O'Neill v Commissioner for State Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

O’Neill v Commissioner for State Revenue [2019] QCAT 132

PARTIES:

PENELOPE O’NEILL
(applicant)

v

COMMISSIONER FOR STATE REVENUE

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR173-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

15 May 2019

HEARING DATE:

1 April 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member King-Scott

ORDERS:

The decision of the Commissioner for Sate Revenue to disallow the objection is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

TAXES AND DUTIES – LAND TAX – LIABILITY FOR LAND TAX – OTHER MATTERS – objections and appeals to land tax – Exemption as a Primary Producer – Cattle raising and bee keeping – business or hobby – failure to keep records

Land Tax Act 2010 (Qld)
Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld)

Evans v FCT (1989) 20 ATR 922
Ferguson v FCT [1979] 37 FLR 310

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

B Kabel for the Commissioner for Sate Revenue

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is an application by Ms Penelope O'Neill to review a decision of the Commissioner for Sate Revenue (‘the Commissioner’) to refuse her application for a primary production exemption from land tax.

    Background

  2. Ms O'Neill owns land situated at 767 New Cleveland Road, Gumdale more particularly described as Lot 5 on SP135919. A home exemption (from land tax) was previously applied to the property in conjunction with Lot 4 on SP135919 during the 2012-13, 2013-14 and 2014-15 financial years (the earlier period). From 30 June 2012, the Valuer-General issued separate valuations for Lots 4 and 5 on SP135919.

  3. Ms O'Neill was advised by the Commissioner 12 November 2014 that the home exemption would apply to only one parcel of land. She was prohibited thereby from claiming the home exemption in respect of the two lots. On 12 November 2014, the Commissioner issued reassessment for the earlier period to give effect to that decision.

  4. On 7 January 2015, Ms O'Neill lodged an objection with the Commissioner in respect of the removal of the home exemption. By letter dated 11 February 2015 the Commissioner disallowed the objection and confirmed her earlier decision of 12 November 2014. Ms O'Neill did not appeal that decision.

  5. On 11 August 2015 the Commissioner issued an assessment for land owned by Ms O'Neill as 30 June 2015. On 30 January 2017 and assessment was issued for land owned by Ms O'Neal as 30 June 2016.

  6. By email dated 28 April 2017, Ms O'Neill lodged a Form LT 11- Land Tax Exemption- land used for the business of agriculture, pasturage or dairy farming, seeking an exemption from land tax (the primary production exemption) in relation to the property.

  7. The Commissioner sought further information from Ms O'Neill before determining the application for exemption. That information was provided.[1]

    [1]See Tab 51 Book 1.

  8. An assessment was issued by the Commissioner on 15 August 2017 for land owned by Ms O'Neill as at 30 June 2007.

  9. By letter dated 21 August 2017 Commissioner notified Ms O'Neill that her claim for primary production exemption on the property was disallowed.

  10. Ms O'Neill, by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Neill v Commissioner for State Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of O’Neill v Commissioner for State Revenue, Ms Penelope O’Neill sought a review of the Commissioner for State Revenue's decision to deny her application for a primary production exemption from land tax. The Commissioner had disallowed Ms O’Neill's application for an exemption based on her activities related to cattle raising and bee keeping, asserting that these activities did not constitute a significant primary production business but were rather akin to a hobby. The dispute primarily hinged on whether the activities were commercial in nature or simply recreational.

The legal issues before the court included whether the new evidence presented by Ms O’Neill could be considered and, if so, whether her activities qualified for the primary production exemption under the Land Tax Act 2010 (Qld). The court also needed to determine if the Commissioner's decision was justified under the relevant statutory provisions and whether the evidence supported the characterization of Ms O’Neill’s activities as a business.

The Tribunal found that while the new evidence, including testimonials and letters, was not strictly compliant with procedural requirements, it did not significantly advance Ms O’Neill's case. The key issue remained the nature of her activities. The Tribunal concluded that the evidence did not substantiate that Ms O’Neill’s activities were of a commercial scale necessary to qualify for the primary production exemption. The number of cattle sales and the scale of bee keeping were insufficient to meet the threshold for a commercial business. Therefore, the Tribunal confirmed the Commissioner's decision to disallow the objection.

