O & L

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2005] FamCA 1233

FAMILY LAW ACT 1975

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY  FILE NO SYF 438 of 1999

BETWEEN O
[Applicant mother]
AND L
[Respondent father]
Date of Hearing: 15 September 2005
Date of Judgment: 22 December 2005

JUDGMENT OF THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BOLAND

APPEARANCES:

Mr Bell, of Counsel, instructed by Rita Thakur & Associates [of Unit 2, 107 Church Street Wollongong NSW 2520] appeared on behalf of the applicant mother.

Mr Cumming, agent, instructed by Kells [of DX 5162 Wollongong] appeared on behalf of the respondent father.

INTRODUCTION

  1. These proceedings have had an extended history before me.  In November 2003 I heard an application by the mother to re-hear residence proceedings.  Originally O’Ryan J had dealt with competing residence applications in May and June 2000 and determined that the two children of the marriage should live with the father and have contact with the mother.  The mother’s application before me was conducted on the threshold issue of whether or not there had been a substantial or significant change to warrant the re-hearing of competing residence applications.  I dismissed the mother’s application.  Subsequently the father sought an order for costs in respect of the proceedings before me, and after submissions on 24 February 2004 I delivered ex tempore reasons about that application (“the costs judgment”).  There was disagreement between the parties about the interpretation of my costs orders, and after further written submissions on 2 June 2005 I delivered written reasons relating to the costs judgment and orders (“the supplementary costs judgment”).

  2. In October 2004 the father filed an Application in a Case seeking the issue of order for a costs assessment in the sum of approximately $19,000. At the time of hearing the father’s application, I was advised from the bar table that criminal charges had been brought against the father, and that the children of the marriage were subject of an order under the Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1989 (NSW), but there was no admissible evidence of these matters before me.

  3. In my supplementary costs judgment I said in paragraph 22:

    “No formal application has been made to the Court for a stay of the costs order made on 24 February 2004.  It is open to the mother to do so at any time and to support her application with evidence.  Absent any formal application to relist this matter or the filing of an Application in a Case seeking a stay I do not find I can deal with the submissions made by Mr Bell on behalf of the mother absent any admissible evidence to support his submission”. 

  4. On 28 June 2005 the mother filed an Application in a Case.  That application has, by consent, been adjourned on several occasions and was finally heard by me on 15 September 2005 when Mr Bell of counsel made submissions on behalf of the mother, and Mr Cumming as Agent for the father’s solicitors, made submissions on behalf of the husband.

  5. The dispute in issue as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O & L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FamCA 1233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Family Court of Australia heard an application by the mother seeking a stay of costs orders made against her. The dispute arose from previous proceedings concerning the residence of the parties' two children, which had been determined in favour of the father. Following those substantive proceedings, the father sought and was awarded costs. The mother's current application sought to permanently stay these costs orders, or alternatively, to stay them pending an application for an extension of time to appeal the costs orders, or until the expiry of a care order made under the *Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1989* (NSW).

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether Justice Boland was *functus officio*, meaning whether he had discharged his duty and no longer had authority to alter or set aside his previous costs orders. If the Court found he was *functus officio*, the only avenue for the mother to challenge the costs order would be through an appeal to the Full Court, potentially requiring an extension of time. The secondary issue was whether, in the circumstances, the Court should exercise its inherent jurisdiction to grant a stay of the costs order pending a potential appeal.

Justice Boland reasoned that the costs order made on 24 February 2004, and subsequent supplementary costs orders, were final determinations of the costs application. He referred to *Kazimierczak & Koch* (1987) FLC 91-849, which established that in the Family Court, the power to award costs is statutory and limitations are found within the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth). As the costs application was considered a matrimonial cause under s 4(1)(f) of the Act and had been determined, the Court found itself *functus officio* regarding the ability to set aside or vary the costs order. Consequently, the Court considered the mother's application for a stay pending a foreshadowed application for an extension of time to appeal. Applying principles from cases such as *Commission of Taxation v The Commonwealth of Australia and the Meyer Emporium Limited* (1986) and *Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation* (1987), the Court noted that a stay is an exceptional remedy requiring special circumstances to prevent an appeal from being nugatory. Despite the mother's reliance on events occurring after the costs order, including care orders for the children, the Court found that the material presented did not demonstrate a sufficient basis to exercise its inherent jurisdiction to grant a stay prior to any formal application for an extension of time to appeal being made and considered by the Full Court.

The mother's application filed on 28 June 2005 was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established