O'Donnell and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

O'Donnell and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) [2016] AATA 861 (31 October 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/3679

Re

John O'Donnell

APPLICANT

And

K & S Freighters Pty Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms J C Kelly, Senior Member,
Dr Saw Hooi Toh, Member,
Dr L. Bygrave, Member

Date 31 October 2016
Place Sydney
  1. The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision of 25 June 2012 and substitutes for that decision, the decision that:

    (a)As at 20 March 2012, the respondent was liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009.

    (b)As at the date of this decision, the respondent is liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009. This decision has effect from the date of the Tribunal’s decision.

    (c)The respondent is liable to pay the cost of CT Guided Right C7 Perineural Injection given by Dr Ives on 4 April 2012.

  2. The Tribunal will grant the parties liberty to apply within seven days in respect of the question of costs. If no application is made within that time, the Tribunal will make the order that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings.

    ..................................[sgd]......................................

    Ms J C Kelly, Senior Member

    CATCHWORDS

    COMPENSATION – remittal from Federal Court of Australia – applicant suffered right shoulder condition – whether respondent liable under ss 16 and 19 of Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – whether Tribunal can make findings as to applicant’s entitlement to compensation at the date of its own decision – whether Tribunal limited to findings made at the date of the first tier decision – whether decision of Federal Court confines the Tribunal’s consideration of causation issue – Tribunal decided not to confine review of the proceedings – decision set aside

    LEGISLATION

    Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 25(4A), 27, 33(1), 43, 44(6)

    Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 14, 16, 19, 64, 66

    CASES

    Australian Telecommunications Corporation v Davis (1991) 30 FCR 467

    Comcare v Lofts (2013) 217 FCR 220

    Lees v Comcare (1999) 56 ALD 84

    Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Wang (2003) 215 CLR 518

    Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

    Smith v Comcare (2014) 64 AAR 205

    REASONS FOR DECISION

    Ms J C Kelly, Senior Member,
    Dr Saw Hooi Toh, Member,
    Dr L. Bygrave, Member

    Introduction

  3. This matter concerns claims for compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) for injuries suffered in an accident that occurred on 15 October 2009. Liability was accepted under section 14 of the SRC Act to pay compensation in respect of injuries to the applicant’s left leg, left groin, right shoulder, and right wrist, arising from the accident that occurred on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Donnell and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 861
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr O'Donnell against K & S Freighters Pty Limited for compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act) for a right shoulder condition. The case was remitted from the Federal Court of Australia to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for redetermination. The core dispute revolved around the extent of the Tribunal's review powers and whether it was confined by previous findings or limited to the date of an earlier decision.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether it was limited to the findings made at the date of the first tier decision, or if it could make its own findings as to the applicant's entitlement to compensation at the date of its own decision. A further issue was whether the decision of the Federal Court confined the Tribunal's consideration of the causation issue. The Tribunal considered whether it was appropriate to confine its review of the proceedings, particularly in light of new evidence and the fact that the previous decision had been set aside.

The Tribunal reasoned that it was not confined by the previous decision or the Federal Court's directions. It noted that the Federal Court had not made any specific directions limiting the AAT's hearing, and there was no agreement between the parties regarding the acceptance of prior findings. The Tribunal emphasised that it was exercising its jurisdiction under the SRC Act and had received new medical evidence not previously considered. It also highlighted that arrangements had been made for three medical practitioners to give concurrent evidence, indicating a comprehensive review of the evidence was intended.

The Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision of 25 June 2012. It substituted a decision that, as at 20 March 2012 and as at the date of the Tribunal's decision, the respondent was liable to pay the applicant compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury. The Tribunal also ordered the respondent to pay the cost of a specific medical procedure and granted the parties liberty to apply within seven days regarding the question of costs, otherwise ordering the respondent to pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision of 25 June 2012 and substitutes for that decision, the decision that:

(a) As at 20 March 2012, the respondent was liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009.

(b) As at the date of this decision, the respondent is liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009. This decision has effect from the date of the Tribunal’s decision.

(c) The respondent is liable to pay the cost of CT Guided Right C7 Perineural Injection given by Dr Ives on 4 April 2012.

2. The Tribunal will grant the parties liberty to apply within seven days in respect of the question of costs. If no application is made within that time, the Tribunal will make the order that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant in this case suffered a right shoulder condition following an incident on 15 October 2009. The injury was documented by Dr Wong on the day of the accident, who recorded that the applicant had injured his left knee and shoulder but noted pain to his left groin. The incident report also records that the applicant injured his left knee, left groin, right shoulder, and right wrist. The applicant was referred to Dr Hollands for his left groin pain, but the predominant injuries were recorded as being to his left knee and left shoulder. The applicant subsequently underwent treatment for his right shoulder condition, which included consultations with several doctors and medical specialists, as well as several medical reports and statements. The Tribunal had access to extensive documentation, including medical records, reports from various specialists, and statements from the applicant and other medical practitioners. The evidence before the Tribunal included 408 pages of documents, statements from the applicant, and reports from several medical practitioners.