As a result of the Tribunal's decision, the Commissioner for State Revenue's decision to disallow the objection was upheld. This meant that Ms O’Neill remained liable for land tax on the property in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the Commissioner for Sate Revenue to disallow the objection is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by Ms Penelope O'Neill to review a decision of the Commissioner for Sate Revenue (‘the Commissioner’) to refuse her application for a primary production exemption from land tax. Background Ms O'Neill owns land situated at 767 New Cleveland Road, Gumdale more particularly described as Lot 5 on SP135919. A home exemption (from land tax) was previously applied to the property in conjunction with Lot 4 on SP135919 during the 2012-13, 2013-14 and 2014-15 financial years (the earlier period). From 30 June 2012, the Valuer-General issued separate valuations for Lots 4 and 5 on SP135919. Ms O'Neill was advised by the Commissioner 12 November 2014 that the home exemption would apply to only one parcel of land. She was prohibited thereby from claiming the home exemption in respect of the two lots. On 12 November 2014, the Commissioner issued reassessment for the earlier period to give effect to that decision. On 7 January 2015, Ms O'Neill lodged an objection with the Commissioner in respect of the removal of the home exemption. By letter dated 11 February 2015 the Commissioner disallowed the objection and confirmed her earlier decision of 12 November 2014. Ms O'Neill did not appeal that decision. On 11 August 2015 the Commissioner issued an assessment for land owned by Ms O'Neill as 30 June 2015. On 30 January 2017 and assessment was issued for land owned by Ms O'Neal as 30 June 2016. By email dated 28 April 2017, Ms O'Neill lodged a Form LT 11- Land Tax Exemption- land used for the business of agriculture, pasturage or dairy farming, seeking an exemption from land tax (the primary production exemption) in relation to the property. The Commissioner sought further information from Ms O'Neill before determining the application for exemption. That information was provided.[1][1]See Tab 51 Book 1. An assessment was issued by the Commissioner on 15 August 2017 for land owned by Ms O'Neill as at 30 June 2007. By letter dated 21 August 2017 Commissioner notified Ms O'Neill that her claim for primary production exemption on the property was disallowed. Ms O'Neill, by email dated 15 October 2017, objected to the Commissioner's decision of 21 August 2017. The objection was not confined to the decision to refuse the primary production exemption but included objection to all the land tax payments she had been required to pay since 2012. The Commissioner refused to consider those objections unrelated to the refusal of primary production exemption on the basis that Ms O'Neill had not exercised her rights of appeal against the earlier decisions and was out of time. However, the Commissioner was prepared to consider the objection to the reassessments to the earlier period only to the extent that they were related to the primary production exemption. The principal issue to be determined by the Tribunal is whether the activities conducted by Ms O’Neill in relation to cattle raising and bee keeping constituted a business or was it just a hobby.Legislation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 71 of the Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld) provides for review by the Tribunal of a decision of the Commissioner on an objection. The review must be heard and decided by way of reconsideration of the evidence before the Commissioner when the decision was made unless the Tribunal considers that necessary in the interests of justice to allow new evidence. It must also decide the review in accordance with the same law that applied to the making of the original decision.New evidence A preliminary issue that arose in the course of the hearing was whether Ms O’Neill could rely upon references, testimonials and letters (new evidence) that were not available to the Commissioner when she made her decision. Counsel for the Commissioner did not object to the Tribunal receiving the documents but objected to the documents being considered by the Tribunal in reaching its decision as the material constituted new evidence but, in any event, it was submitted that the evidence was of little value and should not be given much weight. Further, this material was not reduced to statements in accordance with the directions of the Tribunal. Counsel for the Commissioner did not request the authors to be available for cross-examination.[2][2]Transcript 1-14 line 1. The material comprises: (a)a signed letter from Brad Maidmant, a neighbour, dated 10 August 2018. He states that he has known Ms O’Neill and her daughter since 2000 and over that period he considers that they have raised and sold over 30 or so calves in that time;(b)a signed letter from Valley Hay Supplies Pty Ltd dated 10 August 2018. The author states that he has known Ms O’Neill since 2012 and has provided hay to the property since 2014 and confirms that she keeps calves;(c)a handwritten letter dated 21 August 2018 from West Morton Stock Feeds. The author states that he has known Ms O’Neill since 2005 and she has raised calves and kept cattle since that time;(d)a signed letter from Franz Ripphausen dated 21 August 2018. He has known Ms O’Neill since 2009 and states that since that time she has raised numerous calves at the property and sold a lot of calves during that time. He has also made bee boxes for Ms O’Neill;(e)An unsigned letter from Ross Newman, a Veterinary Surgeon, who states that he has visited the property since 2009 (on 9 occasions) for multiple livestock related reasons including calf husbandry procedures;(f)A signed letter from Mr Russell Zabel of Australian Stingless Native Bees. He is an authority on native bee keeping and says he has visited Ms O’Neill’s property and noted that she kept 10 hives which he considered was far in excess of a hobbyist who may only keep one or two hives. This material does not comply with the Directions given by the Tribunal on 9 August 2018, however, I agree with Counsel for the Commissioner that the information contained in the letters and testimonials are broad and non-specific. They do not advance Ms O’Neill’s case to any great degree. Respondent’s submissions

