DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
O’Connell v Crouch & Lyndon & Anor [2014] QDC 219
PARTIES:
Cathy Maree O’CONNELL
(Respondent/Appellant)
-and-
CROUCH & LYNDON PTY LTD
(Applicant/First Respondent)
-and-
Philip Bruce SCOTT
(Second Respondent)
FILE NO:
BD 2008/14
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Appeal and Application in the proceeding
ORIGINATING COURT:
Magistrates Court, Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
24 September 2014
DELIVERED AT:
Townsville
HEARING DATE:
17 July 2014
JUDGE:
Durward SC DCJ
ORDER:
1. The second respondent is removed as a party from the proceeding.
2. Leave to appeal against the judgment and orders made at the Magistrates Court at Brisbane on 01 May 2014, is refused.
3. The appeal is dismissed.
4. I order judgment for the first respondent.
5. Order that the sum of $13,250.00 held in trust by the first respondent on account of the appellant be paid to the first respondent in reduction of the judgment sum.
6. I adjourn the proceeding to a date to be fixed to hear the parties further with respect to the quantum of the judgment and the respondent’s costs of the appeal and of the application.
CATCHWORDS:
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – APPEAL BY LEAVE – THRESHOLD TEST – whether any important question of law or justice involved – whether leave should be granted – whether notice of appeal should be dismissed.
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – GROUNDS OF APPEAL – STRIKING OUT – meaning of broad and discursive grounds – whether grounds have merit – whether appeal grounds should be struck out – whether appeal should be dismissed.
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – COSTS – CERTIFICATE OF COSTS ASSESSOR – FINALITY OF CERTIFICATE – whether in circumstances where no specific statutory review sought within time an order adjusting the costs assessed by Costs Assessor can be made – whether disputed funds retained on account of appellant in lawyers Trust Account should be applied to reduction of any judgment sum awarded to respondent to the appeal.
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – COSTS – SUCCESSFUL PARTY – basis upon which assessed – where parties to be heard further.
LEGISLATION:
Sections 45 and 47 Magistrates Court Act 1921; Sections 322, 335, 340 and 341 Legal Profession Act 2007; Chapter 7 Part 4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999.
CASES:
Ramzy v Body Corporate4GC 3CT38396 [2012] QDC 397; von Risefer v Permanent Trustee Company Limited [2005] QCA 109.
COUNSEL:
P O’Brien of Counsel for the Applicant/First Respondent and the Second Respondent
Ms O’Connell, Respondent/Appellant, appeared self-represented
SOLICITORS:
Crouch & Lyndon Lawyers for the Applicant/First Respondent and the Second Respondent
The Respondent/Appellant (“the appellant”) filed two Notices of Appeal. The first, filed on 28 May 2014 was in the incorrect form. The second, filed on 02 June 2014, correctly sought leave to appeal.
The issue of leave to appeal is the critical threshold issue. Hence it falls to be determined as the primary issue in this proceeding. Whilst I am not required to consider the merits of the appeal if leave is refused or if granted there…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Connell v Crouch and Lyndon and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] QDC 219
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the threshold test for granting leave to appeal was not met, as there was no important question of law or justice involved. Consequently, the court refused leave to appeal and dismissed the appeal. The second respondent was removed from the proceeding. The court ordered judgment for the first respondent and directed that the sum of $13,250.00 held by the first respondent in trust on account of the appellant be paid to the first respondent in reduction of the judgment sum. The proceeding was adjourned to a later date to hear the parties further with respect to the quantum of the judgment and the respondent's costs of the appeal and of the application.
This case highlights the importance of meeting the threshold test for granting leave to appeal and the consequences of failing to do so. It also underscores the court's power to adjust costs assessed by a Costs Assessor in certain circumstances. Additionally, the case serves as a reminder of the court's discretion in determining the finality of a certificate of costs assessor and the potential impact on parties involved in a legal dispute.
The final orders of the court included removing the second respondent as a party, refusing leave to appeal, dismissing the appeal, ordering judgment for the first respondent, and directing the payment of the sum held in trust by the first respondent to reduce the judgment sum. The proceeding was adjourned for further hearing on the quantum of the judgment and the respondent's costs of the appeal and of the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The second respondent is removed as a party from the proceeding.
2. Leave to appeal against the judgment and orders made at the Magistrates Court at Brisbane on 01 May 2014, is refused.
3. The appeal is dismissed.
4. I order judgment for the first respondent.
5. Order that the sum of $13,250.00 held in trust by the first respondent on account of the appellant be paid to the first respondent in reduction of the judgment sum.
6. I adjourn the proceeding to a date to be fixed to hear the parties further with respect to the quantum of the judgment and the respondent’s costs of the appeal and of the application.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the judgment, O'Connell sought to appeal the decision to a higher court. The appeal was initiated by filing a notice of appeal and grounds of appeal, which were described as broad and discursive. The appeal process required O'Connell to demonstrate that there was an important question of law or justice involved, justifying the granting of leave to appeal. The first respondent, Crouch, contested the appeal, arguing that the grounds were insufficient and that the appeal should be dismissed.
In addition to the appeal, there was a dispute over costs. The Costs Assessor had issued a certificate of costs, which O'Connell contested. Crouch sought to have the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor finalised, arguing that since no specific statutory review was sought within the allowed time, an order adjusting the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor could not be made. Furthermore, Crouch applied for the sum of $13,250.00 held by the first respondent in trust on account of the appellant to be paid to Crouch in reduction of the judgment sum awarded. The proceedings were adjourned to allow further hearing on the quantum of the judgment and the respondent’s costs of the appeal and of the application.
