8 September 2014 advice was received from the ACT Heritage Council in relation to the proposal. The advice states: The proposed development will have a detrimental impact [original emphasis] upon the heritage values of the place on the basis of the attached heritage assessment and to prevent such impact would require change to the fundamental nature or concept of the development. …the applicant states that the current site coverage was approved by the Council. This was approved before the current Heritage Guidelines for the Blandfordia 5 Housing Precinct and consequently met the Guidelines that were applicable at that time. The Council does not expect that the applicant should reduce their site coverage to the current maximum of 27.5%, but will object to any additional site coverage that further breaches the current Heritage Guidelines. The Council notes that the proposed additional development will further compromise the ability to provide a generous garden setting for the development on the site, which is the underlying objective for mandatory requirement 2.1d. This is due to the proposed development encroaching on the area that remains where trees and shrubs can be planted to provide a garden setting.The existing development on the site also results in less than 40% of the block being retained as planting area, breaching mandatory requirement 2.1f of the Guidelines. The proposed addition will further reduce opportunities for planting on the block as areas currently paved will be less likely to be converted to planting area…The Council does not consider… concrete pavers or red granite to be an area that is available for landscape planting. Consequently, areas covered by concrete pavers and red granite cannot be included in the planting area.The applicant has noted that recent development has been undertaken on Block 7 Section 13 Griffith that exceeds the allowable site coverage. The Council has not supported any development on that block that exceeds the allowable site coverage.The combination of the excessive site coverage and inadequate planting area does not meet objective 2.1 of the Guidelines “To conserve and reinstate the historical arrangement of dwellings across the precinct and the provision of a generous garden setting for each dwelling”. The existing development on the site is already a substantial breach of the allowable site coverage and the Council does not believe it is appropriate to allow additional encroachments into the garden setting.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 6 August 2014 Ms Oberoi sought reconsideration of the original decision. On 7 October 2014 the Chief Planning Executive of the Authority confirmed the original decision (the reconsideration decision). The notice of decision on reconsideration gave the following reasons for the decision[8]: [8] T-Documents page 62The applicant contends there are exceptional circumstances surrounding the application that require the further addition to the existing dwelling. Given the sensitive nature of the proposal and the issues surrounding it, the application for reconsideration was referred to the Executive Policy Committee (EPC) for consideration.The committee discussed the Human Rights issue as raised by the applicant. The applicant states that her situation is unique because of her cultural background where it is one’s duty to care for the elderly and adult children stay at home until they are married. The applicant contends the refusal of DA201425272 is a violation of Section 27 – Rights of Minorities of the Human Rights Act 2004. It is recognised that such rights may be limited as to achieve a balance between individual rights and the protection of public interest, pursuant to Section 28 of the Human Rights Act 2004.The application was accompanied by evidence such as medical certificates and an occupational therapist’s home assessment to support the application and confirms that the proposal is the only option to accommodate elderly sick relatives in the house. The evidence provided substantiates the need for the proposed house extensions. However it is considered that a decision to refuse the proposed development would not contravene the Human Rights Act 2004.The [executive policy] committee discussed whether the applicant’s circumstances could be considered exceptional and whether all other options to accommodate the family within the existing space had been considered. There were further discussions on the potential impact including possible precedent an approval of the application would have on the Blandfordia 5 Housing Precinct. The EPC concluded a precedent to further depart from the heritage site coverage requirement should not be set and therefore the original decision to refuse the development application should be confirmed.…On 8 September 2014 advice was received from the ACT Heritage Council in relation to the proposal. The advice states: The proposed development will have a detrimental impact [original emphasis] upon the heritage values of the place on the basis of the attached heritage assessment and to prevent such impact would require change to the fundamental nature or concept of the development. …the applicant states that the current site coverage was approved by the Council. This was approved before the current Heritage Guidelines for the Blandfordia 5 Housing Precinct and consequently met the Guidelines that were applicable at that time. The Council does not expect that the applicant should reduce their site coverage to the current maximum of 27.5%, but will object to any additional site coverage that further breaches the current Heritage Guidelines. The Council notes that the proposed additional development will further compromise the ability to provide a generous garden setting for the development on the site, which is the underlying objective for mandatory requirement 2.1d. This is due to the proposed development encroaching on the area that remains where trees and shrubs can be planted to provide a garden setting.The existing development on the site also results in less than 40% of the block being retained as planting area, breaching mandatory requirement 2.1f of the Guidelines. The proposed addition will further reduce opportunities for planting on the block as areas currently paved will be less likely to be converted to planting area…The Council does not consider… concrete pavers or red granite to be an area that is available for landscape planting. Consequently, areas covered by concrete pavers and red granite cannot be included in the planting area.The applicant has noted that recent development has been undertaken on Block 7 Section 13 Griffith that exceeds the allowable site coverage. The Council has not supported any development on that block that exceeds the allowable site coverage.The combination of the excessive site coverage and inadequate planting area does not meet objective 2.1 of the Guidelines “To conserve and reinstate the historical arrangement of dwellings across the precinct and the provision of a generous garden setting for each dwelling”. The existing development on the site is already a substantial breach of the allowable site coverage and the Council does not believe it is appropriate to allow additional encroachments into the garden setting.