Oates v. Cootes Tanker Service Pty Ltd & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

[2005] QSC 213

FRYBERG J

No BS8241 of 2003

BRETT ANDREW OATES Plaintiff

and

COOTES TANKER SERVICE PTY LTD

and

THE SHELL COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED

First Defendant

Second Defendant  

BRISBANE

..DATE 27/07/2005

RULING

HIS HONOUR:  In this matter counsel for the defendants has

objected to the tender of oral evidence by Dr McKay, the

plaintiff's general practitioner.

The plaintiff is suing for damages for back injuries with

psychiatric sequelae sustained, allegedly, in late 2001.  So

far the evidence has disclosed that a few days after he had

the fall which he alleges caused the injuries, his back was

operated on by Dr Campbell and apparently that operation was

successful.  The plaintiff now complains, not only of pain from the region  of that operation, but also of pain from a much higher part of his back.  It is unclear from the plaintiff's case at this point whether he asserts a definite orthopaedic injury in respect of that second source of pain or a psychiatric disability with that part of the back as a focal point.  It is, however, clear that the plaintiff now asserts that he suffers severe pain from his back, including the higher part of his back, and that the nature of the pain is severely disabling and that it has been so for at least two years.

The evidence called on the part of the plaintiff from medical

practitioners relates to medical practitioners who examined

him in periods leading up to 2003, at least in the main.  No

particular attention has been focused by any medical

practitioner on the plaintiff's condition in 2004 and,

(perhaps a little surprisingly) none has been focused on his

present condition.  He does not appear - I should add that his evidence is not yet complete - to be intending to lead evidence of up-to-date medical examinations showing his current position.  Presumably he intends to rely on some sort of presumption of continuity, reinforced by his own evidence as to the actual continuity of his condition for the last two or three years.

Among the doctors to be called on his behalf is Dr McKay.

Dr McKay is his general practitioner and has provided three

reports regarding the plaintiff, the most recent of which was

in early 2004.  If the pattern followed by other witnesses

were to be followed with Dr McKay his evidence in chief would be limited to those reports.  However, the plaintiff now wants to lead oral evidence from Dr McKay relating to his visits to the doctor in and around September 2004 and since that time and of the doctor's opinion of his condition and treatment at and since that time.

Objection has been taken by the defence to that evidence.  It

is accepted that no report has been prepared and that the

evidence does not exist in written form.  The reason advanced

by the plaintiff for the absence of any report on this matter

is that the plaintiff did not intend…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oates v. Cootes Tanker Service Pty Ltd & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QSC 213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of Queensland heard a case involving Brett Andrew Oates, who was suing Cootes Tanker Service Pty Ltd and The Shell Company of Australia Limited for damages related to back injuries and psychiatric sequelae. The defendants objected to the tender of oral evidence from Dr McKay, the plaintiff's general practitioner, regarding visits in and around September 2004 and subsequent treatment. The defendants argued that the plaintiff should not be allowed to introduce this evidence, which was not in written form, as it contravened the rules of court.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff could introduce oral evidence from Dr McKay that was not documented in a report, and if so, whether such evidence could be admitted under the rules of court. The court had to decide whether the absence of a written report constituted a breach of the rules, and if not, whether special leave was required for the introduction of such evidence.

The court determined that the absence of a written report did not constitute a breach of the rules if there was no intention to rely on such evidence at the time the request for trial date was filed. The court found that the plaintiff's intention to introduce this evidence was formed in response to a videotape produced by the defendants during the trial. The court further held that special leave was necessary under rule 548(4)(c) because the need for the evidence arose only during the trial in response to the videotape, which the defendants had not disclosed and had kept secret. The court granted leave under rule 548(4)(c) for the adduction of this evidence. Additionally, the court considered whether the evidence could be introduced under rule 427, which allows an expert to give evidence by report. The court concluded that the evidence could be introduced under rule 427(4)(b) as it related to issues that first emerged in the course of the trial.

The court overruled the objection and allowed the plaintiff to introduce oral evidence from Dr McKay.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.