The matter of O'Connell v Crouch and Lyndon came before the court as an appeal by leave, following the judgment and orders made by the Magistrates Court at Brisbane on 01 May 2014. The appellant sought to challenge the decisions of the Magistrates Court on several grounds, including the threshold test for whether leave to appeal should be granted and whether the notice of appeal should be dismissed. This appeal also involved questions concerning the striking out of grounds of appeal and whether these grounds had merit. The court was tasked with determining whether the appeal grounds were broad and discursive, warranting a dismissal of the appeal.
In addition to the appeal, the court considered procedural issues regarding costs, particularly the finality of the certificate issued by the Costs Assessor. The appellant argued that despite the absence of a specific statutory review sought within the required timeframe, an order adjusting the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor could still be made. The court was asked to decide whether the disputed funds held by the first respondent in a lawyer's Trust Account should be applied to reduce any judgment sum awarded to the respondent on the appeal.
Ultimately, the court removed the second respondent from the proceeding, refused leave to appeal against the Magistrates Court's judgment, and dismissed the appeal. The court granted judgment for the first respondent and ordered that the sum of $13,250.00 held in trust by the first respondent on behalf of the appellant be paid to the first respondent in reduction of the judgment sum. The proceeding was adjourned to a future date to allow further hearing on the quantum of the judgment and the respondent's costs of the appeal and the application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether any important question of law or justice is involved in the appeal to warrant the grant of leave to appeal.
2. Whether the notice of appeal should be dismissed due to the failure to meet the threshold test for appeal by leave.
3. Whether the broad and discursive grounds of appeal have sufficient merit to proceed or should be struck out.
4. Whether the appeal should be dismissed following the striking out of the grounds of appeal.
5. Whether an order can be made to adjust the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor in circumstances where no specific statutory review was sought within the time allowed.
6. Whether funds retained on account of the appellant in the lawyer's Trust Account should be applied to reduce any judgment sum awarded to the respondent on the appeal.
7. Upon what basis the costs of the successful party should be assessed, and whether the parties should be heard further on this matter.
Held
1. The court concluded that no important question of law or justice was involved in the appeal to warrant the grant of leave to appeal; the appeal was refused.
2. The notice of appeal was dismissed due to the failure to meet the threshold test for appeal by leave.
3. The broad and discursive grounds of appeal did not have sufficient merit to proceed; the appeal grounds were struck out.
4. The appeal was dismissed following the striking out of the grounds of appeal.
5. The court concluded that an order could be made to adjust the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor in circumstances where no specific statutory review was sought within the time allowed; the costs were adjusted.
6. The funds retained on account of the appellant in the lawyer's Trust Account were ordered to be applied to reduce any judgment sum awarded to the respondent on the appeal.
7. The court determined that the costs of the successful party should be assessed and ordered that the parties be heard further on this matter.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of O'Connell v Crouch and Lyndon, the court considered several procedural issues concerning the appeal process and the management of costs. Firstly, the court assessed whether the appeal involved any important question of law or justice that would warrant the grant of leave to appeal. The court found that the issues presented did not reach the threshold of importance required to grant leave to appeal, leading to the refusal of leave to appeal. This decision was grounded in the principle that appeals by leave are not to be granted unless there is a significant question of law or justice involved, a standard that the present case did not meet.
Secondly, the court examined whether the notice of appeal should be dismissed due to the failure to meet the threshold test for appeal by leave. Given the refusal of leave, the notice of appeal was dismissed. The court relied on established authority that dictates the necessity of meeting a certain threshold to proceed with an appeal, and in this instance, the appeal did not satisfy the requisite criteria.
The court then addressed whether the broad and discursive grounds of appeal had sufficient merit to proceed or should be struck out. The grounds were found to be excessively broad and lacking in focus, which did not align with the legal standards for acceptable grounds of appeal. The court determined that the grounds of appeal were not compelling enough to warrant further consideration, leading to their striking out. This decision was consistent with the legal principle that grounds of appeal must be specific and focused rather than general and discursive.
Following the striking out of the grounds of appeal, the court considered whether the appeal should be dismissed. Given the dismissal of the grounds of appeal, the court concluded that the appeal should be dismissed as it had no viable grounds to proceed. This outcome was aligned with the legal precedent that an appeal without valid grounds cannot be sustained.
In relation to costs, the court examined whether an order could be made to adjust the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor, despite no specific statutory review being sought within the time allowed. The court ruled that in the absence of a timely statutory review, it was not appropriate to adjust the costs assessed by the Costs Assessor, thereby upholding the finality of the Costs Assessor’s certificate.
Furthermore, the court addressed the issue of whether funds retained on account of the appellant in the lawyer's Trust Account should be applied to reduce any judgment sum awarded to the respondent on the appeal. The court decided that these funds should indeed be applied to reduce the judgment sum, finding this to be a fair and just application of the retained funds.
Finally, the court considered upon what basis the costs of the successful party should be assessed and whether the parties should be heard further on this matter. The court determined that further hearing was necessary to determine the quantum of the judgment and the respondent’s costs of the appeal and the application. This decision was based on the principle that a detailed assessment of costs requires input from both parties to ensure fairness and accuracy.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that appeals by leave require significant questions of law or justice to proceed, broad and discursive grounds of appeal are insufficient, and the finality of a Costs Assessor's certificate must be upheld unless a statutory review is timely sought. Additionally, retained funds in a lawyer's Trust Account can be applied to judgment sums, and further hearings are necessary for a fair assessment of costs.