O’Hara and Comcare (Compensation) [2024] AATA 422 (13 March 2024)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2023/0577
Re:Damon O’Hara
APPLICANT
ComcareAnd
RESPONDENT
INTERLOCUTORY DECISION
Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member
Date:13 March 2024
Place:Canberra
The decision under review is affirmed.
………………[SGD]……………………
Mr S. Webb, Member
Catchwords
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – compensation for injury – review of past rehabilitation program – utility – purchase of electronic application subscriptions – claim for reimbursement of costs – insufficient evidence to include application subscriptions in rehabilitation program – decision affirmed
Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s 42B, 43
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 16, 36, 37, 39Cases
O’Hara and Comcare [2023] AATA 3824
Mr S. Webb, Member
13 March 2024
Damon O’Hara claimed compensation for work-related injuries. Comcare accepted liability and paid him compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (SRC Act). Mr O’Hara was assessed for rehabilitation purposes and engaged in a rehabilitation program. Mr O’Hara challenged the effectiveness and utility of the rehabilitation program and he made several applications for review by the Tribunal. A number of jurisdictional and technical issues arose.
This application is for review of a Comcare reconsideration decision[1] to affirm a determination of the rehabilitation authority, the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Department), on 26 September 2022 requiring Mr O’Hara to undertake a rehabilitation program (Rehabilitation Program). [2] These decisions required Mr O’Hara to undertake a rehabilitation program determined for the purposes of s 37(1) of the SRC Act following an assessment under s 36 of that Act.
[1] T1.1.
[2] T5
In the course of the Tribunal proceedings, the rehabilitation program came to an end. Comcare applied for dismissal of the proceedings on utility grounds under s 42B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act). I dealt with these matters in O’Hara and Comcare [2023] AATA 3824 (Interlocutory Decision). The question of utility could not be dealt with to finality on the materials then available.
Additional materials have now been given to the Tribunal. The parties have made submissions in respect of relevant matters, and each has been given a reasonable opportunity to present their respective case. The issue of utility and the merit of Mr O’Hara’s application can now be determined.
As will appear, I am not persuaded the application lacks utility to the extent it has no reasonable prospect of success. There is relevant and potentially probative material before the Tribunal which requires careful examination and analysis.
The central issue raised by Mr O’Hara’s application which remains to be determined relates to subscriptions he purchased and his assertion these should be included in the rehabilitation program under review.
Facts
Many of the background facts were set out in the Interlocutory Decision. Insofar as they are relevant, I adopt those facts. These and other relevant background facts established by the materials before the Tribunal follow.
Mr O’Hara has accepted compensation claims in respect of post-traumatic stress…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read O’Hara and Comcare (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] AATA 422
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the electronic application subscriptions, specifically a sleep monitoring app, health tracking apps, and language training software, were reasonably and appropriately included as part of Mr O’Hara’s rehabilitation program. This required the Tribunal to consider the definition of a "rehabilitation program" under the SRC Act and the factors to be taken into account when determining such a program, as outlined in section 37(3) of the Act.
The Tribunal reasoned that while the SRC Act defines "rehabilitation program" broadly to include various medical and vocational services, the inclusion of specific items requires sufficient probative evidence. In this instance, there was no medical evidence to support the necessity of a sleep monitoring app for Mr O’Hara's PTSD, nor was there evaluative evidence regarding the efficacy of the language training software for improving his employment prospects or rehabilitation. The Tribunal emphasised that the low cost of the subscriptions or the injured employee's views alone were insufficient grounds for their inclusion. The decision-maker must be satisfied of the reasonableness and appropriateness of such inclusions by considering all relevant matters under section 37(3) of the SRC Act.
Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. It found that Mr O’Hara had not provided sufficient evidence to establish a reasonable basis for including the electronic application subscriptions within his rehabilitation program, despite the substantive issue warranting a full determination rather than dismissal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Comcare contends Dr Ryan did not refer to a sleep monitoring app and there is no medical evidence Mr O’Hara requires a sleep monitoring app in relation to his PTSD. Comcare asserts no evidence has been provided to support Mr O’Hara’s assertion that the sleep app should be considered as rehabilitation and not as medical treatment. Without further medical evidence, Comcare argues there is no basis for the Tribunal to find that the sleep app ought to have been included in the rehabilitation program.Consideration The phrase ‘rehabilitation program’ is given a broad and inclusive meaning in s 4(1) the SRC Act:rehabilitation program includes medical, dental, psychiatric and hospital services (whether on an in‑patient or out‑patient basis), physical training and exercise, physiotherapy, occupational therapy and vocational training. On review, for the purposes of determining a rehabilitation program an injured employee is obligated to undertake under s 37(1) of the SRC Act, the Tribunal must make factual findings in respect of the matters set out in s 37(3) and determine the matter on the available evidence. The matters set out in s 37(3) of the SRC Act are: In making a determination under subsection (1), a rehabilitation authority shall have regard to:(a) any written assessment given under subsection 36(8);(b) any reduction in the future liability to pay compensation if the program is undertaken;(c) the cost of the program;(d) any improvement in the employee’s opportunity to be employed after completing the program;(e) the likely psychological effect on the employee of not providing the program;(f) the employee’s attitude to the program;(g) the relative merits of any alternative and appropriate rehabilitation program; and(h) any other relevant matter. These matters must be considered. I note the written assessment under s 36(8) in respect of a suitable rehabilitation program for Mr O’Hara to undertake does not illuminate with any specificity reasons to include the particular subscriptions in the rehabilitation program under review. Even though in this case the individual and collective costs of the subscriptions Mr O’Hara wants included in the rehabilitation program under review are small, the contents of the rehabilitation program cannot be determined on the basis of low cost and the views of the injured employee alone. The decision-maker must be satisfied it is reasonable and appropriate to include these items in the rehabilitation program. Satisfaction hinges on consideration of all relevant matters, including the matters set out in s 37(3) of the SRC Act, and relevant probative evidence. With regard to the Duolingo Plus subscription, there is no evaluative evidence of the likely efficacy of the subscription Mr O’Hara purchased in a language training or rehabilitation context. Mr O’Hara’s assertion the Duolingo Plus language training will improve his employment prospects is not supported by other evidence. The general proposition that language training might assist Mr O’Hara’s employment prospects and his rehabilitation is not a sufficient reason to include the Duolingo Plus subscription in the rehabilitation program. More is required to establish a reasonable basis for doing so. There is no relevant probative evidence addressing this point. The extent to which, if at all, the Duolingo Plus subscription might improve Mr O’Hara’s employment prospects is unknown. There is also no evidence addressing the relative merits of alternatives to the subscription or any reduction in the future liability to pay compensation should it be included in the rehabilitation program.