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 53 of the Land Tax Act 2010 (Qld) provides an exemption for land or the part of the land that is used solely for the business of agriculture, pasturage or dairy farming.The Commissioner's decision The Commissioner refused to grant the primary production exemption on the property because she could not be satisfied the land was being used to undertake a ‘significant primary production business as at 30 June 2016’. The Commissioner noted that even though Ms O'Neill had native bees on her property, the honey production and number of hives appeared to fall below commercial produce numbers. The Commissioner was of the view that the business of beekeeping on the property was more akin to a hobby. Further, it was noted that there were no cattle sales during ‘2015 and 2016’ and in the previous years for 2012, 2013 and 2014 there were minimal sales of cattle. Review Section 71 of the Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld) provides for review by the Tribunal of a decision of the Commissioner on an objection. The review must be heard and decided by way of reconsideration of the evidence before the Commissioner when the decision was made unless the Tribunal considers that necessary in the interests of justice to allow new evidence. It must also decide the review in accordance with the same law that applied to the making of the original decision.New evidence A preliminary issue that arose in the course of the hearing was whether Ms O’Neill could rely upon references, testimonials and letters (new evidence) that were not available to the Commissioner when she made her decision. Counsel for the Commissioner did not object to the Tribunal receiving the documents but objected to the documents being considered by the Tribunal in reaching its decision as the material constituted new evidence but, in any event, it was submitted that the evidence was of little value and should not be given much weight. Further, this material was not reduced to statements in accordance with the directions of the Tribunal. Counsel for the Commissioner did not request the authors to be available for cross-examination.[2][2]Transcript 1-14 line 1. The material comprises: (a)a signed letter from Brad Maidmant, a neighbour, dated 10 August 2018. He states that he has known Ms O’Neill and her daughter since 2000 and over that period he considers that they have raised and sold over 30 or so calves in that time;(b)a signed letter from Valley Hay Supplies Pty Ltd dated 10 August 2018. The author states that he has known Ms O’Neill since 2012 and has provided hay to the property since 2014 and confirms that she keeps calves;(c)a handwritten letter dated 21 August 2018 from West Morton Stock Feeds. The author states that he has known Ms O’Neill since 2005 and she has raised calves and kept cattle since that time;(d)a signed letter from Franz Ripphausen dated 21 August 2018. He has known Ms O’Neill since 2009 and states that since that time she has raised numerous calves at the property and sold a lot of calves during that time. He has also made bee boxes for Ms O’Neill;(e)An unsigned letter from Ross Newman, a Veterinary Surgeon, who states that he has visited the property since 2009 (on 9 occasions) for multiple livestock related reasons including calf husbandry procedures;(f)A signed letter from Mr Russell Zabel of Australian Stingless Native Bees. He is an authority on native bee keeping and says he has visited Ms O’Neill’s property and noted that she kept 10 hives which he considered was far in excess of a hobbyist who may only keep one or two hives.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.