O'Toole v M Johnson Building Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

O’Toole & Anor v M Johnson Building Pty Ltd (No 2)

Citation:

[2023] ACTSC 171

Hearing Date:

Decided on the papers

DecisionDate:

7 July 2023

Before:

Balla AJ

Decision:

(1)  Judgment for the plaintiffs against the first defendant in the sum of $269,982.66.

(2)  The first defendant to pay two thirds of the plaintiffs’ costs of the proceedings up to 20 April 2023 and 100 per cent of the plaintiffs’ costs thereafter. These costs are to be assessed on an indemnity basis.

Catchwords:

CIVIL LAW – BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION – apportionment – costs

Legislation Cited:

Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 141

Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW) s 5

Cases Cited:

Baxter v Obacelo (2001) 205 CLR 635

Hyblewski v Bellerive Homes Pty Ltd [2019] ACTSC 44

Parties:

Kate Mary O’Toole ( First Plaintiff)

Farooq Ahmed (Second Plaintiff)

M Johnson Building Propriety Ltd ( First Defendant)

Capital Certifiers Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

M Robens ( Plaintiffs)

J Masters ( First Defendant)

Solicitors

Harrington Hall Lawyers (Plaintiffs)

O’Connor Harris & Co ( First Defendant)

File Number:

SC 386 of 2021

BALLA AJ:

  1. On 19 May 2023 I delivered my findings as to liability and damages and noted the agreement between the plaintiffs and the builder as to the apportionment of responsibility for the damage under s 141 of the Building Act 2004 (ACT) being:

(a)  The first defendant, the builder, – 85 per cent.

(b)  The second defendant, the certifier – 15 per cent.

  1. A timetable was set for the parties to make submissions as to the mathematical outcome of my findings and costs, if agreement could not be reached.

  1. The parties have agreed that the mathematical outcome of my findings is, in total, $287,084.00.

  1. The parties cannot agree on how the agreed apportionment between the two defendants is to be applied to the sum of $287,084.00, nor on the appropriate Order for costs. They have provided written submissions in accordance with an agreed timetable.

  1. It is common ground that:

(a)  The builder was retained to build the house.

(b)  The second defendant was appointed the certifier of the project.

(c)   The parties have agreed on a schedule headed “Plaintiffs Calculation of Damages”. It summarises the findings I have previously made, describing the work to be done as items A-L with items A-D shown as being subject to the second defendant’s supervision as certifier. That schedule sets out the amount calculated in accordance with my findings in respect of each item. As I have said the total is $287,084.00. The amount payable by the builder, after taking into account the 15 per cent payable by the second defendant for Items A-D is $269,982.66.

(d)  The plaintiffs’ claim against the second defendant was settled before the hearing commenced. On 20th April 2023, judgment was entered for the plaintiffs against the second defendant in the sum of $200,000 inclusive of costs.

Apportionment

  1. Counsel for the builder submitted that the plaintiffs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Toole v M Johnson Building Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of O’Toole v M Johnson Building Pty Ltd (No 2) was before Balla AJ in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The plaintiffs, Kate Mary O’Toole and Farooq Ahmed, sought damages from the first defendant, the builder, and the second defendant, the certifier, for issues arising from the construction of their house. The primary dispute concerned the apportionment of damages and the associated costs between the defendants, following an agreement on the respective liabilities of 85% for the builder and 15% for the certifier under section 141 of the Building Act 2004 (ACT). The certifier settled with the plaintiffs before the hearing, leading to further contention over the impact of this settlement on the builder’s liability and the calculation of costs.

The court had to determine the correct application of the agreed apportionment of liability to the total damages of $287,084.00, and resolve the issue of costs. The builder argued that the settlement with the certifier should reduce the amount recoverable from them, while the plaintiffs maintained that the agreed apportionment should be applied without considering the settlement. Additionally, the court needed to decide on the appropriate basis for awarding costs, with the plaintiffs arguing for an indemnity basis due to the builder's conduct.

In delivering the decision, Balla AJ found that the apportionment of liability under section 141 of the Building Act was to be applied to the total damages as agreed, without reducing the builder's liability based on the settlement with the certifier. The court dismissed the builder’s argument that the settlement should affect the apportionment, emphasizing that the section only allows for apportionment between defendants found liable. The court also rejected the builder's contention that the plaintiffs might have double recovery, as there was no evidence to support this claim. Regarding costs, the court ordered that the builder should pay two-thirds of the plaintiffs' costs up to the date of the settlement with the certifier and 100% thereafter, on an indemnity basis.

The final orders included a judgment for the plaintiffs against the builder in the sum of $269,982.66, and mandated that the builder pay the plaintiffs' costs as outlined above. This decision ensures that the agreed apportionment of liability is faithfully applied and that the builder bears a fair share of the costs in line with their significant responsibility for the damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.