This case was remitted from the Federal Court of Australia back to the original tribunal for reconsideration. The Federal Court had previously set aside a decision made by the first tribunal. The remittal did not come with any specific directions from the Federal Court that would confine the tribunal’s review of the proceedings. The tribunal was exercising its jurisdiction under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. New evidence, including additional medical evidence, was presented to the tribunal that had not been available to the first tribunal. Several medical practitioners were also available to give concurrent oral evidence before the tribunal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal notes that Wang concerned the Refugee Review Tribunal which is constituted pursuant to the Migration Act 1958, but accepts the applicant’s submission that this Tribunal has the power to limit its review in appropriate cases. The Tribunal does not consider that this is such a case for the following reasons. The decision of the first Tribunal has been set aside. The Federal Court has not made any direction pursuant to section 44(4) or (5) of the AAT Act that confines this Tribunal’s hearing. There is nothing in his Honour’s decision to suggest that the respondent submitted that such a direction should be made. There is no agreement between the parties about findings made by the first Tribunal that this Tribunal should accept. The Tribunal is exercising its jurisdiction pursuant to the SRC Act. New evidence, including medical evidence is before the Tribunal which was not before the first Tribunal, and arrangements had been made for three medical practitioners to give concurrent evidence before the Tribunal. Consideration of the evidence The evidence before the Tribunal The evidence before the Tribunal included the 408 pages of documents provided to the first Tribunal pursuant to section 37 of the AAT Act (the T documents), four statements made by the applicant and his oral evidence, five reports from Dr Giblin, Orthopaedic Surgeon, four reports from Dr Maxwell, Orthopaedic and Spinal Surgeon, three reports from Dr Stephenson, Orthopaedic Surgeon, a report from Dr Duckworth, Shoulder and Elbow Surgeon, and selected material summonsed from him, selected documents summonsed from Dr McMaster, selected clinical notes of Dr Wong, the applicant’s treating General Practitioner, a Workplace Progress Report dated 5 March 2012, and the transcript of the hearing before the first Tribunal. The Tribunal also had the benefit of Doctors Giblin, Maxwell and Stephenson giving concurrent oral evidence. The Tribunal has taken into account the statements of facts, issues and contentions filed by both parties and their written and oral submissions.The history of the applicant’s right shoulder condition The following information is derived from contemporaneous documentation before the Tribunal, apart from clinical notes. It is a summary of the history of the applicant’s right shoulder condition, including treatment, his claimed symptoms, doctors’ opinions and findings on examination, work restrictions and his reaction to his condition. Dr Wong recorded in the Medical Certificate he issued on the day of the accident, 15 October 2009, that the applicant had injured his “left knee & shoulder but after noted pain to left groin”. The incident report completed by the “Supervisor/Manager” and stamped “16 October 2009” records that the applicant injured his “left knee and groin and right shoulder and right wrist”. The applicant was referred to Doctor Hollands, Gastrointestinal, Hepatobiliary and Laparoscopic Surgeon in relation to pain in his left groin. Doctor Hollands recorded that the applicant’s “predominant injuries were to his left knee and left shoulder”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the evidence before the Tribunal, it finds that on 20 March 2012 and as of the date of its decision, the respondent was and is liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009. Decision The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and substitutes for that decision, the decision that:(a)As at 20 March 2012, the respondent was liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009. (b)As at the date of this decision, the respondent is liable to pay the applicant compensation pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 16 and section 19, in respect of the accepted right shoulder injury suffered on 15 October 2009. This decision has effect from the date of the Tribunal’s decision. (c)The respondent is liable to pay the cost of CT Guided Right C7 Perineural Injection given by Dr Ives on 4 April 2012 pursuant to section 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. Given the Tribunal’s decision, it follows that it is appropriate that the Tribunal order the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings. However, the Tribunal will grant the parties liberty to apply within seven days if that order is opposed. If no application is made within that time, the Tribunal will make the order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the issue of whether the respondent is liable under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for the applicant's right shoulder condition. It found that the evidence, including new medical evidence and the oral testimony of medical practitioners, supported the conclusion that the respondent was liable to pay compensation for the applicant's condition. The court noted that the first Tribunal's decision had been set aside and there were no constraints from the Federal Court's decision that would limit the Tribunal's review of the causation issue.

Regarding the Tribunal's ability to make findings as to the applicant’s entitlement to compensation at the date of its own decision, the court held that the Tribunal has the discretion to determine the applicant's entitlement based on the evidence presented to it. The court reasoned that the Tribunal is exercising its jurisdiction pursuant to the SRC Act and has new evidence that was not available to the first Tribunal.

The court further addressed the issue of whether the Tribunal is limited to findings made at the date of the first tier decision. It concluded that the Tribunal is not confined to such findings and can make its own determinations based on the evidence before it. The court emphasised that the first Tribunal's decision had been set aside and there were no agreements between the parties that would restrict the Tribunal's findings.

Lastly, the court examined whether the decision of the Federal Court confines the Tribunal’s consideration of the causation issue. The court found that the Federal Court's decision did not impose any restrictions on the Tribunal's review of the causation issue. It reasoned that the Federal Court had not made any direction pursuant to section 44(4) or (5) of the AAT Act and there was no suggestion that such a direction should be made. Therefore, the Tribunal was free to consider the causation issue based on the evidence presented to it.